Never really understood the "to be able to work from coffeeshops" argument. Actually we have an office, i have to commute to everyday but i love it far more than working on my own. I am achored to the office yeah, but its the place where i can get most done and talk to other engineers working on the same project.
Its not that having a Desktop disqualifies you from having a laptop aswell, so if i feel like it, i could still work from somewhere else. I like to have the best gear for every situation, so in the office having a workstation with 2x 24" screens and a MBA for on the road seems to be perfect for me. Dropbox makes syncing relativly painless.
Oh yeah the brain argument ;) Well people tend to work on different stuff. I am a game developer and apart from a huge IDE i also need to compile builds, test server & client on the same machine, view debugging/docs while running the builds etc. With only the Laptop screen its a major pita. For doing some web development its mostly fine though i guess.
The link between screen resolution and productivity is well established:
http://www.newscientist.com/blog/technology/2008/03/screen-s...
I have two screens sitting on my desk at home with bluetooth keyboard. Plug it in when I am at home with bluetooth keyboard, and laptop when I am away (although I usually always take my external mouse with me)
Perhaps that works for some people, but others (like myself) still differ. To each their own. :)
To add to that, I personally get no benefit from extra screens; maybe it takes a certain type of brain, but I'm able to visualize everything in my head very easily to the point where I can not be looking at a screen of text but still recall it all just fine. Having windows crammed onto a screen just isn't an issue for some of us. :)