News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by ShabbyDoo on Monday May 02, 2011 @04:59PM (#2507822)
This is what I submitted to the FDA:

----

I am angry that the FDA is considering limiting access to my own DNA. How is this within the scope of the FDA's authority? What is next? Will I be prevented from purchasing a glucose meter because I can not be trusted to know my own glucose levels? Maybe the FDA should outlaw the sale of blood pressure monitoring devices. After all, I might mis-interpret my own readings.

Here's what I suspect is really going on: The FDA is being pressured by the insurance industry to restrict consumers' access to their own DNA because of the information asymmetry between the government's preclusion of insurers ability to consider genetic data when determining eligibility and consumers' recently available ability to cheaply know if they have a predisposition for a variety of potentially expensive or life-limiting illnesses. That the FDA is likely pandering to this industry under the dishonest guise of consumer health protection makes me more distrustful of it as an independent entity.

----

If my suspicions are right, this is a perfect example of how regulation begets regulation. The insurance industry is right to be scared of this government-mandated information asymmetry and the potentially horrific impact it might have on profitability. Imagine that everyone who new he had a high propensity for a degenerative disease made a very rational choice to buy nursing home insurance. The insurance companies would have little alternative but to price their products based on the the probability that those who are genetically predisposed to such illnesses would comprise the risk pool. This would likely price out a huge portion of the US population and effectively shut down the entire product category.

If we allow the insurance industry to do its own genetic testing, we will effectively take away the ability for a huge swath of the population to purchase life, nursing home, or health insurance. The effect would be that the US government would be the de facto insurer through Medicaid and other wealth transfer programs. And, because those who would find themselves un-insurable would not be contributing any of their own money toward their likely future care needs, the insurable population would indirectly pick up the slack through increased taxation or more government borrowing.

So, what can be done? Before we had our children, I imagined purchasing meta-insurance -- insurance that my children would be insurable. I wanted to buy this insurance BEFORE conception. My rate would be a function of my wife and mine's DNA testing, her health status, and her adherence to pregnancy best practices (don't get drunk, etc.). If we were quoted a high rate because our future children were deemed high risk, we would have to consider the moral issues of knowingly producing a child which could have a life of suffering (adopt instead, use a sperm/egg donor, etc.).

What would this insurance cover? I haven't thought through the mechanics, but I would like for such a product to allow the purchase of various health-related insurance products at rates not dependent on my children's genetic make-up or current physical condition. I would also like a nursing home-esque provision which would pay out if my children ended-up having expensive needs. [My otherwise healthy five year-old Aspie costs us thousands a year in non-covered services (social skills group, etc.). I can't imagine having a kid with CP. etc.] Imagine having a kid with Downs' Syndrome. How much money would you need so that your lifestyle would be the same as if your kid was born healthy?

The insurance would be sold as follows: Upon receiving a price quote, I would obligate myself to purchase the insurance if we conceived a child which was born alive and lived for more than N months. The obligation aspect of the product is designed to prevent an obviously nasty selection bias effect.

So, why is this insurance not available? Current government regulations coupled with social welfare programs take away the incentives. Let's presume that, if the US because a libertarian-esque country that the majority of children born would not be insured in this way -- after all, we have lots of evidence that many parents can't even provide immediately necessary things for their children. [Note that I consider myself a weak libertarian.] And, let's presume that letting children suffer is politically unacceptable. What if the government effectively privatized a huge swath of its social welfare programs by offering this insurance for free -- genetic testing be damned. The effective future payment stream would not be much different than it is today because the government pays for poor sick people anyway. We could rid ourselves of many layers of regulation and allow the free market to do what it does best.

I am strangely hopeful that the availability of direct-to-consumer genetic data will necessitate such a change in the ways US citizens have to mitigate health-related risks. Unless we peel back the layers of regulation already in place and offer market-centric replacements for their intent, we will see more and more inefficient layers added over time.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by orangecat on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:30PM (#2507924)
Excellent post.

Before we had our children, I imagined purchasing meta-insurance -- insurance that my children would be insurable.

I've thought that should exist as well. It's similar to the concept of "health status insurance": http://www.cato.org/pub_display.php?pub_id=9986. Both ideas are fundamentally about restoring the actual meaning of the word "insurance", to provide protection against expensive and unlikely outcomes, not to cover minor and foreseeable expenses.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by ShabbyDoo on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:35PM (#2507943)
Thanks for the link. I had never actually read about this and did not know that the term "health status insurance" had been coined. It is depressing that so many regard US healthcare as a market failure when the reality is that regulation has done so much to hurt people.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by VladRussian on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:54PM (#2508405)
>It is depressing that so many regard US healthcare as a market failure when the reality is that regulation has done so much to hurt people.

unfortunately there is not enough regulation of the real kind - the insurance companies have been exempted from anti-trust law. Thus, because of missing regulation, there is no free competitive market of insurance in the US and thus it isn't a market failure.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by A1kmm on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:30PM (#2508188)
Is it really fair that a child's access to health insurance for the rest of its life depends on decisions parents made?

What your thought experiment really shows is that market based health insurance is hard to justify ethically, and that at least some level of health care should be paid for on a more equitable basis (such as through a public health system).

In addition, issues like information asymmetry mean that there is no happy medium between unregulated health insurance and a full public health system.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by ShabbyDoo on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:55PM (#2508409)
"Is it really fair that a child's access to health insurance for the rest of its life depends on decisions parents made?"

Probably not. This is why I suggested that it might be valid for the government to provide this meta-insurance to all children born. Your other statements are simply opinions without the associated effort of argumentation.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by Alex3917 on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:59PM (#2508058)
"Will I be prevented from purchasing a glucose meter because I can not be trusted to know my own glucose levels?"

Then again, the fact that you (apparently) don't know that home glucose meters are largely a hoax shows why they want to regulate DNA testing.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/19/health/policy/19monitor.ht...

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by TheEzEzz on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:58PM (#2508418)
This is exactly a situation where the FDA should step in. The FDA should make sure that people can trust what they are buying (when it pertains to health), not make sure that people don't have the choice in the first place.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by hammock on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @09:25AM (#2509833)
Actually there is another regulatory body called the FTC that does that.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by nollidge on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @09:21AM (#2509818)
That article doesn't even come close to saying that glucose meters are a hoax. It says that they're poorly regulated and fail far too often, which is much different from saying the principles they're based on are fraudulent, as is the case with the IED "detectors".

Glucose meters may be off by 20%, but you're still better off having one than not.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by ShabbyDoo on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:08PM (#2508101)
I am not so concerned about the regulation of DNA testing's quality as I am about availability of information.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by eru on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:23PM (#2508160)
Interesting find, but I don't know if it's applicable. He probably doesn't know too much about glucose meters, because he's not diabetic.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by Alex3917 on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:29PM (#2508185)
"He probably doesn't know too much about glucose meters, because he's not diabetic."

Seeing as glucose meters are basically only used by diabetics, your assumption that most diabetics would know that glucose meters are fraudulent seems empirically false.

Virtually all diabetics use glucose meters, despite the fact that they are basically the Iraqi IED detectors of medical hardware.

http://www.nytimes.com/2009/11/04/world/middleeast/04sensors...

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by bellaire on Monday May 02, 2011 @09:29PM (#2508628)
Virtually all studies (and there have been many) have shown that people with diabetes who use glucose meters regularly are at markedly reduced risk of complications than those who do not.

WRT the OP, unless you are advocating that the FDA should allow home genetics testing provided it is held to high standards, your analogy does not hold. As stated, it seems that you are implying that people would be better off without home glucose meters. a proposition that is demonstrably false.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by eru on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:55PM (#2508242)
> Seeing as glucose meters are basically only used by diabetics, your assumption that most diabetics would know that glucose meters are fraudulent seems empirically false.

I did not want to imply that assumption. I want to say that non-diabetics don't care about glucose meters enough, and he probably only brought it up for the sake of rhetorics.

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by noahl on Monday May 02, 2011 @05:35PM (#2507945)
I find your point about the information asymmetry between insurance companies and consumers extremely insightful. Here is another possible consequence.

Insurers might choose to protect themselves from this asymmetry by only offering very general medical insurance. Rather than insurance for specific conditions, such as cancer or nursing homes or anything that one might find out that one had a predisposition for, they would only offer insurance for "lack of health", or some similarly-broad language.

If they did that, lots of people would buy that insurance, because everyone has a legitimate risk of being unhealthy at some time, so you wouldn't get the situation where people with a genetic predisposition for a disease made up a disproportionate number of the people buying insurance for that disease.

That would also have great effects on the availability of good health insurance, because then insurers would have an incentive to cover a large number of conditions. (I know that this would probably not give large number of people good insurance. The insurance industry just sucks.)

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by ShabbyDoo on Monday May 02, 2011 @06:05PM (#2508079)
The problem I see is that, because such a low percentage of Americans purchase health-related insurance policies, even relatively small increases in propensity of those with diseases like Huntington's to buy-in would have huge impacts on the expected cost of an insurance company's policyholder pool.

According to this article, an individual can know with near certainty that he will become symptomatic with Huntington's disease in the future if certain genetic markers are present:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Huntingtons_disease

[I am clueless about most genetic diseases, btw]

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by sixcorners on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @02:01AM (#2509142)
The article that is linked to (http://www.genomicslawreport.com/index.php/2011/03/11/the-fd...) says that "Again, despite suggestions from many panelists that a clinician should be involved in the ordering and interpretation of the vast majority of genetic tests, there was no formal or binding recommendation to that effect from the MCGP. Nor will one be forthcoming. There is also no good reason to suspect that genetic tests which are currently available DTC without clinician involvement, some of which have remained available for nearly a year since the FDA first publicly announced its intention to regulate these tests as medical devices, are going to be yanked from the market by the FDA tomorrow." None of this is about limiting access to your own DNA.
Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by temphn on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @04:24AM (#2509366)
http://blogs.discovermagazine.com/gnxp/2011/03/your-genes-yo...

^ Watch that video. You don't even need to postulate insurance as the hidden hand behind this. In the span of four short minutes, FDA head honcho Jeffrey Shuren manages to commit perjury before Congress while explaining that "traditional manufacturers" will be helped by the new regulations. Who woulda thunk?

Truly blood boiling clip. The entire genomics blogosphere exploded over this guy back in March. No one has any idea why he's still employed.

Some links:

http://massdevice.com/news/fda-device-chief-under-fire-did-d...

http://www.technologyreview.com/blog/editors/26499/?p1=A4

http://reason.com/blog/2011/03/10/fda-regulation-of-direct-t...

http://www.fdablog.org/2011/03/controversy-grows-around-fdas...

http://johnhawks.net/weblog/topics/biotech/testing/fda-dtc-m...

http://www.genomesunzipped.org/2011/03/why-dtc-genetic-testi...

http://blogs.plos.org/genomeboy/2011/03/09/making-movies/

http://www.harappadna.org/2011/03/your-genes-regulated/

Re:Last chance: let the FDA know why you want direct access ... by barisme on Tuesday May 03, 2011 @12:04AM (#2508953)
We came up with the same metaphor. My post started with the glucose meter as well, and pointed out that misinterpreting blood glucose was more likely to have immediate and dire consequences.