Those are huge numbers. The problem is that the confidence interval is really wide.
quibble: non significant, wide confidence doesn't mean "small", it means _unknown_. It means the data is too sparse and/or too noisy to tell.
Of course since "everything is correlated" [0] expecting such truly simple signals might be nonsensical/pointless.
I was just lamenting the lack of simple magical treatments basically.
I can't quite tell by your summary whether you are saying "exercising is good, but the overall effect on mortality is small", or "exercising is good, and the effect of adding HIIT to baseline exercise is small".
You cannot make the former statement from this study as control group were not non-exercisers (and adherence was decent). The latter statement, does seem to be supported.
Regarding exercise in general, the literature shows the mortality gap between exercisers and non-exercisers is absolutely massive.
So, 1.7% vs 1.2% seems just above noise level. The OP is right, the numbers are not that impressive.
We are not talking about reducing overall mortality by double digits...
Summary: looks like exercising is good, and adding HIIT has an increasing effect of reducing mortality, but the overall effect is small.