Fines are a fast and easy political win against these "evil foreign tech giants". Just like rent seeking.
Bootstrapping an ecosystem capable of spawning and growing global market leaders is hard. And it would require some very unpopular measures.
- Weak/Non-Existent non-compete
- Make it easier to hire and fire employees
- Competitive approach to retaining talent
- Lower tax rate for tech companies instead of endless government grants/subsidies
The last one in particular is critical. In some EU countries, you can already justify your 5th employee's complete salary having a dedicated "accountant" whose only job is to apply for government grants.
The only way would be to completely block the GAFAMs (and their Russian and Chinese equivalents of course) from operating in the EU. Only then alternatives might actually be able to gain a foothold.
Why not simply compete? Europe sure has the brains, give them the freedom to use them!
But for the rest of us who live either outside that bubble or outside of the US in general, lots of good has come out of EU, even startups, that we rely on daily.
[1] https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/end-to-end-encryption-euro...
Also, since the EU cannot mandate a breakup of Google, how would this actually be framed?
What sort of other legislation could they do to push Google out of the way in a way that doesn't actively discriminate against Google but also applies to all companies (both inside and outside the EU)?