News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by lopis on Thursday November 12, 2020 @05:50AM (#25068536)
Exactly. Unfortunately GDPR failed to realize that most data companies hold about us is inferred. Data takeouts usually provide you with all data you willingly provided (uploads, reviews, likes, playlists, etc). But most interesting information is missing. How often did I watch each video? When did I open each e-mail? There's so much data that companies collect about your behaviour that is never given back to us.
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by aboringusername on Thursday November 12, 2020 @06:23AM (#25068693)
It's entirely possible to collect information to identify a unique human without it being considered PII - combine it all together and maybe add a sprinkle here and there (perhaps public domain info, buying "anonymized" info) and boom, you know who it is.

Yet, if you're audited, it's just a series of IDs and numbers, nothing identifying there...Right?

If you ask Spotify for your data dump, you'll notice in a lot of the .JSON files the information is encrypted such that you can't understand it (it's just numbers). It's impossible to say whether it's actually stored like this or if they encrypt it before they provide the archive to you.

Meta data is almost impossible to legislate against, and as far as I can see, is entirely legal to collect and use as you see fit.

How many people in the world are on hackernews, named "lopis", use Firefox 65, have an IP address in $country, use this screen resolution etc etc

Easy enough to identify who you are.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by hyperman1 on Thursday November 12, 2020 @06:59AM (#25068868)
AFAIK the GDPR already does this:

See first definition of https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...

You are identifiable by combining multiple factors, even if every individual factor is not enough to be identifiable.

If I understand it correctly, the EU 'personal data' (PD) concept is much wider than the US 'Personally Identifiable Information' (PII) concept. You are touching one of the differences here.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by cj on Thursday November 12, 2020 @08:37AM (#25069678)
This is correct.

For GDPR purposes, data is PII if it can be used in combination with any other data to identify an individual. Doesn’t matter if the individual data points are not themselves identifying.

One thing I’ve been curious about is whether AI and algorithms that can potentially take a huge amount of anonymous data and “identify” a user (but not explicitly), only identify in the sense that the output of the AI was only possible by correlating individuals granularity enough. I’m almost certain the answer is yes. I’m not clear on whether GDPR addresses that issue or not.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by neallindsay on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:17AM (#25070071)
> For GDPR purposes, data is PII if it can be used in combination with any other data to identify an individual.

By that definition, all data is PII. There is no information available on this planet that has not been influenced by people.

I'm not trying to be obtuse. I worry about this problem a lot. Obviously we need to keep companies from doing stupid stuff like storing the first digit of a Social Security number (can't identify someone by that!) and then the second digit (also not uniquely identifying!), etc.

On the other hand, what if I have web log files that only store URL, timestamp, and status code? Is that OK? If I get hits for two specific pages within a couple of minutes of each other, and there's only one person on the planet who would know about both those pages, I know they were visiting my site at that time.

People influence the world around them and it feels like privacy laws are trying to prevent companies from understanding that influence. At the same time every other incentive is pushing those companies to understand more.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by remus on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:30AM (#25070232)
> By that definition, all data is PII. There is no information available on this planet that has not been influenced by people.

I think that is a step too far. For example, it seems quite clear that a dataset of daily average temperatures from the top of Everest is not personally identifying information.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by ohmaigad on Thursday November 12, 2020 @10:36AM (#25070954)
Black hair = PII, address = PII, drives black BMW = PII, any of this information together with other information could be used to identify an individual and that is exactly the issue. It is like saying that one brick is a house just because multiple bricks can make a house. If you gather enough data you can potentially point to specific individual. Just like unique PC fingerprinting - gather enough data points so that the fingerprint is unique.
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by hyperman1 on Thursday November 12, 2020 @11:16AM (#25071364)
AFAIK according to the GDPR, knowing each individual fact is fine. Only the combination is PD.

Hence, installing a camera that counts black-haired people, another that counts people entering some location, a third counting people having a BMW is perfectly fine. Merging the 3 recorded tapes to identify a person is not. Giving the 3 tapes to someone else is only OK if you guarantee somehow they wont do the merge.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by tokamak-teapot on Thursday November 12, 2020 @10:24AM (#25070825)
Privacy laws are mainly aimed at allowing those whose data is being used to be aware of this, understand what is used for which purpose, and to elect to control this should they object.

None of this is the same as a blanket prevention.

Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by kace91 on Thursday November 12, 2020 @06:29AM (#25068715)
My gdpr requests have usually included inferred data. I'm not sure if it was facebook or tinder's that showed a giant list of categories they thought I fitted in, which was btw hilariously wrong (I'm a 30 y/o single male and I was categorised as a single mom, for example).
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by jakubp on Thursday November 12, 2020 @06:21AM (#25068682)
GDPR does cover inferred data. Source doesn't matter. Only whether this is data about a specific identifiable person and whether it's covered by the list of protected types of data.
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by lopis on Thursday November 12, 2020 @10:00AM (#25070559)
Then the takeouts I've personally taken from Facebook, Spotify and Google were not compliant. They were missing anything interesting and non-obvious.
Re:Google Takeout: Export a copy of your data in Google serv... by fsflover on Thursday November 12, 2020 @10:08AM (#25070638)
Yes, and not just in your case: https://ruben.verborgh.org/facebook/#history