News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:37PM (#25061310)
Time to dust off my side project, Timeliner [1] which downloads your Google Photos (and other content from various services) and indexes them in a local SQLite DB.

Then after backing them up locally, I won't feel bad about deleting them from the cloud later to free up space.

I've been using Timeliner for a while but need to update it. New maintainers welcomed, if you're interested!

(One major "oof" is that the Google Photos API strips geolocation data, so unfortunately coordinates are lost when using this method. There's discussion about using Takeout as a workaround, or even automating web browser interactions, but those have their own problems too.)

[1]: https://github.com/mholt/timeliner

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:39PM (#25063339)
> indexes them in a local SQLite DB.

I don't really understand this. I've been in computing for 45 years now. Programs come and go. I store files I want to keep in the most generic format practical. Storing a file in some program's special format is not a good plan for reading it 40 years from now.

For photos, I store them as jpgs in folders named after the year. Within those folders, there might be sub-folders named with a topic, like "disneyland" or "christmas". I'll "tag" photos by selecting a name for the jpg, like "bob and sue.jpg".

If more is needed, I'll just add a "notes.txt" file in the folder, with whatever text seems appropriate.

I have no worries about ascii text becoming unreadable, and few worries about jpgs becoming unreadable.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:57PM (#25063519)
Please don't misunderstand, with your 45 years of computing experience. :) (which I highly respect) I never said the files are stored in sqlite. They are just indexed in sqlite. The files are stored on disk like normal.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by peterwwillis on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:38PM (#25065808)
> Please don't misunderstand

If there's one thing people will always do regardless of age, it's that.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by phoe-krk on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:46PM (#25063411)
SQLite is an ubiquitous and well-tested piece of software that is going to stand the test of time and survive the next twenty years. There are very few pieces of software that I am able to praise like that with a clean conscience; SQLite is definitely one of them though. You might find it worthwhile to read e.g. about its memory allocation strategy, or its testing strategy.

Also, I don't think that the image files themselves are stored in the SQLite DB file; likely just their indices and metadata.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:06PM (#25063586)
> SQLite is an ubiquitous and well-tested piece of software that is going to stand the test of time and survive the next twenty years.

My timeline is much longer than 20 years. I have family photos going back to the Civil War.

Besides, Wordstar and Wordperfect files used to be ubiquitous. Good luck with those today.

I switched my mail from Outlook to Thunderbird because the former stores the email in some undocumented unreadable binary format. TB stores the mail as text, so I can recover the mail without needing TB. I have mail going back 25 years now. Some of my earlier mail is now lost because, surprise surprise, the mail program no longer works and the data is stored in a proprietary format.

I unzipped all my old file archives a few years back out of concern that some of the old DOS archive software would disappear.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by williadc on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:59PM (#25064037)
> Besides, Wordstar and Wordperfect files used to be ubiquitous. Good luck with those today.

Here's a Hacker News story from 10 days ago about an update to Wordperfect: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24959090

I haven't tried it myself.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:13PM (#25064627)
I saw that story, which is why I remembered Wordperfect. Good luck having a DOS emulator that works with WP 40 years from now :-)

Now what happens if it was a slightly less popular word processor, like PC-Write? (PC-Write rose to fame by being the first shareware program.)

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fomine3 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:52PM (#25064987)
I agree to store metadata inside the file is better, but FYI: SQLite is expected to be supported very long.

https://www.sqlite.org/lts.html

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by knyazhefilms on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:02PM (#25066299)
>My timeline is much longer than 20 years.

What storage format do you use then? Are you concerned about Hard drives format becoming obsolete? Are you using Mac or Windows? What if tomorow Apple or Microsoft decide to stop support for their formats? What would you consider as a reliable Storage format? Do you trust linux formats ext3 ext4? What would be your ideal choice looking from your perspective which I really share. It's really a big question for me how reliably store things for long periods of time.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Thursday November 12, 2020 @06:42AM (#25068777)
I copy them forward to new media every year or so. It's how I avoid bit rot and media obsolescence.

My files have survived magtapes, DECtapes, 8" floppies, 5.25" floppies, 3.5" floppies, zip drives, CDs, DVDs, blurays, 6 Mb hard disks (yes, 6 megabytes!), many no-longer-readable hard drives, and that about covers it.

Just keep copying them forward, and rotate among more than one drive.

My experience is that every media device and every media format becomes unreadable after a few years.

I learned programming on punch cards. I wish I'd kept my punch card decks, but they'd be unreadable by now. Unreadable by machine, that is, I could decode them by hand.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by stjohnswarts on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:57PM (#25064026)
I hope you at least have at least 1 on site and one off site and 1 physical media backup of all those if you want to keep them for the next few generations...
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:14PM (#25064635)
Having all your backups in the same spot is as dumb as relying on the cloud.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by depr on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:48PM (#25063935)
Wordperfect files can be opened in MSFT Word ;)
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by google234123 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:57PM (#25064027)
For how much longer? And how much resources do you imagine will be spend to fix bugs/issues opening these files? I don't think this example is strong enough to deserve a mocking wink
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:57PM (#25063513)
> likely just their indices and metadata

notes.txt will work just fine, then, even for several thousand photos. I don't see a need for a database until you've got far more than that. The tree file system works tolerably well as a "database".

As for searching, I know how to use "grep" and "locate".

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by joshuamorton on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:36PM (#25063846)
Tags are more flexible than folders. An actual index let's you search by tag. Folders don't let you search for all photos of your mother, or in 1987, or in Alabama, or some combination thereof.

Folders are a limiting api and we shouldn't limit ourselves to strictly hierarchical organizational structures for non hierarchal data.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:59PM (#25064040)
I know, but folders work perfectly fine even up to a few thousand files. It doesn't take me long to find a vacation picture from 1966, for example. I look in the 1966 folder, which doesn't have a lot in it. The preview thumbnails from file explorer quickly let me hone in.

It'd take me far more time to set up a proper tag database than I'd save looking things up.

It's still infinitely better than a random shoebox with random snapshots in it.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by sokoloff on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @08:30PM (#25065339)
Looking up something by its clustered index is indeed pretty easy. That's not the only access pattern into most data sets, which is where tags can be handy.

I agree with your last two points, as my family's digital photos are also stored in a fairly similar clustered index style where you have to know the date at least pretty closely to start your search unless you want to scan "all Thanksgivings" [which itself is just a series of clustered index lookups]

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by megablast on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:41PM (#25064362)
45 years experience, and your first thought is that they are being stored as a binary blob in a database??
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:25PM (#25064732)
Yes. Binary file formats are common (like Microsoft Outlook, pdf files, etc.), and are very fast to read/write. Text files have to be parsed. I've written lots and lots of dumpers for binary file formats generated by other programs.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:13PM (#25066362)
Oof, I feel the trauma on this one. I've been bitten by too many binary file formats that I don't care to store aggregate amounts of content in them (unless it's just metadata).
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ForHackernews on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:44PM (#25063395)
TBF SQLite format is also extremely unlikely to become unreadable: https://www.sqlite.org/fileformat2.html
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Retric on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:44PM (#25063394)
Metadata is more useful with older photos. Right now it’s obvious who’s in them, but in 40 years being able to just put names to faces can be difficult.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:49PM (#25063449)
I just note their names in the file name. If there are too many, I make a copy of the photo, bring it up in an image editor, and type the names of the people next to their heads. It works like a champ.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by zeroxfe on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:29PM (#25064276)
Bits rot. If you want your data to last the next 40 years, plan for spending a few hours every 5 years migrating your storage. It's a far better plan than trying to predict what the world will be like 40 years from now.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by WalterBright on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:19PM (#25064683)
Absolutely. I buy new drives every year or so and copy the stuff forward. Many of my 10+ year old drives no longer function.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by e_y_ on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:26PM (#25063753)
It would be easy enough to use the SQLite DB for normal read/write and search, and also save a human readable .txt dump periodically such as when making backups, or asynchronously on every save.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by kristopolous on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @08:17PM (#25065210)
Creating a cadence that also stores the data in EXIF isn't really that hard if that's your concern. You could even get SQLite triggers to do external calls to update the tags if things change. This is all pretty trivial.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by scrollaway on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:49PM (#25062159)
Matt, did you see Promnesia? https://beepb00p.xyz/promnesia.html

There are a lot of converging ideas out there, for "self-hosted NSA of yourself" type software which gather your own data from services you use and index it / make it more accessible to users. Would love to see something serious come out of it.

I followed Timeliner early on and really like the idea, but yeah it's a bitch to get traction for this sort of thing. You need people willing to implement backends for basically everything, then maintain them.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:08PM (#25062400)
Yep, I've also seen Perkeep and several other similar projects. They're all a bit different and I'm happy with something simple and bare-bones, it just has to be good at getting the data off.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fletchowns on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:57PM (#25062270)
It's so annoying that Google strips the geolocation data. What would be the reason for this? It has been frustrating following along with the ticket that goes nowhere for years: https://issuetracker.google.com/issues/80379228
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ghaff on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:24PM (#25062572)
As andybak says, almost certainly privacy. It's very easy for an unsophisticated user to share photos that, for example, effectively show where they live (or where someone else lives). I believe Facebook strips geo data as well. (A service like Flickr does not although I assume there is a switch somewhere that tells it to.)
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fletchowns on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:55PM (#25062869)
Wouldn't it be easy for Google to only strip the geolocation data if you are not the owner of the photo though?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ehsankia on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:13PM (#25063054)
Well it's being done through the API, which is presumably OAuth'd under your name, but again, this API is generally used by other sites to interact with your photos library, and it's very easy for someone to just approve the OAuth permissions for sharing photos, not realizing they are also implicitly sharing their location.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ghaff on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:03PM (#25062951)
One scenario is you're at a party at someone's house. If you post a captioned photo from the party that's geotagged, you're identifying where they live.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by agustif on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:31PM (#25063262)
Vice gave away John Mcaffe's location when he was wanted. with geo data not stripped. from a photo shared by Vice Editor in the blogpost... LOL
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ByteJockey on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:44PM (#25066536)
Doesn't it also save some space?

I mean, it's a small amount, but on the scale of google it might be worth it.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by stjohnswarts on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:59PM (#25064039)
Privacy?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by andybak on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:18PM (#25062513)
Ironic as it sounds - privacy?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by irrational on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:36PM (#25062691)
Ironic indeed. I can’t help but wonder if Google stores the geolocation data privately where only they can access it for their own data mining uses before removing it from the photos.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ehsankia on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:15PM (#25063070)
You can see the location on Photos website/app, it's not hidden from the user. You also still get it when you Takeout the photos. It's explicitly stripped when sent through the API, because said API is generally used by other websites for getting your photos, and it's not clear to the user they are actually leaking their location when uploading a Photo to "ShareYourRecipe.com".
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ciarannolan on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:50PM (#25062823)
I would start with the assumption that Google is collecting and storing every single possible data point about every single thing you share with them, including this. I have zero doubt that they store this info privately for their own use.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by chrisbroadfoot on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:54PM (#25062863)
Zero doubt? Wow, wish I had such confidence to make claims about things I know little about.

Each photo's geolocation data is stored. Of course.

It is shown in the UI, as well as indexed so you can search by location.

For example, I can search for "photos of dogs in Portland" and it'll show all the pics of dogs I've taken in Portland.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Xorlev on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:28PM (#25062614)
Exporting via Takeout will retain the geolocation tags. The API isn't the best place to export.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Roritharr on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:15PM (#25063067)
I've stumbled upon this problem lately. Is there any software to organize the takeout dump sensibly?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by BoboDupla on Thursday November 12, 2020 @03:20AM (#25067669)
but the result is a mess - why can't Google just give me all my photos in a logical folder structure, but instead I get duplicate folders with .json files and pictures which are in a completely different folder.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:58PM (#25062275)
I have one primary collection but I also have probably 30TB of old drives lying around with photos scattered all about. Is there something I can do to mount those drives, grab all image files and then dedupe/catalog them (at least by date)? Ideally this would work with videos as well.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by bayindirh on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:12PM (#25063041)
Considering you're using Linux, I'd do something of sorts:

  1. get all image files with "find", considering they are with a known extension
  2. run jdupes on the dump and deduplicate them.
  3. run exiftool on them to automatically divide them to folders based on any metadata field you like.
  4. Index all of the images with digikam and further organize them there.
Another path would be to add all drives as "removable collections" to digikam and manage all of them there. digikam also has fuzzy search so it can find not only identical but similar images so you can deduplicate them.

Both ways are applicable to videos as well.

I'm currently using the second path since Digikam is already my primary photo cataloging and managing tool for years and, it works wonders.

---

On mac, Gemini II and Retrobatch would allow for a similar workflow but, I didn't use them as my primary workflow tools. Gemini also has similarity search so it can deduplicate similar photos.

I'm not using Windows for more than a decade so, I don't know anything on that front.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:17PM (#25066016)
This looks like a great approach, thanks for putting it together. I'm hoping to dump these disks to an image b/c the filesystems on them are all over the place...some of them are IDE lol, then just loopback mount them for this process.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by bayindirh on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:35AM (#25067094)
I'm glad that it helped. Organizing old files always take much longer than anticipated. It's a live exercise on entropy :)

Taking images and mounting them sounds reasonable. :)

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Jiocus on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:20PM (#25063117)
From the comfort of a terminal[1], a few options comes to mind,

git-annex[2] will allow you to index all, or just some, of those files where they are - and keep track if you shuffle them around. The really useful feature in your case, is that git-annex will keep tabs on even your disconnected harddrives, flashdrives or cloud storage. It will let you know if you have redundant copies and how many, or if you're about to trash the last known instance of IMG001.jpg. It will point you to specific storage media if query some file not currently local.

Note that it's not entirely as trivial as I make it out to be - git vcs experience helps. Some love it.

In your situation, I'd might try borg[3] - No experience, but I heard appreciative voices about it and docs seem OK.

Personally, I always end up using rmlint/fdupe and unix tools, but that's a secret.

[2] https://git-annex.branchable.com/ [2] https://github.com/borgbackup/borg [3] There's GUI implementations of these

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:15PM (#25066007)
Whoa git-annex looks like it would be useful for a few projects, thanks for the tip. Will take a look at both.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jdeibele on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:03PM (#25062947)
I've been pleased with PhotoSweeper on my Mac. I started with the free Lite version, then went ahead and bought the full version.

I set it at the highest match setting. If you adjust it to a lower setting, it will match things where somebody is looking at the camera versus looking away.

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/photosweeper/id463362050?mt=12 https://apps.apple.com/us/app/photosweeper-lite/id506150103?...

PS: I was going to say that they have a PC version but it looks like the 3rd entry for me on DuckDuckGo is actually spam that says there is a PC version, then feeds you to programs that are "like PhotoSweeper". I wouldn't download those.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:14PM (#25066001)
Will check this out, thanks for the suggestion!
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by avgDev on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:07PM (#25062380)
I bought a Synology NAS mainly for images/videos/personal files and run hard drives in RAID setup. You could explore other NAS solutions like QNAP or open source.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:36PM (#25062685)
I've stopped and started shopping for a NAS at least five times now. One of these days i'll pull the trigger.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by alliao on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:32PM (#25063803)
Synology's photo station is slightly jarring... the whole indexing operation isn't optimized at all so if you have like 500k photos it's going to be spinning for a while.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by walterbell on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:12PM (#25062444)
There's an ancient-but-maintained image cataloger / asset manager called NeoFinder, available on Windows and Mac. Would love to find an OSS equivalent.

https://cdfinder.de/

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:35PM (#25062678)
Will take a look, thank you!
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by x87678r on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:13PM (#25062450)
Same problem. The other issue is having a 2 cameras and 2 phones in the family and grouping together events. Its easier just to save them all and not try.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jcims on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:27PM (#25062605)
My problem is I'm paranoid of getting rid of anything now. I just want to take one good sweep through so I can do something with those drives.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by subsaharancoder on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:50PM (#25063953)
Another alternative is Perkeep (formerly known as Camlistore) https://perkeep.org/ and there's even a tool to extract your pics from Google Photos https://github.com/perkeep/gphotos-cdp and move them to Perkeep.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by flashgordon on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:53PM (#25062207)
This is awesome. What would it take to hook up the storage to say block storage (say EBS or GCS) so that we can have more durabality interms of storage instead of having to manage a NAS at home? For me there have been a whole bunch of needs (photos, videos, docs) where storage has been the major stumbling block.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:55PM (#25062242)
You can use rclone to copy the files back up to any cloud you want. Timelines are just files and folders.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jmonger on Thursday November 12, 2020 @11:22AM (#25071434)
I extracted myself from Google Photos in 2019. Geolocation was a nightmare. I ended up using exiftool to merge the metadata from JSON available in Takeout.

https://exiftool.org/forum/index.php?topic=10412.msg55391#ms...

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jkingsman on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:14PM (#25062463)
Takeout sounds like an interesting workaround. I just do a takeout download once a month and figure that if google photos vaporizes or I lose my account I can write a python script to bake back in the JSON metadata that comes with it.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by skybrian on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:52PM (#25061501)
After downloading, can you upload to a different cloud photo service? I'd love to have a way to sync them automatically, and having a non-cloud backup would be nice too.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:12PM (#25061743)
You can do whatever you'd like. They're just files like any other.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by skybrian on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:33PM (#25062655)
Sure, but doing it automatically (and handling things like making sure they're not duplicated) would be more convenient over cobbling together a solution.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by charlieegan3 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:13PM (#25061763)
You might find rclone helpful. It has support for google photos.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by thinkloop on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:37PM (#25062022)
> The current google API does not allow photos to be downloaded at original resolution. This is very important if you are, for example, relying on "Google Photos" as a backup of your photos. You will not be able to use rclone to redownload original images. You could use 'google takeout' to recover the original photos as a last resort

https://rclone.org/googlephotos/#limitations

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by heroprotagonist on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:52PM (#25061497)
A demo or screenshots would go a long way here.

The project seems like it could be very interesting, but there's too much effort required to perform an initial evaluation.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:12PM (#25061755)
I know, but it's not a graphical app.

Contributions welcomed to lower the barrier to entry. Use it, contribute to it, or leave it, I guess!

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by dedosk on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:39PM (#25062036)
Integrate the takeout somewhat into www.digikam.org!
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by akx on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:50PM (#25061467)
And then you're responsible for backing that local content somewhere else... maybe the cloud?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mittermayr on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @01:55PM (#25061535)
The Google Photos interface itself isn't that big of a product (I think), if you can lose some of the sharing features, I guess it'd be quite an easy app to make that can be run off a v-server or Amazon at considerably less long-term trouble. The big big issue is the seamless auto-upload from phone to Google Photos, that's the fantastic feature that locked me in.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by llimos on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:27PM (#25062604)
True but their AI adds a lot of value. Searching for people is invaluable (though to be fair if you have the files locally, Windows Photos does that too.) Searching by item in the photo is less useful but I can imagine people use it now and again. And the automatically created videos are a nice bonus.

But yeah, not enough for me to pay them for it. If I'm going to pay someone, I'll pay someone else.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by majora2007 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:53PM (#25062209)
MegaUpload and Plex offer both of those things. Using Plex allows you to control the full storage and interface, then you can sync those to a cloud service or keep on a HDD yourself.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Normille on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:46PM (#25062777)
There's also Yandex Disc [0] which is still offering unlimited photo uploads from mobile devices. Although it wouldn't surprise me if they followed Google's lead on this and curtailed their offering as well. As they seem to pretty much mirror everything else Google does.

Yandex Disc also has an AI which allows you to search for objects within your photos.

[0]https://yandex.com/promo/disk/unlim

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jogundas on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:39AM (#25067119)
You might want to be aware that Yandex is a Russian company before moving all your photos there.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Normille on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:21AM (#25070124)
Not everyone who reads this site is a "reds under the bed" paranoid American.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by walrus01 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:39PM (#25062038)
the long term cost of buying something like a 12TB USB3.0 external hard drive and periodically letting it synchronize from your master copies, then unplugging it and storing it at a trusted family member's house is a great deal less than paying for 12TB+ of "cloud" storage indefinitely forever.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fouronnes3 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:42PM (#25062082)
Sure, except no drive sync software is as convenient or user friendly as google photos.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fletchowns on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:04PM (#25062346)
Google Backup & Sync makes it very cumbersome to retain a local copy of your photos. They used to sync them to Google Drive, so you could at least use Backup & Sync to have local copies. However, they got rid of that feature some time in the last year.

I had to switch to using a third party app to sync my "photo reel" from my phone to Google Drive: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.ttxapps.dr...

Then I use Google Backup & Sync to create a local copy on my desktop, scheduled SyncToy job to copy it to the NAS, and the NAS has a scheduled job to backup to Backblaze B2. In my setup, these irreplaceable photos & videos exist on my phone, Google, my desktop, my NAS, and Backblaze.

If you are relying on Google Backup & Sync to restore a large amount of data after a data loss event, you are in for a world of pain and disappointment. It simply does not handle any significant amount of data well. I had to stop backing up "My Computer" with Backup & Sync and just switched to using Google Drive. The files in Google Drive seem to be the only way to "restore" a large amount of files after a data loss event. If they are backed up under "My Computer" in Google Drive and you have a decent amount of data (50GB+), you will have no way to restore these files. The web interface will simply time out when you try to download them. The Backup & Sync client won't even attempt to download these files, even if you try the dead-end workarounds suggested on the web. You won't be able to drag them into your "Google Drive" folder as a workaround either. The whole thing is atrocious.

Google Backup & Sync is a fucking joke, and Google should be ashamed of themselves for releasing such a shitty product which does not actually help consumers protect against data loss. Consumers will only realize this at the point they are fucked and trying to restore their data.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Snitch-Thursday on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:48PM (#25062801)
For the 'I take pictures on my phone, poof its on my computer' needs, I replaced Onedrive Camera Upload with a Syncthing folder and haven't had to look back.

Onedrive is of course a different product than Google Photos, and the last time I used Google Photos, Google Now was still a left-swipe sidebar, so YMMV.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by jdeibele on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:19PM (#25063106)
Maybe if you commit 100% to the Google system or work solely on your iPhone/iPad it is.

I wanted to look at pictures on the big screen of my desktop Mac. Leaving Google Photos in automatic upload on my phone meant that photos would all get uploaded but the ones that I culled would be deleted from Apple Photos but not Google Photos.

Using Google Photos on my phone would let me delete both copies (Apple and Google) but it was much harder to make out differences. 27" screen vs 6" screen.

I was using Google Photos in the unlimited free quality mode so their copy shouldn't match my original pictures.

So Google Photos ended up as a place where I dumped photos as a backup. I bought more storage on iCloud.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by seraphsf on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:49PM (#25063450)
If you delete from Google Photos on the web from your desktop, the iPhone client will prompt you to allow deletion of those same photos from your iPhone’s Photos app (and hence iCloud, I think).

So, just do your deletion on the Google Photos web client on desktop. The culled photos will be culled from Apple Photos as well.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by yangikan on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:10PM (#25065982)
How long does it take to download a terabyte of photos?
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by fwiwm2c on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:13PM (#25062455)
Why not just pay $30/yr to get access to all the features which Google Photos (and other Google services) offer? I know $30 is not the same everywhere but if you are in US (and assuming you are in tech given you are on HN), you'd spend that much in a dinner without thinking much. There is something about paying about online services which brings a lot of resistance in us (me included but I think I am getting over it)
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ENGNR on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:17PM (#25062497)
Realistically... if you wanted to pay $30/year for a set and forget photo album, is Google the best place to do that?

Given how they often they deprecate things and how hard I've heard it is to restore a disabled account, I feel like some kind of smaller company dedicated to photo storage would be much better anyway

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ehsankia on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:21PM (#25063121)
Photos is a billion user product, how many of those have they deprecated? The disabled account thing may be a real concern, but statistically it's more rare than getting into a plane crash, yet we still fly planes. Also, if anything, monetizing the product and allowing it to be self-sustaining financially makes it far less likely to be killed. I'd much rather pay for a product that brings me value, since now I'm a real customer get treated differently from a free user. Also AFAIK Google has never killed a paid service either.

I would be curious to know what the competition looks like, but I don't know of any other service that lets me do "Show me photos of me and my brother at the beach" and actually return relevant results. The face/object clustering is near flawless, and even works with pets.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by murgindrag on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:39PM (#25063343)
Umm.... no. The disabled account thing is pretty common. Perhaps it's safer than flying a GA Cessna 172 in a storm, or being an air force test pilot. But probably not even that.

And as for killed services with a billion users, well, free unlimited Google Photos is now a killed service.

As for killed paid services, Google Play Music, Nest Secure, Google Photos Print, Google Audio Ads, and a ton of others.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ehsankia on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:45PM (#25063913)
> The disabled account thing is pretty common

Not really, it's mostly frequency illusion hanging out on HN, but considering Google has multi-billion users, those dozen or so incidents are nothing in comparison.

> free unlimited Google Photos

That's a feature, not a service. And name me one other company that provides unlimited free storage.

> Google Play Music

Technically migrated, all your data and purchases are still there

> Nest Secure

Hardware is a completely different ball game. The existing users can still keep using their hardware just fine. Every single device eventually stops being sold.

> Google Photos Print

Again, a feature. You didn't lose any data. You can still print photos using other services.

> Google Audio Ads

Not familiar, but I see it's still around? Do you have a link to the announcement of it being killed?

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by hyperdimension on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:04PM (#25064077)
Just for something to think about regarding the disabled/locked accounts, remember that we only hear about those who have the means/social-media following to make a Big Deal about it or those with the right friends inside of Google who might be able to nudge the proper team to take a second look, and the only stories that happen to pop up are "success stories" if I can call them that. As far as I can see, the average person is screwed should The Algorithm (blessed be thy name) decide against them.

Given the scale of Google and how many people have access to the Internet today, I'd generally be willing to bet that there are many, many others with the same fate but who simply can't get enough traction behind them for anyone (let alone Google) to care enough.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by murgindrag on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:18AM (#25070085)
> Not really, it's mostly frequency illusion hanging out on HN, but considering Google has multi-billion users, those dozen or so incidents are nothing in comparison.

It's not at all uncommon.

I've done business with Google multiple times in my career, and I could name a dozen such incidents. They're just not public.

For the most part, there wasn't anything the user did; just Google algorithm bugs. In one case, a startup lost all of its data because one Google system expected another Google system to implement a fraud detection measure, and the other Google system didn't. Completely internal to Google, but poof, all of a sudden, account gone, all data gone, and no way to fix it.

In another case, GCE lost a contract worth millions of dollars to AWS because Youtube had algorithm bugs. Poof. Youtube system broke. This was early GCE days, and they were looking for successes, and we were sufficiently high-profile that we had a dedicated engineering team. They pushed on Youtube. Youtube said we weren't important enough to help.

Most of this stuff is either under NDA, or otherwise just private, but it is why my current employer, as a policy, doesn't do business with Google. That's a big contract too; I'm not at a startup right now, but at a big company.

> And name me one other company that provides unlimited free storage

I think you're unintentionally arguing I shouldn't rely on Google-unique features, since I might lose them. I already knew that. I've learned that lesson painfully over, and over, and over, and over, and over.

That hurts Google in B2B. If all customers take that philosophy, Google fundamentally can't have unique, differentiating advantages beyond price. It doesn't matter what unique AI algorithm Googlers come up with for the Google Cloud. I won't use it if I can't count on it still being around when I ship my product. And I can't. The only time I will use Google is if it provides unique customer access (e.g. Android apps or Youtube eyeballs), which hopefully the antitrust thing will help with.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ghaff on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:21PM (#25062540)
Personally I use Flickr and am happy with them.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by Normille on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:14AM (#25070034)
I'm not sure if you're just stating a personal preference there, or hinting that Flickr are somehow morally superior to Google. But Flickr had their own 'google Photos moment' a few years back, when they were bought out by SmugMug and immediately got rid of their 'free for life' 1TB storage.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by skybrian on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:30PM (#25062630)
I am pretty much all-in with Google and do what I can to protect my Google account, but one risk you can't get rid of is if Google cancelled your account for whatever mysterious reason, which is unlikely but would be catastrophic.

I still like Google Photos, but ideally I'd automatically sync all my photos to a backup service and have things set up so I could make it the primary replica if needed.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by ghaff on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:45PM (#25062758)
IMO, no one should be treating any online photo site as their primary photo storage. At the risk of seeming paranoid, I have everything local and both backed up locally and to Backblaze; the online photo site I use is strictly for sharing and, I suppose, yet another backup of last resort.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by archon810 on Thursday November 12, 2020 @01:57AM (#25067216)
$30/year will get you... 100-200GB?

I can easily fill up that much data in a single month with videos of my kids.

The next tier is 2TB for $10/mo. Then 10TB for $50/mo.

All of a sudden, you're paying $600 a year and it isn't as insignificant as you suggested.

Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by thekyle on Thursday November 12, 2020 @02:40AM (#25067454)
If you're easily generating 200GB per month in photos and videos then a NAS would probably make more sense. But keep in mind the vast majority of people don't take that many photos.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by helij on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:57PM (#25064516)
What you say makes sense but these services quickly add up.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by johnghanks on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:02PM (#25061608)
why would anyone want this? you lose literally every benefit of Google Photos.
Re:Google Photos will end its free unlimited storage in June... by mholt on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:14PM (#25061770)
Hmm, good point, I guess nobody has ever lost access to their Google Account or (in the future) run out of storage space. After all, they're just photos, not important memories or anything.