News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by zepto on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:08AM (#25059488)
The assumption that Apple wants to approve all apps is wrong.

Apple sees App Store apps, and web apps as having different advantages, and it is in their interest to have the best platform for both.

It’s not just me saying this, they keep saying it too, and proving it by investing in making web apps run better.

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by mikenew on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:38AM (#25059842)
And yet they've completely nerfed PWAs on iOS. So they can say what they like; I don't believe it.
Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by zepto on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:48PM (#25062152)
Not everything they do will fit your view of how they should support the web.

Believe whatever you like.

But this means you are also choosing to ignore absolutely enormous investments at every level of the stack that they have made to increase web performance, adopt standards and improve web user experience.

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by rictic on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:15PM (#25063069)
It's hard to square the claim that they've made enormous investments when you compare feature support against budget. Apple's operating budget is 200x Mozilla's ($85B vs $0.45B), and yet Safari lags significantly behind Firefox in features (and for some the use cases, in performance as well).

Disclosure: I work at Google on JS libraries, and at one point was in the Chrome org, but my opinions are my own.

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by klelatti on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:19PM (#25063689)
It's reasonably clear that Apple's main focus for Safari is on memory, power use and performance rather than features so that doesn't in any way disprove that they are investing heavily in it.

You'll probably know better than me but Apple's work on Webkit was presumably worthwhile enough for Google to fork it into Blink (no problem with that but maybe worth acknowledging that fact).

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by e_y_ on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:39PM (#25063878)
I think it highlights a distinction between Apple's past work and their recent work.

Google forked Blink because for whatever reason they were unsatisfied with the state of Webkit -- nominally because they wanted to take a different approach to multi-process, but there may have been other technological and project direction/pace disagreements. Since then, a number of browsers have switched from Webkit to Blink/Chromium as their engine, and arguably Safari is falling behind on new features and overall quality (weird quirks that require web devs to work around).

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by klelatti on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:18PM (#25064193)
Don't disagree on features and some aspects of quality but I think it's a mistake not to recognise that the overall user experience also depends on other factors.

If Apple's focus is on getting better power consumption and memory use (esp on mobile) then that's still investing and arguably that does as much if not more for users and the web than adding more features.

PS Let's not forget that Apple are still standing behind WebKit when Microsoft have given up on their own rendering engine so let's give them some credit for helping to avoid a Chrome only web.

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by zepto on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @08:37PM (#25065403)
Google has a strategy to destroy other platforms and replace them with Chrome.

It’s hardly obvious that this is best for users in the long run.

I point this out not to say it’s wrong for them to attempt this, but because it makes no sense to use Google’s strategic decisions as evidence of Apple’s intentions or investment.

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by jbergens on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:02PM (#25062943)
Safari is known among many web developers as the worst browser to develop for.
Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by bleuarff on Sunday November 15, 2020 @04:18AM (#25099589)
I would agree if us poor souls didn't have to still support ie11.
Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by oarsinsync on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:35AM (#25059796)
> Apple sees App Store apps, and web apps as having different advantages, and it is in their interest to have the best platform for both. It’s not just me saying this, they keep saying it too, and proving it by investing in making web apps run better.

The method to pin a webapp to the home screen is substantially worse than it used to be.

There was a period where javascript running in Safari ran significantly faster than javascript running in a webapp opened from the home screen, or in any other app opening a web view. Is that still the case, or did they decide to share that function?

Re:Apple's Shifting Differentiation by pvg on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @11:46AM (#25059948)
It hasn't been the case for years.