News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by derriz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @08:57AM (#25058405)
Describing these as mini-plants gave me the impression that they're talking about say a container sized "unit".

While they would be considered small at 440MW, they are still full nuclear plants - the novelty seems to be that as much of the structure as possible will be assembled from prefabricated modules constructed off-site.

I can't figure out the economics here. They project $2.7B to construct each 440MW plant. This is presumably an optimistic estimate since they haven't even designed it.

Then you have high running and security costs and subsequent decommissioning costs. You need security infrastructure for storage and transport of fuel and waste.

And I guess it's envisioned it will take a least 10 years to get the first one operational given they've just started on design work?

In contrast, you can build 2GW of on-shore wind capacity for that money and have it delivering electricity in a year or less. The plant will require almost no personal at all to run, and maintenance can be done one or two part-time engineers. Operating costs are effectively zero.

Sure, depending on location 10% of the time you'll dip below 1/3 operating capacity but that will still exceed the output from one of these plants. Even if the peak 2GW cannot be utilised efficiently immediately, advancements in storage and increases in BEV sales will make the excess valuable.

I think there little future role for fusion for electricity generation - it's just too complex and expensive. The collapse in price for wind/solar in the last decade have changed all the numbers. Prices are so cheap that you can basically over-provision wind/solar by a factor of 3 to minimise effect of fluctuations. Add in cheap efficient combined-cycle gas peaker plants to provide smoothing in production and you can get to 80% carbon-free relatively easily and economically.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by cure on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:34AM (#25058707)
> I can't figure out the economics here. They project $2.7B to construct each 440MW plant. This is presumably an optimistic estimate since they haven't even designed it.

Same here, this makes no sense from an economic perspective.

The article quote was even worse: they think that after they have built a few, they think they will be able to build them at roughly $2.7B a pop. How much will the first few cost?

Who pays for the handling and storage of the nuclear waste? That's never included in the cost estimates for nuclear plants, mini or not.

How much grid-scale battery would $2.7B buy today? Looks like a Tesla megapack is ~$300/kWh with all the batteries and electronics included (https://cleantechnica.com/2020/10/05/tesla-megapack-powerpac...). $2.7B would pay for ~9GWh of grid-scale storage, or about 20 hours of output from a 440MW plant. Of course you would still need to add the generation piece - solar or wind is cheapest today.

I'm going to guess that in 10 years, when those mini-plants may finally be a reality, the combination of grid-scale batteries with solar/wind or wave generation will be so much cheaper that there will be no market for mini-nuclear plants.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by SiempreViernes on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:41PM (#25063360)
They might be a worthwhile investment if you can use them to straight up buy political support for green policies like co2 taxes and energy efficiency regulations.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by krona on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:59PM (#25062291)
The cost of compensating wind farms for overloading the power grid, which considering the UK's current (and future!) wind generation capacity, is not inconsequential.

Wind farms in the UK have to be disabled for periods during the Winter, which is hardly ideal, even if such downtime is a few hours at a time.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pydry on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:13PM (#25062448)
If you factor in the cost of upgrading the grid wind turbines are still a bargain.

Especially if you consider the economic possibilities of periods of nearly free electricity - e.g. fleets of electric cars/storage heaters/aluminium shelters demand shifting to take advantage.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by Devils-Avocado on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:25PM (#25064250)
We need to begin building that smart charging/discharging capability into electric cars now, then.

We need to establish the regulatory and user interface standards around this ideally before we start manufacturing tens of millions of EVS each month.

It might make sense to also unbundle electricity for consumers, charging the live wholesale rate and indicating the pricing via apps, alerts, or indicators on the meter itself.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by jl6 on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:49AM (#25058812)
How much would it cost for wind capacity plus enough battery storage capacity to make the whole setup functionally equivalent to a 440MW nuclear plant?
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:15AM (#25059023)
Can't speak to wind, but I know off hand that solar and storage is cheaper than coal [1], and onshore wind is cheaper than solar at utility scale [2]. Offshore wind still has a premium, but is still coming down in cost.

[1] https://pv-magazine-usa.com/2020/10/12/solar-plus-storage-re... ("Solar-plus-storage replaces coal plant in New Mexico, makes carbon-capture retrofit moot")

[2] https://www.lazard.com/media/451419/lazards-levelized-cost-o... (PDF, slide 3, center of page)

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by xyzzyz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @08:47PM (#25065470)
Your link only has 4 hours of storage, won't even last the whole night. Also, solar in UK will perform significantly worse than in New Mexico, for obvious reasons.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:03PM (#25065581)
It’s not meant to last all night, just to bridge the later hours between when the sun sets and everyone goes to bed (and load drops substantially). Europe has enough wind potential to power the world, its simply a deployment, storage, and transmission issue [1].

The New Mexico example was only to demonstrate that renewables and storage paired are cheaper than coal and nuclear, today.

[1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/08/europe-giant-wind-far...

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by ClumsyPilot on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:37AM (#25070315)
That is deeply misleading, there are sometimes several days of little to no wind, you 4 hours of storage are going to lead to nationwide blackouts and bodies in the streets
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by toomuchtodo on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:41AM (#25070367)
If only we could power nations with hyperbole.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by ClumsyPilot on Thursday November 12, 2020 @08:04PM (#25077574)
Which statement is hyperbolic, about multi-day low-wind weather or that we depend on the powergrid for survival?
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by toomuchtodo on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:45PM (#25078220)
Grid operators and generators aren’t going to decommission generation that’s necessary for grid stability if renewables, transmission, and storage haven’t proven themselves as adequate replacements. Tasmania (Australia) electrical supply is served primarily by hydro, solar, wind, and an undersea HVDC cable [1], and they still keep two gas turbines available [2] (one combined cycle, one open cycle) for meeting energy and ancillary service needs (but their run time is fairly low, if you look at the OpenNEM graphs).

Check out South Australia as well on those OpenNEM links below; they’re also close to meeting all of their electrical demand with renewables and battery storage (should be there in another year or two, rooftop solar uptake rate has blown away everyone’s expectations, to the point where the grid operator nervously expects there to be occasions where they might see zero grid demand [3]).

A rapid transition to exclusively renewables doesn’t mean a loss in grid reliability, simply a different grid configuration, occasional curtailment of renewables, and storage (hydro where available, battery everywhere else).

[1] https://opennem.org.au/energy/tas1/?range=7d&interval=30m

[2] https://opennem.org.au/facilities/tas1/

[3] https://reneweconomy.com.au/south-australia-the-first-big-gr...

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by briandear on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:08PM (#25065617)
Not to mention the land cost for solar as well as the environmental consequences of non-recyclable windmill parts. And the significant impact on birds. When people talk about the cost of power, they need to factor in the entire supply chain. And batteries have a very significant environmental cost in terms of mining and disposal.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by Schiendelman on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @09:13AM (#25058527)
Yep. These projects continue to be military-industrial at worst, and corporate handouts at best.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:09PM (#25064598)
Indeed. This government has made it absolutely clear that its Prime Directive is handing public money to cronies and party donors. So this fits perfectly.

And these are not small reactors, and there's nothing "mini" about them. They're comparable in power output to the first generation of UK reactors which operated from the 50s/60s to the 90s/00s.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by edogg on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:14PM (#25065999)
It’s 6000 jobs, generating electricity without producing carbon, sustaining an industry and construction and manufacturing know how, and creation of a product for export. These seem like worthwhile pursuits to me and a good use of public funds.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by Schiendelman on Thursday November 12, 2020 @07:46AM (#25069220)
Absolute numbers of jobs without a number of years aren’t useful (most of those may be transient), and they especially aren’t useful when not compared to the job creation impact of other expenditures of those same dollars.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by edogg on Thursday November 12, 2020 @12:15PM (#25071991)
Giving a grant to an existing company with a long history of technical excellence and delivering products to build a new product and a factory for it means jobs that don’t go away. A power plant built creates jobs to run it for as long as it exists.

On the other hand All construction jobs are not permanent - they finish building the project and have to move on to the next one, if it is the factory for the power plants, the power plant itself, the next power plant, or something else.

18 million pounds is a lot of money, but it’s a pittance compared to what tech companies are raising from VCs. In relation to the size of tech companies and the size of investments in them, 6000 jobs and the kick start to an industry for 18 million pounds seems like a bargain to me.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by DoingIsLearning on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:02PM (#25063551)
> I think there little future role for fusion for electricity generation...

Not to deviate from the main discussion, I believe you meant fission instead of fusion.

Fusion energy is still being researched and will (hopefully) play its role in our carbon free future (... also hopefully not too far into the future).

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by derriz on Thursday November 12, 2020 @03:35AM (#25067740)
Good spot. Yes you are correct - I had meant to say fission.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by bigbubba on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @02:52PM (#25062196)
440MW really pushes the bounds of the S in SMR (Small Modular Reactor). Most SMR proposals are a fraction of that.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by baking on Thursday November 12, 2020 @12:48AM (#25066876)
Looks more like at Medium Modular Reactor. The Reactor Pressure Vessel (RPV) and three Steam Generators (SG) are all sized to fit on large trucks, 4.5m wide.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @03:42PM (#25062747)
> it's just too complex and expensive

This seems like a verbose rehash of an older comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25058145) that has already been refuted.

You’re not accounting for the real life costs like paying consumers to take excess energy when demand is lower than fluctuating supply, or replacing renewable infrastructure as often as every other decade (nuclear reactors may be able to last centuries, and their “waste” is recyclable).

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:02PM (#25063549)
Renewable sources can be easily curtailed, so in a high renewable grid prices cannot often go negative, unless someone is paying extra for the renewable sources to produce (which production tax credits do today in the US.)
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:07PM (#25063588)
Good point, though my larger point that they’re more expensive per watt still stands.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:13PM (#25064157)
Renewable sources are much cheaper per watt than new nuclear. By like an order of magnitude, for PV. They are also cheaper per kWh (levelized cost).

Nuclear's sole remaining argument is that the cost of intermittency of renewables is too high. But if that argument has any remaining validity, it requires that the rapidly decline of the cost of renewables and storage soon and suddenly runs into a brick wall.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by lmm on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:45PM (#25066184)
I don't think we can blindly assume that the extraordinary improvements to energy storage of the last few decades will continue forever; things like the Samsung exploding battery issues suggest we're already pushing the limits. CPU single-core performance was always increasing rapidly until it wasn't.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Thursday November 12, 2020 @08:07AM (#25069414)
And I don't think we can safely assume the decline won't continue. And you need to make that assumption if you're going to invest in nuclear, otherwise you've pissed away many billions of dollars.

Renewables and storage right now could handle the grid. So the downside, if we go with them and the decline suddenly stops, is that costs are higher than we wanted them to be. But that's it -- they can still do the job. If the economic risk for nuclear is higher than that, it's still worth going with renewables. At best, it might make sense to do some token nuclear projects to keep the industry from dying completely. You can view SMR efforts, or even Chinese reactor building, in that light.

I think, though, that renewables and storage will continue to get cheaper. For storage, in particular, I think the trends are very clear. There are many different storage technologies vying in the marketplace -- for example, hundreds or thousands of battery chemistries, or more with organics -- and increasing economic incentive to make them work and install them. Zero or even negative grid pricing is becoming common in more and more places. Trillions of dollars are available to those who win at this.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by lmm on Thursday November 12, 2020 @11:46PM (#25078983)
It's not pissing away, it's insurance. Maybe cheap storage will work out. But I'm not quite ready to bet all our futures on that assumption.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2020 @09:29AM (#25092471)
The insurance argument would support small efforts to sustain seed groups that could be expanded if the insurance policy has to be "cashed". It would not justify any large nuclear building program, or even justify replacing existing nuclear power plants as they age out.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:45PM (#25064402)
> They are also cheaper per kWh (levelized cost).

That seems to contradict the thread I linked to above.

> the rapidly [sic] decline of the cost of renewables and storage soon and suddenly runs into a brick wall

That doesn’t seem too unlikely given how tiny the combined storage capacity of all the batteries ever made, and all that could be made with all the raw lithium that can mined on Earth, would be compared to modern energy needs.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:20PM (#25064699)
> That seems to contradict the thread I linked to above.

That thread was wrong, then. The cost of PV, utility scale, is about $1/W(dc). Nuclear is an order of magnitude more expensive, per watt. PV has lower capacity factor, but it's still cheaper per kWh.

https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:43AM (#25070385)
> Nuclear is an order of magnitude more expensive, per watt.

Where are you getting that?

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Thursday November 12, 2020 @07:56PM (#25077486)
Vogtle 3/4 cost about $10/W.

Utility scale PV costs roughly $1/W(dc).

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:12PM (#25064621)
That might be true if lithium battery storage was the only option. It isn't.

https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/8/9/20767886...