News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @05:07PM (#25063588)
Good point, though my larger point that they’re more expensive per watt still stands.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:13PM (#25064157)
Renewable sources are much cheaper per watt than new nuclear. By like an order of magnitude, for PV. They are also cheaper per kWh (levelized cost).

Nuclear's sole remaining argument is that the cost of intermittency of renewables is too high. But if that argument has any remaining validity, it requires that the rapidly decline of the cost of renewables and storage soon and suddenly runs into a brick wall.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by lmm on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @10:45PM (#25066184)
I don't think we can blindly assume that the extraordinary improvements to energy storage of the last few decades will continue forever; things like the Samsung exploding battery issues suggest we're already pushing the limits. CPU single-core performance was always increasing rapidly until it wasn't.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Thursday November 12, 2020 @08:07AM (#25069414)
And I don't think we can safely assume the decline won't continue. And you need to make that assumption if you're going to invest in nuclear, otherwise you've pissed away many billions of dollars.

Renewables and storage right now could handle the grid. So the downside, if we go with them and the decline suddenly stops, is that costs are higher than we wanted them to be. But that's it -- they can still do the job. If the economic risk for nuclear is higher than that, it's still worth going with renewables. At best, it might make sense to do some token nuclear projects to keep the industry from dying completely. You can view SMR efforts, or even Chinese reactor building, in that light.

I think, though, that renewables and storage will continue to get cheaper. For storage, in particular, I think the trends are very clear. There are many different storage technologies vying in the marketplace -- for example, hundreds or thousands of battery chemistries, or more with organics -- and increasing economic incentive to make them work and install them. Zero or even negative grid pricing is becoming common in more and more places. Trillions of dollars are available to those who win at this.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by lmm on Thursday November 12, 2020 @11:46PM (#25078983)
It's not pissing away, it's insurance. Maybe cheap storage will work out. But I'm not quite ready to bet all our futures on that assumption.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Saturday November 14, 2020 @09:29AM (#25092471)
The insurance argument would support small efforts to sustain seed groups that could be expanded if the insurance policy has to be "cashed". It would not justify any large nuclear building program, or even justify replacing existing nuclear power plants as they age out.
Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @06:45PM (#25064402)
> They are also cheaper per kWh (levelized cost).

That seems to contradict the thread I linked to above.

> the rapidly [sic] decline of the cost of renewables and storage soon and suddenly runs into a brick wall

That doesn’t seem too unlikely given how tiny the combined storage capacity of all the batteries ever made, and all that could be made with all the raw lithium that can mined on Earth, would be compared to modern energy needs.

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:20PM (#25064699)
> That seems to contradict the thread I linked to above.

That thread was wrong, then. The cost of PV, utility scale, is about $1/W(dc). Nuclear is an order of magnitude more expensive, per watt. PV has lower capacity factor, but it's still cheaper per kWh.

https://www.lazard.com/perspective/lcoe2020

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by boogies on Thursday November 12, 2020 @09:43AM (#25070385)
> Nuclear is an order of magnitude more expensive, per watt.

Where are you getting that?

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by pfdietz on Thursday November 12, 2020 @07:56PM (#25077486)
Vogtle 3/4 cost about $10/W.

Utility scale PV costs roughly $1/W(dc).

Re:Rolls Royce plans UK class of mini-nuclear plants by TheOtherHobbes on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @07:12PM (#25064621)
That might be true if lithium battery storage was the only option. It isn't.

https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/8/9/20767886...