Re:.NET 5.0
by Netcob on Wednesday November 11, 2020 @04:16AM
(#25056833)
Yeah, I'm pretty shocked how much hate it seems to get. Maybe it just makes things easier for simpletons like me?
The one issue I can see with DI in ASP.NET Core is that it doesn't really do DI correctly. The point of DI is that ultimately, you have complete control over how you build your dependency graph and you shouldn't be forced to use a container at all if you don't want to. With a DI abstraction the developers are basically saying "you can do what you want, as long as it's pretty much exactly what we expect you to do".
Re:.NET 5.0
by Netcob on Sunday November 15, 2020 @08:02PM
(#25106747)
Yeah, that whole approach hasn't really changed at all. I'm not sure how MS could even realistically change it without breaking a lot of stuff, so I think it's more of an example of what to avoid.
The one issue I can see with DI in ASP.NET Core is that it doesn't really do DI correctly. The point of DI is that ultimately, you have complete control over how you build your dependency graph and you shouldn't be forced to use a container at all if you don't want to. With a DI abstraction the developers are basically saying "you can do what you want, as long as it's pretty much exactly what we expect you to do".
This explains this pretty well: https://blog.simpleinjector.org/2016/06/whats-wrong-with-the...