Wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abbottabad
Maps: http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&client=safari&q=ab...
Google Earth (copy/paste): 34° 8'48.00"N 73°12'59.00"E
Just amazing - harbored by friends in the Pakistani military for years while they received billions in aid from the US.
Edit: From the BBC - "Syed Riaz Hussain in Abbottabad, writes: "Last night, at around 0100, there was heavy gunfire about 300 metres from our house, which was followed by a huge blast. There was little in terms of military activity during the day to suggest something even remotely close to what happened. The exact spot where this incident took place, is a stone's throw from the Pakistan Military Academy, Pakistan's equivalent of West Point."
This is completely normal, and it's long been the case for the Taliban too. The Taliban operate, and sometimes govern, fearlessly and openly in parts of Pakistan. This includes proper towns and city districts, not just remote regions in the mountains. The old guard of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence is largely pro-Taliban and provides political protection, funding, supplies, training, etc. Other parts of the Pakistani government help them too.
The relationship between Al Qaeda and the Taliban is also complicated, and I'm probably in the dark as much as you are. My understanding is that they've never seen eye-to-eye, but apparently bin Laden was responsible for bringing the groups closer together. Al Qaeda has often resided in Taliban territory, with the latter's permission and protection.
Taliban: group of people looking to form a government.
Both have the goals of some kind of extremist Wahhabi-law region.
small area means that you are noticed right away by the locals, since they spend their days waiting for something out of the ordinary to happen. big cities you have surveillance and large media. you need mid sized
besides, in the case of bin laden, there was far too much heat in the tribal areas with daily drone attacks and military incursions etc. for him to be hiding there. the big cities are full of CIA agents, so it was always going to be somewhere in between.
Next up, Zawahiri (edited.) Considering that Osama was in a mansion outside of Islamabad, I would expect Zawahiri (edited) to be in a beach house outside of Karachi.
Edit: Imagine being the guy who pulled the trigger. I will never cheer anyone's death, but Osama would likely not allowed himself to be taken alive. Buy a beer / coke / shot (whatever he prefers) for the shooter. These guys are military hackers, maybe they read this as well.
Edit: Whoops, got wrong name of #2. blush
I think you're misunderstanding me, I don't want it to be true (or false, frankly, don't give a crap either way), I am just sharing what is a widely held belief there, in contrast to what is believed here.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CIA-Osama_bin_Laden_controversy
Dunno if I'd go as far as saying they were still pals in the last decade but I would warn you that jingoistic fervor is a terrible reason to suspend critical thought or curiosity. Boogeymen are enormously useful tools to those who have power. Skepticism is as valuable to apply to one's government as to conspiracy theorists. It's never "the time" to turn off your brain.
This is the same organism, mind you, that once called Iraq an imminent threat. Keep your salt handy.
Here's a great book by a former CIA field agent that explains just how complicated the reality of our middle east relations can get:
http://www.amazon.com/Sleeping-Devil-Washington-Saudi-Crude/...
Get through that book and even the most outlandish claims about our foreign policy or intelligence services will seem worth considering.
SO Pakistan ISA brokered US help by accepting US weapons and training and passing those weapons and training onto Afghan freedom fighters..
The source of the US help was the CIA..
So there was no direct knowledge in the sense that Osama did not know any CIA officers to contact, etc..but yes an indirect linkage of stuff yes..
BTW, why Pakistan? When Pakistan got the nuke bomb US policy makers reasoned that it might be helpful to support and help Pakistan to prevent use of the nuke bombs they had and those weapons falling into hands of someone else other than Pakistan..Pakistan's nuke bombs indirect result of China's political help to offset India ambitions.
update: here it is. add your review. http://bit.ly/kP0DCq
PMA Kakul (Pakistan Military Academy) is 200m South East of that, again matching the news reports.
* Surrounded with very high walls with a single entrance
* The compound was eight times larger than other houses in the area
* When it was built it was only accessible via a dirt road
* It has a field and grassy area to the side of it, which is what is shown in the Pakistan TV footage
* The compound had a clear view of anybody approaching by road, and escape routes out the back
It is amazing that they built this place only 5 years ago for the purpose of housing bin laden, and nobody in the area really asked any questions. It seems that the compound didn't have a cover story either - it had no phone or internet connection
It would have been a lot smarter to find a rich arab and his family to use as a cover. Say that it is his holiday home and get all the regular services hooked up. Having such a big building with high walls that doesn't have a phone or internet service must stand out so much that it only further leads me to believe that some in Pakistan knew what it was for and who was there.
Apparently there were ISI agents on the scene at the time of the gun battle, even though the USA didn't tip anybody off in pakistan about the compound or about the operation
I think the official US line of the pakistan government helping is just a way of placating skeptics. All the official statements from the government talk about a foreign operation and they seem to be distancing themselves from it
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/02/world/02osama-bin-laden-ob...
It's a great read. I'm wondering how they pulled it off, though - did they have the copy for an obituary filed away, and pulled it out and edited when the news broke?
Yes, that's how they do it.
It used to be that hilarity would ensue when people found news orgs' internal web servers exposed on the net. Don't recall it happening in awhile though. Guess they learned their lesson.
But it can lead to some interesting firedrills when someone dies unexpectedly:
http://voices.washingtonpost.com/postmortem/2009/06/michael_...
And sometimes the obituaries are pre-written many years in advance. Which leads to incidents like NYT's obit for Elizabeth Taylor, whose author died several years ago:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/03/24/movies/elizabeth-taylor-ob...
See: Debate over Britney Spears' Obituary
http://articles.sfgate.com/2008-01-22/news/17150316_1_hollyw...
If i'm not mistaken, I think it was in 2008 where Bloomberg accidentally published Steve Job's obituary which sparked a rumour that he died even though he was perfectly healthy.
The ISI overthrew the old government in Afghanistan by arming and training large groups of students from local pakistani madrasas. The student group after a few key wins in the south went on to be known as taleban (which is tajik for students)
These same factions within the ISI helped keep the Taleban in power, and assisted in aiding their escape back through Tora Bora and into Pakistan. I bet they tipped bin laden off to not staying in Wazrisistan and other tribal areas, since there was too much heat and the Pakistani military had some reach there.
I bet that the military in Pakistan knew a little (nothing about timing) but that the ISI were told nothing. The CIA have been in an active war with the ISI in Pakistan since 2001. There was the incident last year[1] where a CIA agent killed two ISI officers who were following him. I think that incident must be linked to bin laden tracking, since the agent - Raymond Davis, had been visiting the Pakistani countryside and taking photos of various compounds. When the ISI found out, they had him followed and intimidated him into leaving the country and minding their own business.
The CIA doesn't take shit and shot the other agents in their own country, then got Davies released by the Pakistani gov as part of a plea deal
I can't wait for the books and stories to come out about the last 2-3 years in Afghanistan and Pakistan - there is a real gap in public knowledge in terms of what has been happening there, and I bet some of the most interesting stories of the entire war on terrorism happen in that time.
The biggest problem always was that one of our key allies in the war had its own internal problems - and one side of our allie directly created and supported the very enemy we were fighting and continued to support them.
I don't doubt for a second that at least some elements of the ISI knew where bin laden was and protected him. The same thing happen in Serbia, with elements of the army and special police protecting Karadzic and Mladic, who is still at large.
[1] story on Raymond Davis, the CIA agent who shot two ISI agents in Pakistan last year: http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2011/03/11/spy_games?p...
Just to add to your comment: allowing the Kunduz Airlift (shortly after the invasion in 2001) was another of Bush administration's big mistakes. It allowed the top Taliban leadership to be airlifted out of Afghanistan, just when the NA troops had them surrounded. The seeds of today's insurgency were sown on that day; the top leadership survived, regrouped and still fight on today.
One thing that was unclear to me is if Bin Laden died in the firefight or was killed afterwards. From the article: "After a firefight, they killed Osama bin Laden and took custody of his body."
I hope to find a transcript and append a link to it. As of several minutes ago, the White House had not released a transcript.
OK, sorry to waste everyone's time.
This is people on HN downvoting you because you are failing to display a sufficient capacity for logical thought.
Bringing in more and more emotional scenery isn't helping. It's a predictable and transparent rhetorical tactic that we've all seen used in desperation many times before.
There are plenty of other sites where that kind of stuff is appreciated and even encouraged. Take it there and you'll get a better response.
* In August '10 a lead was uncovered. Obama directed followup.
* Lead was strengthened over time until it was isolated that bin Laden was in a compound in Pakistan.
* Obama gave the order and an American commando team went in, had a firefight, and killed bin Laden. His body was brought out.
* No Americans were harmed, and civilians were attempted to be protected.
* The Pakistani government was notified (speech did not say if this was pre-event or post-event).
And, transcript! http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2011/05/02/osama-bin-laden-de...