News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by londons_explore on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:24AM (#25034007)
While it's a minor logistical challenge, it's simple enough to ship this in a liquid nitrogen dewar.

Even very small cities will have liquid nitrogen facilities. Shipping from the nearest city to most of the population sounds very doable in 24 hours.

Remember you only need to get most of the population to halt the spread. If there's some tiny village 3 days hike away in the rainforest, you can skip them.

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by refurb on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:31AM (#25034064)
Shipping hundreds of thousands of doses of vaccine at -80C is more than a “minor logistical challenge”. First, you’d never ship in a liquid nitrogen dewar. It would be a massive logistics bottleneck considering the weight of dewars and the volume you'd be shipping (Pfizer already has deals secured for hundreds of millions of doses). And plus, these are packaged vaccines - a glass vial with a label, in a paper box, with a folded product info sheet inside. You can't submerge the whole thing in liquid nitrogen.

Shipping at -10C is a major logistical challenge. Mentally it doesn't sound like like much, but that's envisioning a single vial to a single patient. Multiply that by one million and deliveries to not only NYC but to Booneville, Louisiana. Temperature excursions mean spoiled product - product that gets thrown out. -80C is way harder than -20C (there are no vaccines today that require -80C).

You can’t just throw it on dry ice and say “we’re good”. Even just packing it is complicated. You have a pallet sized box with 20,000 doses. You put it in a box and surround it with dry ice. Are all the vials the same temperature after 2 hours? Are you sure? You need temperature monitoring at multiple points in the package so you know when it’s been spoiled.

Your delivery gets held up for 12 hours at customs, are all the vials still -80C? Are you sure? What do you do when you deliver to hospital and find out they don’t have -80C storage, even though they said they did? Do you have an intermediary storage facility you can bring it to until you figure out a solution?

Do you have monitoring after it’s been delivered so it doesn’t spoil before administration? Correct thawing procedures? What happens if a dose is thawed and the patient doesn’t show up and it sits at room temp for an hour? Just throw it out? Or is it still good? Are you sure?

And to add on top of all this - you (as the manufacturer) might have all this figured out, but you need to make sure everyone along the logistics chain does too. Guaranteed you'd send emails and letters in advance, and have massive yellow stickers all over the shipment that says "Must be stored at -80C" and you'll have a customer call you a week later asking if the product that's been sitting at -10C is still good.

Here is a document from WHO that will tell you way more than you’d ever want to know about cold chain distribution. There is an entire section on how to appropriately stack the vaccine vials in the freezer so they stay the right temperature. Yeah, it's that complicated.

https://www.who.int/immunization/documents/IIP2015_Module2.p...

Even cold chain for today’s products is really fucking hard.

Derek Lowe had a good quote on this:

"Pfizer has provided these details to the CDC about shipping and storage of their candidate: the vaccine can be shipped in “dry ice pack” boxes, but that dry ice will need to be replenished within 24 hours of receipt. The shipping carton needs to be closed within one minute of opening, and not opened more than twice per day. Vaccine vials, once removed, can be kept at refrigerator temperatures for up to 24 hours or at room temperature for no more than 2 hours after thawing. So this is going to take a very organized approach to make sure that the vaccine is handled properly without wastage. We’re looking at a lot of dry ice and a lot of orders for ultra-cold freezers if this is the candidate that gets heavy nationwide distribution. And mind you, I’m talking about organized distribution in Little Rock and Long Beach. What about La Paz and Lahore? What about Lubumbashi? Even back inside the US, what’s the nearest source of dry ice in Shiprock, New Mexico or Oceana, West Virginia?"

https://blogs.sciencemag.org/pipeline/archives/2020/08/31/co...

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by jessaustin on Monday November 09, 2020 @08:02AM (#25034307)
When we buy cattle semen it's always shipped in liquid nitrogen tanks. UPS knows how to do this. It is more expensive than other sorts of shipping.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by tatersolid on Monday November 09, 2020 @09:54AM (#25035375)
This comment is why HN still matters.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by marcosdumay on Monday November 09, 2020 @08:07AM (#25034368)
Yes, it is hard. It's full of issues and details.

But it's something that poor countries manage to do successfully with a reasonable reliability even on rural areas.

I am sure there will be plenty of new problems for that lower temperature. And a number of smart people will have to work really hard to solve them, a large amount of money will change hands and all that.

But I think the GP's point is that it's doable. It doesn't need any sci-fi tech or any large restructuring of humanity (and we already did some of the later for this virus).

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by xxs on Monday November 09, 2020 @10:07AM (#25035503)
>Shipping at -10C is a massive logistical challenge.

This is definitely false - refrigerated trailers are pretty normal. A lot of goods are shipped in similar trailers.

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by refurb on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:07PM (#25041475)
Logistics is way more than just refrigerated trailers. You've basically described 1 step of a 20 step process.

That's why their are specialist delivery services for cold chain. And cold chain medicine is way more complex than say, cold chain food.

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by ggghhhfff on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:37PM (#25041685)
I agree. I think sometimes it is hard to fully understand how complicated logistics can be. I mean that’s why people study logistics in school and companies pay money for professionals well versed in logistics.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by thehappypm on Monday November 09, 2020 @01:49PM (#25038167)
This is a fundamentally easy thing to solve.

Developing a safe and effective vaccine -- fundamentally hard. Developing a nuclear weapon -- fundamentally hard. Developing a quantum computer -- fundamentally hard.

Shipping something cold at a large scale? Hard, but not fundamentally hard. We'll solve it. There's no fucking way the vaccine effort is stopped by refrigeration needs.

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by ggghhhfff on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:41PM (#25041714)
I disagree. All problems you mentioned are fundamentally hard. It is unfair to say that a logistical challenge is easier simply because it involves refrigeration at scale as opposed to research, weapons development, or computing at scale.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by refurb on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:14PM (#25041526)
I love the declarative statements on HN by people who have zero practical experience in a given area.
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by thehappypm on Monday November 09, 2020 @10:19PM (#25042535)
Please tell me what parts of my statement are incorrect or misinformed. I’d love to learn more, but I haven’t gained anything from your snark!
Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by refurb on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @06:28AM (#25044778)
“easy thing to solve“

That’s what’s incorrect. Yes, it’s not “put a man on the moon hard”, but you’re really underestimating how difficult it is.

I’ve worked in drug distribution for a few years and you’d be surprised the challenges to getting a room temperature drug to a patient in a developed country. None of the steps are hard, but when you introduce humans into the mix things go poorly pretty quickly.

Getting a -80C drug transported to a 2nd tier city in sub-Saharan Africa is not “easy”. Unless you’re willing to have half (or more) of your product spoil. Based on the demand and urgency for a vaccine for Covid, we can’t spare even 1 dose to spoilage.

Yes, it’s not a “we can’t figure this out” problem, but it’s a big enough problem to really bottleneck distribution. It’s going to take some pretty smart logistics people to make sure the process works all the way from Pfizer’s distribution center to the patient’s body.

Re:Covid vaccine: First ‘milestone’ vaccine offers 90% prote... by bluGill on Monday November 09, 2020 @08:57AM (#25034830)
All of your concerns are real. However it is important to remember that this is also routine. The amount of vaccine to ship this way is not that large compared to all the other things shipping in this way. Shipping companies already know how to handle this type of thing and have systems in place. They have the monitoring in place and systems to watch it because this is already done on a large scale.