News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by dehrmann on Monday November 09, 2020 @03:18AM (#25032499)
This looks like a pretty popular project, so I assume he's decently talented. How does he not have a day job? Passion projects are great and all, but they're not known for paying the bills. Especially for solo maintainers, it's almost like playing a gig at a coffee shop for tips. Want to make a career out of it? You need talent, marketability, and be ready to compromise on your vision.
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by pietrovismara on Monday November 09, 2020 @05:26AM (#25033299)
This is wrong. If someone works a day job, they won't have time to work on their OS projects. Corporation should pay contribution to the OS projects they use to make billions/year. We should have license that requires only high income companies to pay for usage.
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by andrey_utkin on Monday November 09, 2020 @09:51AM (#25035341)
> This is wrong. If someone works a day job, they won't have time to work on their OS projects.

As everybody knows, every OSS maintainer doesn't have a day job.

> Corporation should pay contribution to the OS projects they use to make billions/year.

Impossible to accomplish, because "OS project" is not a legal entity to whom one could pay.

> We should have license that requires only high income companies to pay for usage.

We have such licenses, but they don't have anything to do with Free Software or Open Source Software. Such licenses are called "commerical licenses".

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by pietrovismara on Monday November 09, 2020 @10:28AM (#25035720)
> As everybody knows, every OSS maintainer doesn't have a day job.

We could still have many more if it was viable to do it without being forced to have a day job. Especially when your software is used by many succesfull companies.

> "OS project"

It stands for open source project. I don't get your quotes here.

> Impossible to accomplish, because "OS project" is not a legal entity to whom one could pay.

You talk about law, I talk about ethics.

> We have such licenses, but they don't have anything to do with Free Software or Open Source Software. Such licenses are called "commerical licenses".

Using "commerical licenses" hurts every use cases that is not profit based. Having mixed licenses adds a lot of complication for the mantainers on top of the already difficult volontary development.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by jiofih on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:05AM (#25036173)
I suggest you do some research. It is perfectly fine to have “mixed” licenses. Redis operates like this and has no problem making money, as do many others.

“adds a lot of difficulty” is a terribly weak argument - you want to make it your job and get paid for it, of course it will take some effort. Nobody owes you anything.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by pietrovismara on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:19AM (#25036322)
As a developer, I want my job to be about producing software. Handling the nitty gritty of commercial licensing is something I will happily leave to people who studied to do it.

I also reject the notion that everything should be commercialized, OSS is the antithesis of it.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by jiofih on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:38AM (#25036557)
I agree wholeheartedly with that.

I thought you were proposing a form of hybrid paid-OSS as many seem to want now. If you want to make a living, make it a business (yes, someone will have to deal with the business stuff).

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by pietrovismara on Monday November 09, 2020 @12:04PM (#25036875)
And that's true, but then we circle back to the OP (original problem), if you can't make a living out of OSS you're generally very limited in how much you can achieve, which then stiffles innovation in all other sectors that depend on OSS.

So the question stands, how do we allow OSS maintainers to contribute without forcing them to find ways to monetize their project, which would be against the very nature of OSS?

And I'm loving this discussion, because then why can't you apply it to other fields, like arts? In fact similar discussions are already happening in most creative fields. I know where this is going, and it's great.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by ghaff on Monday November 09, 2020 @12:26PM (#25037123)
>how do we allow OSS maintainers to contribute without forcing them to find ways to monetize their project

The most common way--which is pretty widespread--is to work for a company that is monetizing the project or otherwise depends on it as they're often interested in hiring someone with particular familiarity with the code base.

>which would be against the very nature of OSS

The very nature of OSS is not against monetizing.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by CaptArmchair on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:37AM (#25036546)
> Using "commerical licenses" hurts every use cases that is not profit based.

At the end of the day, people still have to eat.

The direct consequence of releasing you work under a copyleft license is that you have to figure out an alternate source of income in order to sustain yourself.

You could do that by providing paid consultancy, or by selling a product. It's perfectly valid to have a full time day job as an employee to sustain yourself, and do related or totally unrelated open source on the side. It's valid to start your own business providing consultancy based on your own open source project. Or maybe own a business on something entirely unrelated. To put it even to the extreme: you could be homesteading in the outback, living on cans of beans and rice while writing open source code on a dingy laptop powered by a generator and a satellite uplink each night.

My point is that covering your primary needs by making an income should come before any considerations to provide free labour.

In fact, this principle extends beyond open source code and to any creative endeavour. For instance, many famous writers didn't write full time. Kurt Vonnegut managed a Saab car dealership and J.D. Salinger was an entertainment director aboard a cruise ship at one point.

Copyleft isn't a business model. And one should interpret "business model" in the broadest sense of the word here: figuring out your personal finances and how you make an income is privy to the notion.

Copyleft protects the creator exactly because it isn't a business model in itself. Copyleft doesn't guarantee any support or continued maintainership towards users. It is not an SLA. There's zero obligation on your part, as a creator, to maintain anything you release on account of what users might want. You're entirely free to walk away.

As far as users are concerned, if they decide to rely on open source, they also accept the risks that comes with using third party code which doesn't get maintained or even gets abandoned. That's not a problem of the creator, that's entirely the problem of those who rely on open source code. Copyleft protects users to the extent that they are entirely free to fork your code and do whatever they want with it as long as they use the same copyleft terms if they decide to publish their modifications.

The perceived robustness of Linux by users actually translates into a due sense of trust in an emerging collective behaviour: that there will always be a wide community of maintainers working on the codebase either being paid or voluntary. But that trust isn't a formal, legal SLA at any given point.

Those are the consequences that come with deciding to maintain or use open source software.

Yes, it's true that there are several companies who have leveraged open source to unrivalled financial and business success. And it's also true that there are plenty of maintainers who barely see a tuppence for their long hours at night herding issue queues and reviewing pull requests.

Pitting them against each other isn't the way forward. If Amazon or Facebook are using open source software in order to sell their services to the tune of billions of dollars, then that's not solely because of Torvalds' decision to put Linux out there under the GPL license. It's equally because they understood and managed other aspects such as legal compliance, financial / asset management, human resources management, sales, marketing, acquiring and mergers,...

The problem there isn't the apparent 'abuse' of copyleft tools in it's own right. It's a far more complex set of economic, political, financial, cultural, ideological,... variables that created a unique context that allowed those companies to emerge.

The biggest fallacy open source maintainers face is that they are somehow obliged to boundlessly cater to the wishes, desires and needs of communities that emerge around their projects for next to nothing. Even when those communities attract developer teams from Fortune 500 companies.

They are not, that's the whole premise of both copyleft AND copyright.

If you want to give your work away unrestricted and free while pouring in endless amounts of hours, days and weeks, that's totally fine. Just don't be surprised that doing that full time without further consideration won't make you rent at the end of the month. At the end of the day, there simply isn't such thing as a free lunch.

After 20 years, I can tell you that neither closed or open source are better in absolute terms. They both have their drawbacks and their advantages. I've ran into specific business cases where closed source solution clearly was the better option; and vice versa as well.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by secretcoderz on Monday November 09, 2020 @05:34PM (#25040774)
Maybe because he’s banned from a bunch of open source communities for threatening comments and being an asshole. Oh and also was arrested in September for having bomb making materials.

https://nypost.com/2020/09/16/resident-of-nyc-home-with-susp...

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by jiofih on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:02AM (#25036147)
He was one of the founders of Nodejitsu, acquired by godaddy in 2015. I wonder if he ended up not seeing any of that acquisition money?
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by unreal37 on Monday November 09, 2020 @11:56AM (#25036784)
To be honest, any small 3-person company "acquired" and then promptly shut down, probably was just a fancy way to close the business.

Each person got a job with a signing bonus. And the investors may have gotten their money back.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by trevyn on Monday November 09, 2020 @03:34AM (#25032612)
Playing a gig at a coffee shop for tips and not compromising on your vision seems like a solid choice to me.
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by black_puppydog on Monday November 09, 2020 @06:16AM (#25033575)
> Making the world a better place by allowing big corporations to generate solid fake test data for their QA flows.

--- Random Guy in a random Silicon Valley episode

Not compromising your vision? Not to belittle Marak's work here, it's certainly valuable, but it doesn't sound like something that one does to make the world better, but like something that is useful (nearly) only in a corporate context and should be done for a decent salary.

But you know, that's just like, my opinion...

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by hazz99 on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:16AM (#25033947)
I think regardless of the repository, participation in the FOSS ecosystem strengthens it and encourages more people to join. The very act of doing so makes the world a better place, indirectly.

It's not the same as boots-on-ground charity work, no. But it's something.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by black_puppydog on Monday November 09, 2020 @09:26AM (#25035101)
Yes, I don't want to say I disagree with their work, not at all!

And while I thought this is classic corporate-centric coding, some people [1] seem to have a strong relationship with this:

> Faker is love. Faker is life. I applaud this move. Someone sponsor this man!

I can't edit the GP anymore, but it really seems to be a beloved tool. I guess we love the tools we use, even if they ultimately benefit someone else. :)

[1]: https://github.com/Marak/faker.js/issues/1046#issuecomment-7...

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by prepend on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:32AM (#25034070)
Definitely, it would be nice. A key to this approach is being able to survive based on tips alone.

It will make me really frustrated if I play for tips and then yell about how listeners should pay be $100k.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by Kaze404 on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:44AM (#25034148)
The difference here is that you have thousands of listeners, and some of them are recording your music to sample in their #1 album.
Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by prepend on Monday November 09, 2020 @07:53AM (#25034224)
Then it’s pretty easy to stop playing for tips or perhaps stop hanging out a sign that says “feel free to sample without paying me or even referencing me.”

If I’m playing for tips, have thousands of listeners, and making an amount of money that doesn’t make me happy then that’s a good sign to stop doing that because people don’t value my music as much as I do.

It’s really hard to understand what makes an album #1 as there’s so many factors. I think that’s why it’s so important to set up licenses beforehand. I don’t think it’s reasonable that I’m entitled to any percentage of a #1 album just because they sampled my CC-commercial licensed music.

Re:No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This by Aeolun on Monday November 09, 2020 @06:14AM (#25033571)
Until your house burns down.