Ships anchors and trawlers are major risks for subsea cables. Deeper is thus better.
Underwater geography is also a major consideration. It's not just the going up and down, it's the risk of landslides, tectonic shifts, volcanoes, currents and icebergs scraping the ocean floor.
On top of that are geopolitics and enviromental concerns.
1901 telegraph submarine cables [1] were more straight for a similar route. Likely because it was essential to make them as short as possible going underwater, so most of them were going from Ireland to Newfoundland.
[1] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/a5/1901_Eas...
The other possibility is that the direct path passes underwater mountainous region with quite variable depths in mid-Atlantic [1], so going up-down or follow the valleys anyway would increase the cable length. The right answer is likely a combination of all these to minimize cable cost, maintenance and latency.
[1] https://earth.google.com/web/@41.47661069,-40.80459324,-4414...