Civilization has multiple centers on Earth and always has, not simply the US East Coast. The GPL has carried on for three+ decades, and look what has exploded in that time. What comes next? A legal framework must engage its epoch, and times change, of course. Massive forces are at work right now, with acceleration.
Free as in Freedom
The same could be said about your analysis. She, at the least, engages the reader to think about Capitalist Property Rights. It's also a small snippet of a larger text/essay, so I would ask you to please consider reading the whole thing before you make up your mind about her positions and overall vision.
> Civilization has multiple centers on Earth and always has, not simply the US East Coast. The GPL has carried on for three+ decades, and look what has exploded in that time. What comes next? A legal framework must engage its epoch, and times change, of course. Massive forces are at work right now, with acceleration.
> Free as in Freedom
I honestly have no idea what you are talking about here, and you provide no useful rebuttal to the points she brings up.
The difference is:
The old system produces social status for daily use by ordinary people. You work at a day job and your parents, your partner, your children, your peers all know about that.
The hacker culture doesn't have a method to do that. It can only produce fame, which is only usable for a few individuals.
The old system needs adjustments. More and more people see that property alone nowadays makes a suboptimal signal of status.
There are now more people who care about these things and more quality Free software available than ever before in human history! It's just that the complacent open-source idea, as well as proprietary software (biggest offenders are locked smartphones, etc), have spread even faster :(
I don't think the movement has weak foundations nor that it is politically naive. In my eyes it goes directly to the problem it cares about, which is human freedom in the context of using a computer. It doesn't oppose commerce, but it is aware of the current socio-political order's (i.e. capitalism's) tendency to turn anything into a sellable commodity.
If that counts as a victory, however, it was a pyrrhic one. In the process of gaining mainstream popularity, the social movement of “free software”—which rejected the very idea of treating software as intellectual property—morphed into the more palatable notion of “open source” as a development methodology, in which free and proprietary software could happily co-exist. The corporations that latched onto the movement discovered a useful technique for developing software, but jettisoned the critique of property rights that formed its ideological foundation.
Yet it was precisely the weakness of that foundation that made the free software movement vulnerable to co-optation in the first place. The movement’s greatest limitation was its political naivete. Even as it attacked the idea of software as property, it failed to connect its message to a wider analysis that acknowledged the role of property rights within a capitalist framework. Free software pioneers like Stallman tended to approach the issue from an individualized perspective, drawn from the 1970s-1980s hacker culture that many of them came from: if you could change how enough hackers wrote and used software, you could change the world. This highly personalized model of social change proposed an individual solution to a structural problem, which necessarily neglected the wider social context."
+
"the neoliberal consensus of the last few decades has meant that the benefits of technological development have largely flowed to corporations, under the aegis of a strong intellectual property regime. As the free software movement came up against these prevailing economic forces, its more contentious aspects were watered down or discarded. The result was “open source”: a more collaborative method of writing software that bore few traces of its subversive origins."
— Wendy Liu, https://logicmag.io/failure/freedom-isnt-free/