But I don't think it will disincentive new companies starting out. They have a hundred other concerns more important than how the CEO will be taxed if they one day become huge and the CEO has extremely high compensation. It won't even factor into the decision of where to locate the company. Also, you should notice most highly compensated CEOs are not founders. Founders don't need to compensate themselves that heavily because they own a large chunk of the equity. Simple capital gains or dividends are the favourite forms of compensation for founders.
Since founders, by definition, are the ones deciding where to found the company, they won't care at all about this law.
The new law includes equity comp in the calculation. Not sure how or if they'll amortize founder equity over many years, though; they may just consider the value in the year it's granted or the year it vests.
On the other hand, the law does cover gross receipts, so the act of “paying” the CEO in stocks is subject to taxation at the point in time the CEO receives it as part of their income.
That is technically true, but this is where it gets tricky.
If you joined a public company (this will work with private too, if you weren't the founder, but let's not thing about it for the sake of simplicity for now) as the CEO, this will work out perfectly just like you described. You got all those shares at joining, you pay tax on their value at the time. As you get more shares, you get taxed on their value as soon as you receive them. If you decide to sell those shares, you don't get taxed on the initial value of them (since you already got taxed on it when you received the shares), only on the profits you made at the moment of sale (or you get your taxable income reduced due to losses, in case the share price went down between the moment you received the shares and the moment you sold them). So far so good.
If you started your own company, you initially hold the shares that are worth nothing, so you aren't really taxed on them. If you don't continue receiving new shares, but instead just hold onto the initial ones, you only get taxed on them when you sell them (since when you "received" them originally, they were worth nothing). Does Zucc receive more shares over time? I don't think so, he is just holding onto his original shares (while, no doubt, selling some and getting taxed on them), so this law will not affect him one bit unless he receives more shares.
Not trying to discredit your theory, your overall point is correct, I just wanted to add more nuance.
P.S. I am not an expert on this by any means, so if someone can correct me (especially on the "starting your own company" scenario), please do so. I find this a fascinating topic, and I try to answer as accurately as I can. But since I didn't experience that scenario myself, I can definitely be wrong or missing some details.
How many startups are there where the executives make 100x to 200x the median employee pay? That only happens via stock-based compensation at public companies. If that's the case, they're not a startup.
Prediction: Many lower-paid staff will be outsourced (Think Apple and Foxconn; Think big companies and their outsourced cleaning company).
Currently, typically things like cleaning staff, internal mail, dining get outsourced. Expect customer support to also start getting outsourced. The unfortunate thing is that now there would be a middle-person also collecting a spread from the company/worker (but to the company, the spread will be lower than the tax.)
"Lead executor"
"Company Chief"
"Dear Leader"
"Head Director"
"Paramount Leader"
"Viceroy"
"Corporate Emperor"
Emperor for Life
Grand PoohBah
The talented workforce is there because of the companies. Why would someone deliberately choose to live in San Fran when given the choice of many cleaner, nicer cities with a lower cost of living?
I guess if you really like fog and hills
The Silicon Valley wasn't nominated as the tech hub overnight, it became one through an organic process thanks to a mix of good weather, access to capital, a pool of talented employees etc.
Don't take any of that for granted (well except the weather I guess, but with Global Warming and earthquakes who knows).
Years ago, Denver placed a tax on companies that create software. By "magic", companies decided to found outside the county lines including Boulder. Boulder has an active software scene. Denver is getting there, but still not the advanced companies Boulder has. I believe Denver recalled the tax, but unsure.
Does it? Startups probably start out with a fairly small Executive Pay Ratio because they start out without a lot of low-paid grunts, and its already not common for them to open satellite facilities or move HQs for grunt work when they scale out to more jobs where they aren't trying to attract locally-concentrated elite talent. Because its triggered on the ratio between the highest paid managerial employee anywere in the firm and the median pay of employees in the City, it really just adds further incentives to do low-level gruntwork outside of the city, but doesn't seem otherwise to really change the structural incentives much for startups.
OTOH, it does make it more expensive for any widespread organization whose headquarters and elite labor are elsewhere to operate a facility with mostly low-level labor in the City; a tech startup headquartered in the City might never be hit by it even as they scaled up if they are focussed on automation, as they might never have a low-paid workforce. OTOH, retail, etc., outlets, hotels, etc., of firms with highly-paid executives with their main executive and high-paid labor force outside of the city would be hit hard (as far as compared to other firms, I don't think the tax rate is ever high enough to really be "hit hard") by it on their operations in the City.
I think it’s gonna disincentivize FAANGs from making future investments in the city. This is BAAAAD timing for a tax hike like this, coming off tech companies doing a seven month experiment in whole-company WFH, and finding out it’s working pretty well.
I would say that SF doesn’t want to incentivize future growth. That’s the source of the inequality, right?
> people who "barely pay any tax at all" are worth helping
Millionaire property owners are barely paying any taxes. Disneyland and every other large commercial building is barely paying any taxes. Why are they worth helping?
Similarly, while I do think everyone is worth helping, I'm not yet seeing how this helps millionaires and large landlords.
A transfer tax says, "oh, the owner change - here's the same tax for a money losing project as an extremely profitable one". It's just disincentivizing change.
This tax is even being talked about because things like CA Prop 15 being voted down leave schools/cities underfunded by giving long time land owners a massive tax break.
We need to make the system more fair not just tax everything that moves.
So you're saying entrepreneurs wouldn't start companies in SF because some day their companies will pay 0.1% tax if they make 100x the average employee?
That's all it takes for founders to get discouraged? Well then maybe they should not start up in the first place.
I think that if companies do suck it up and pay, it will be declared an effective law and then...the there will be proposals to expand it. It might dip down to also include SVPs, then VPs, and so on
Come on... There's a million reasons why new startups shouldn't start here, the salary of a CEO is not one of them.
I suspect that this would collect a lot more money from today's Hiltons and Marriots than FAANGs; its not like FAANGs employ a lot of people at bottom-of-the-barrel wages in SF.
It doesn't have to be food trucks exactly, that's just an industry that people like in a business that's relatively simple and imo has low systemic risk.
Those that don't will expect a steep discount.
Meanwhile those people who take the risk and it doesn't work out will still have bills and rent to pay.
How do you prevent over-crowding of a location, and flow-on effect of crowds from said truck?
How do you make sure the waste products are sanely disposed?
And a million other concerns from third parties unrelated to the business, but is affected by its existence?
I'm definitely open to discussions about how to help people incapable of raising a couple hundred bucks and lacking the skills to cook a hot dog. I'm not claiming to attempt to solve every problem.
As I say I'm asking from ignorance. I also realise I'm likely to get somewhat biased answers to that view point on HN.
We shall see though, and hopefully sooner rather than later.
But to build empire you have to be in denial of that fact.
You want to incentivize future growth too, and you want to make sure that 20 years down the line, you have the new FAANGs of the world giving you millions in tax dollars, because history has shown that the largest of companies can eventually die out, and tech is full of graveyards.
What this does is, it collects money from today's FAANGs while disincentivizing future startups from starting here.
This is akin to the boiling frog fable (yes I know it's fake but the point of the fable stands), except the city is the one putting itself in the cauldron and raising the temperature by chipping away bit by bit the things that make the bay area a good place to live and invest in.