News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xvector on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:36PM (#24993306)
The point is that the media gets up in arms about criminal activity and money laundering with cryptocurrency but rarely ever reports crimes of a much greater magnitude made by “legitimate” institutions like banks.

Someone money launders with crypto and it’s on the front page. A bank launders hundreds of times more and it’s just another day. Perhaps you could say it’s because of the novelty of crypto, but I suspect the motives run deeper - crypto is a threat to modern financial institutions and turning public interest against crypto is in the best interests of the establishment.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by kmeisthax on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:38PM (#24993784)
Money laundering in traditional finance is a problem of scale: there's far too much of it and we don't police it well enough. The problem is tractable given enough enforcement tools and resources. Bitcoin's different - it has little AML control so it's super easy to write money laundering tools. Monero is even worse. Money laundering is built into the protocol, to the point where being able to determine the chain-of-custody over some funds is computationally infeasible. Cryptocurrency is designed to increase the scope of money laundering rather than just the scale, because it makes money laundering the default.

Think about how difficult it was to enforce copyright law in 1970 versus 2010. In the former, copyright enforcement was a matter of having enough lawyers to sue enough enterprises. In 2010, everyone has a commercial-scale copyright infringement device in their pocket. You practically can't enforce the law to the same level purely because the targets are too small and numerous and going after them is a PR nightmare. This is why the music industry fought against consumer-grade recording technology for so long (and lost). Regulating large businesses is a fundamentally more tractable form of law enforcement than individuals.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by chii on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:53PM (#24994664)
> Monero is even worse. Money laundering is built into the protocol, to the point where being able to determine the chain-of-custody over some funds is computationally infeasible. Cryptocurrency is designed to increase the scope of money laundering rather than just the scale, because it makes money laundering the default.

I would replace 'money laundering' with privacy and anonymity.

These properties are desirable. These properties give the individual undertaking the transaction a semblance of control. These properties prevent authorities from taking that control away except by using the law, which i think is a fairly good way to enforce control.

So if the individual feel that the law is unfair, they have the option to _not_ obey. If enough people choose to _not_ obey, it forces the court's hand and legislator's hand - this serves society.

Under centralized control, the individual does not have the option to not obey, because their transactions require approval from authorities. This approval becomes a chilling effect for change, and it makes it easy to target them before the general society is able to transition or understand. Civil disobedience is thus impossible under centralized control.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by kls on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @09:12PM (#24995067)
Right I had to explain this to someone last time this subject came up. Illegal != immoral, take for example the Jews in Nazi Germany because it's required by the internet to invoke Nazis :) . Anyways, had cryptocurrencies existed when the some Jews were trying to escape Germany, and had those Jews moved their assets into crypto it would have certainly been illegal but that does not mean it would have been immoral. There are quite a few people in which anonymous funds not trackable by the government lends to their moral cause, though that cause may very well be illegal in their country.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by eli on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:52PM (#24993410)
"The media" didn't vote this article to the front page of HN.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xvector on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:43PM (#24993817)
HN is not immune to propaganda.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by ndesaulniers on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @08:03PM (#24994712)
or what-about-ism, it would seem.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by crtasm on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:58PM (#24993457)
I don't know what media you read but I see stories in The Guardian about banks laundering money when it comes to light.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by bpodgursky on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:57PM (#24993447)
OK, but the real economy is about 10,000,000x larger than the crypto economy.

The point is that a huge fraction of the crypto economy is outright extortion or fraud, not that it's the source of all evil in the world.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:10PM (#24993558)
> a huge fraction of the crypto economy is outright extortion or fraud

I'm not sure that's true. Do you have a citation?

What is clear is that a huge portion of the crypto economy is based around cryptocurrencies (particularly bitcoin) being financial assets.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:16PM (#24993606)
> citation

While it's good to check sources, keep in mind that original research is also valid.

After all, you made a similarly uncited assertion.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:23PM (#24993665)
I don't think there is any point to saying something like that.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:26PM (#24993688)
Because you don't think I'll change anyone's behavior or opinion? I'm holding out hope.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @06:09PM (#24994020)
What behavior of mine do you think I should change? I didn't see any suggestion of something I actually did wrong. It felt like you were trying to criticize, but that your criticism had no actual content.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @06:37PM (#24994194)
> no actual content

Indeed, the criticism is not of the facts but of the logic. My critique is primarily of your rhetoric. You requested a citation without offering a rebuttal. Yet, you you made a claim that appears to be equally well-founded, or as you're implying, un-founded.

Saying "citation needed" is a somewhat bland, passive-aggressive statement that itself lacks content. I'd have (and still would) appreciate reading the rationale for your skepticism.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Thursday November 05, 2020 @05:39AM (#24997133)
I'm not interested in arguing with you for its own sake. I'm just saying the following because I don't like to see the kind of behavior in this community that I think is going on here (and I don't think it's intentional, fwiw).

Your criticism of me amounts to the fact that I asked for a citation of a statement I was skeptical about. I think that's pretty plainly not a legitimate criticism.

I think that you are the one who is being passive aggressive here.

If you thought my comment was passive aggressive, you could have just said so. (It generally is not passive aggressive to ask for a citation, but I can see how someone could think that.)

If you wanted me to explain the rationale for my statement, you could have just directly asked, instead of criticizing me in the way you did, which seems indirect and unfair.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Thursday November 05, 2020 @03:02PM (#25001429)
I'm not interested in arguing for it's own sake either. I spoke up to fight a frustrating trend in internet argumentation.

> ... pretty plainly not a legitimate criticism

What's plain to you isn't plain to me, and vice versa. I think you missed the main thrust of my argument, which is getting at the hypocrisy of asking for a citation and then making an uncited claim. Perhaps more importantly, it's asking for logical argument to accompany requests for a source.

There's a related issue in the current scientific paradigm, fetishizing statistical p-values. People are so distracted by the veneer of a p-value (or a citation) that they forget to look for a plausible causal mechanism.

By the way, you still haven't explained your skepticism of the original statement you replied to.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Thursday November 05, 2020 @06:39PM (#25003330)
> getting at the hypocrisy of asking for a citation and then making an uncited claim

A person asking for a citation is not disallowed from making a claim. Someone else is free to ask for a citation from me, in return.

You are not only incorrect, which is fine, but you're unjustly calling me a hypocrite, which, personally, I consider to be a rather non-nice thing to say.

Furthermore, my request for a "citation" was supposed to be equivalent to asking for "any sort of rationale." You are interpreting that overly legalistically. I'm was just trying to have a conversation, OK? And I did it in a polite way. I would have been happy to hear a rationale that was not a citation per se. It would even have been OK for the person I was responding to to say, "I don't know, I just suspect it," or "I heard it anecdotally," or whatever.

> There's a related issue in the current scientific paradigm, fetishizing statistical p-values. People are so distracted by the veneer of a p-value (or a citation) that they forget to look for a plausible causal mechanism.

I agree, although that's not related to my behavior here.

I'm annoyed by the same thing you are, which is when people use "citation?" as though it's a counter-argument. But I wasn't doing that. I wish I had just said, "What's your rationale for saying that." But you know what? I can't predict when someone is going to misinterpret a perfectly reasonable and polite thing I've said.

I think the thing I was responding to is exactly the (rare) kind of thing where an actual citation probably is the kind of answer someone with a rationale would want to give, as opposed to a causal explanation or some other sort of evidence. So you're preaching to the choir, here. I get what you're saying, i.e., that many people ask for citations in a context where a citation doesn't really make sense (for example, a controversial medical claim where there are probably numerous studies that seem to disagree with one another). This just isn't that sort of context. I could see myself making the same point you are making in a different context. It annoys me to be lumped in with those people that you and I are both justifiably annoyed by.

> By the way, you still haven't explained your skepticism of the original statement you replied to.

I just don't think it's true. I know that cryptocurrency is being treated as a financial asset. I haven't seen evidence that extortion or fraud are a major fraction of what's going on with cryptocurrency. I have enough familiarity and experience with the field to think that my sense of this is probably correct.

Bitcoin is 66% of the market cap of cryptocurrency. It's clear that bitcoin is being used widely as a financial asset (it's available in multiple funds you can get in brokerage accounts, there are many high-volume OTC desks, there are derivatives, there is now lending). There is a lot of journalism showing that large sums of money are flowing into bitcoin as a financial asset; for example, the company MicroStrategy purchasing $425M of bitcoin, or Robinhood facilitating bitcoin trading, or GBTC accepting inflows of hundreds of millions of dollars to purchase bitcoin.

In contrast, I'm aware of ransomware, but I suspect it's probably a very small fraction of the bitcoin/cryptocurrency economy (but, as I said originally, I would be interested to see evidence contrary to that). My sense is that it's pretty hard to effectively launder money with cryptocurrency, unless you stay out of the US and Europe and parts of Asia, i.e., unless you stay in the places where it's already probably easier to launder money. But again, that's just my sense, so if someone has an explanation contrary to that, I'd be interested to see it, which is why I asked.

I view many of the smaller crypto coins as scams, so there is actually an interpretation of OP's statement that I agree with - I guess it depends on how you define "fraud" and "a huge fraction." Again, bitcoin is 66% and is clearly not a scam (though it would be fair to ask why that's clear if someone doesn't already know - but my answer right now would be, go research it yourself, I can't take the time to explain all that). Bitcoiners may be misguided or wrong, but it's not a scam.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Thursday November 05, 2020 @08:41PM (#25004040)
You've confused a critique of your rhetoric for a critique of yourself. There's no need to defend a turn of phrase so vigorously. If you'd just led off with, "No, I didn't mean it like that," as you've done here, then I'd have shut up. I mean, come on, surely you recognize how "Do you have a citation?" falls into the camp that both of us apparently dislike.

Anyway, back to the topic of Bitcoin. I think your assessment is right in that the bulk of Bitcoin transactions are speculative investments. However, given that the value of Bitcoin as an asset lies in its assumed eventual use as a currency, the original comment might also be correct in that non-speculative transactions are predominantly related to illicit activities. I'm unaware of any common legitimate purpose beyond financial speculation.

When one thinks of world trade, there's (these numbers are from a faded memory of an international trade class about 2 decades ago, so they're horribly wrong) something like $50 billion in goods exported daily. That's the world economy. Then there's $500 billion in currency derivatives traded daily to ostensibly enable exports across currencies, but it's really just speculation. It's not real trade. So when someone talks about the Bitcoin economy, it's hard to know whether we should be talking about just the actual economic activity conducted using Bitcoin as a currency, or whether we should include the speculative trades as well.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Friday November 06, 2020 @08:48PM (#25012694)
> You've confused a critique of your rhetoric for a critique of yourself.

If you call my comment hypocritical, I think you're calling me hypocritical. Apparently you don't think so. That's fine. It could be a cultural difference. Let's not litigate it.

> There's no need to defend a turn of phrase so vigorously. If you'd just led off with, "No, I didn't mean it like that," as you've done here, then I'd have shut up.

I don't think this is a charitable thing to say. If there was no need for me to defend it, there was no need for you to "attack" (criticize) my comment in the first place. If you don't agree, that's fine. Again, let's not litigate it.

> I mean, come on, surely you recognize how "Do you have a citation?" falls into the camp that both of us apparently dislike.

I don't agree. As I already explained, I think it's OK to ask for a citation, in a certain context. I don't think I was doing the thing you're complaining about and which annoys me. If you disagree, that's fine. Let's not litigate it.

I would have liked for you to find a way to continue communicating without continuing to criticize, but it didn't happen. Oh well. Let's call this conversation finished. Take care. On the bitcoin stuff you are bringing up, that looks fine to me. I don't have anything more to say about that.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by xapata on Friday November 06, 2020 @11:23PM (#25013204)
Yeah, it's interesting how similar our viewpoints are, including the stubborn itch to debate rhetoric. Have a good evening.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by kylebenzle on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:54PM (#24993424)
Also, HN inexplicably hates Bitcoin. Also why this comment will be removed.
Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by labster on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:01PM (#24993480)
If you'd like me to explain why I hate Bitcoin, look no further than the Bitcoin Energy Consumption Index[0], which currently has Bitcoin using the same energy consumption as the nation of Chile. It provides less utility than a credit card, all while using 779092 times the energy needed per transaction.

I don't think it's inexplicable that we hate an ongoing environmental disaster.

[0]: https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by javert on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:12PM (#24993574)
Saying bitcoin provides less utility than a credit card is missing the point the bitcoin people are making.

You can still hold that bitcoin is bad, but that particular argument is not viable and comes from ignoring what the other side is saying.

Re:Silk Road Bitcoins worth $1B transferred after seven years by ahallock on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:06PM (#24993527)
You're not wrong. HN seems heavily biased against anything crypto. With Paypal, Square, MicroStrategy, and even JPMorgan adpoting/investing in Bitcoin, I think it's becoming legitimate.