The phone icon used everywhere depicts a corded type (without the cord) that was last popular in the 90s. After that there was a wireless version, then flip-phones, then smartphones.
So actually about the same number of iterations out of date.
Icons are good at representing objects but terrible at representing behavior over time unless it's simple directional movement. How would you symbolize something like the concept of persistence? "Data that can be retrieved unchanged in the future"? A pen, a clock with progression arrows on the hands, and reading glasses? Surely not if there's already an established convention available. The floppy disk happens to be that convention, as the last object that was unambiguously connected to local storage (an optical disk would be ambiguous for recorded music consumption, HDD were supposed to be invisible to the regular user and USB sticks could just as well be any of a variety of radio interfaces in the same form factor). So floppy disk it is. And it's not a problem at all that the convention, once established, is now used by generations that have never seen a floppy, it's just visual language to them. Complaining about the lack of connect between that language and the life realities of it's users seems to me as pointless as complaining that the word dog does not sound like barking at all (why not whoofwhoof?) or that the word hammer does not sound like the noise of hammering (why not banger?).
And still, the floppy disk icon is in decline, because applications that eschew local storage tend to use the "arrow up to cloud" icon. Another convention that has absolutely nothing to do with what is actually going on (few datacenters are actually hidden in clouds)
I think that the 3.5 diskette will have staying power since the trend in applications is to constantly persist. The icons needed have shifted to SCM-like commit, branch, fork, diff, merge, revert. However, these are conceptually very abstract compared to "Save."
Yes, I know. I'm not arguing that it is unworkable or a detriment to the function of some system.
Again, why did we stop with disks? Right or wrong that's what happened. Why?
There were punch cards and tapes and other stuff before disks. There have been flash devices and cloud services and other stuff since. Yet, for some possibly interesting reason we got stuck on disks, and floppy disks in particular.
The disks are mechanical devices, so their shape is dictated by function and thus was uniform. E.g. USB flash drives do not have such consistency.
What the endgame of symbols look like is easy to see in Chinese / Japanese. E.g. "save" 保 consists of a man, a mouth, and a tree. It's about as easy to make sense of as a combination of a square with a cut corner and a rectangle inside it.
Interesting example. It's worth pointing out here that most characters are not composed entirely of meaning-indicating components; there is e.g. a whole series of compounds of 青 which use it solely to indicate the pronunciation of the compound, not to claim that invitations (请) are somehow metaphysically green (青).
But 保 is an exception! Going by wiktionary, it originates as a compound of 人 and 子, both used for the meaning -- protecting is what people do with babies. (Interestingly, the character 仔 exists independently today.) Evolution of the component on the right into 呆 was purely based on shape, and transformed the original meaningful component into something completely arbitrary -- there was no point at which 口 and 木 (as separate from 呆) were conceptually part of the character.
It's not obsolete in Japanese.
Likewise, the follow on technologies to small portable storage did not have distinctive and ubiquitous shapes. Maybe a long rectangle with a short end against a square would represent a flash drive? I think that a sibling comment about the 3.5” diskette being present at the birth of GUIs must be part of the answer too since the world didn’t immediately transition to flash drives and other media. All lived together for quite a while.
Looking at “floppy icon” search results leads me to believe that many icon designers have never seen an actual 3.5” diskette. On many the shutter is too wide and could not slide open, on others the rotor mating surface is classic iPod low.
> There were punch cards and tapes and other stuff before disks.
The floppy was the ubiquitous removable storage medium for the first microcomputers with GUIs.
I point that out to ask this: why hasn't a better, more general icon representing the concept of persisting something emerged? I've seen many attempts (various arrows with lines and whatnot,) but they don't stand alone very well. Certainly not as well as a crummy old floppy disk icon (at least for those that know what they looked like.) It's as if as soon as we began using something we couldn't detach and hold in hand we ceased being able to represent what was happening.