News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by nlavezzo on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @06:43PM (#24985298)
Just like jet plane rides, air conditioning, cell phones, etc. were only for the rich and powerful initially. Capitalism encourages efficiencies which drive prices down over time.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by falcolas on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:02PM (#24985431)
I'm fairly certain it's the efficiencies of scale, not capitalism, that makes previously experimental products affordable.

Capitalism, all other things disregarded, would just keep the price high so long as the demand is high and the supply low.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by sdfin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:04PM (#24985445)
But would also welcome and allow competition if any businessman wishes to enter a profitable market.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by falcolas on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:09PM (#24985479)
One merely has to look at speculative fiction to see that the upsides in letting this technology become available to everyone are non-existant to those who help fund its creation. A monopoly around this technology would form faster than DeBeers could say "Wow" - legal or not.

Human nature plus immortality is not a pretty thing to think about.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by philipkglass on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @09:01PM (#24986010)
If a cure is invented in Country X and monopolized, every other country in the world has an incentive to replicate it by some combination of espionage and reverse engineering. If it can be invented at all, what makes you think that it can be used without other parties figuring out how to copy it? The atomic bomb was duplicated within 4 years.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @02:04AM (#24986938)
This is not about countries, it is about the rich and powerful vs the rest of us. Do you think the rich in the US would steal the secret of eternal youth from the rich of China and just give it to everyone? Or just keep it for themselves?
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by ben_w on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @04:57AM (#24987712)
The rich? Perhaps, perhaps not, depends how much money they could make from it. Some biohacker equivalent to Linus Torvalds or Aaron Swartz? Almost certainly, and for free.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by sdfin on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:12AM (#24988312)
What you say seems to imply that every rich person is an evil and greedy. There are philantropists too.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by Banana699 on Thursday November 05, 2020 @05:17AM (#24997019)
Hey, I'm also not a fan of "Rich Bad!" simplistic narratives, but billionaire "philanthropy" is about the most dubious and laughable concept on the table here. It's pennies-on-the-dollar nature is carefully designed to dupe your statistics-naive hind brain into believing there is something being done when it's really the opposite ; it's the microoptimization of the economic world, equivalent to transforming a multiplication-by-two into shifting while the code above you is allocating one million boxed objects. Just a small, pointless thing you do to make yourself feel better for no actual reason.

A few millions here and there, no matter what they do or how much happiness they cause, is nothing compared to billions upon billions^(TM) continuesly pumped out of the world into one person's coffers.

I don't care what kind of persons billionaires are, allowing someone to have wealth equivalent to several countries' economies is ugly and injust. No amount of gift-giving and hospital-visiting is gonna make that any less of a moral disaster. Maybe when we discover arbitary-destination wormholes can we be that inefficient and injust with resources distribution, but with just one freaking planet? good luck convincing me (and the several billions who are not billionaires) that philanthropist billionaire overthere isn't stealing somebody's (probably several million somebodies) food in their pointless unending quest to pile wealth they're not going to use 10% of in their wildest dreams.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:08AM (#24988297)
Did these rich people stop wanting money?
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:07AM (#24988286)
It's an easy way to generate conflict in fiction. You can't use it as evidence of non-existent benefits any more than you can cite fiction for why you're legitimately worried about zombies.

And how is a monopoly going to form? You think people are going to refuse to eat synthetic diamonds-that-make-you-stop-aging because of marketing around getting "the real thing"? And you can't buy out all the mines for something that isn't dug up.

> Human nature plus immortality is not a pretty thing to think about.

Whatever. People are still going to get cancer.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by ben_w on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @05:00AM (#24987730)
Fiction is not a good place to find evidence, else CERN would be busy looking for dilithium crystals for their antiproton factory: https://home.cern/science/accelerators/antiproton-decelerato...
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by sdfin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:16PM (#24985520)
Do you believe that in a communist country something different would happen?
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by nostromo on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:07PM (#24985467)
> Capitalism, all other things disregarded, would just keep the price high so long as the demand is high and the supply low.

You're confusing capitalism the system with individual businesses.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by croon on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @08:44AM (#24988935)
Capitalism isn't a system, it's a tool applicable within a system.

And it's not an individual business thing. Capitalism is amoral (note: not immoral), with a value function. If in a scenario it behaves what we consider "badly", we provide incentives to skew that value function towards what our society wants. For example through taxes or subsidies.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by falcolas on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:10PM (#24985490)
Capitalism's endgame is a monopoly. Why do you believe that this technology would somehow be exempt from this?
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by sdfin on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @07:19PM (#24985541)
I think that capitalism's endgame may be a post-scarcity society, where technology allows us to have almost free energy, and very cheap everything that we may require for survival, with minimum human work.
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by chillwaves on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @12:51AM (#24986665)
how do you figure?
Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by Mary-Jane on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @03:52AM (#24987396)
There's only so much money you can squeeze out of rich people; they tend to be, well, tightwads. The best way to earn more money is to reach more people (read: increase market share). You can think of prices as indicators of inefficiencies. The high price invites participation which causes competition. The players, driven by greed or desire for profit, seek to eliminate competition (or become monopolies in their field). With the right legal incentives this competition is healthy and innovation leads to lower prices to gain market share. Again, market share == people, and poor people are included in that group.

From this perspective, Capitalism (or "the market") can be viewed as a tool governments can use to increase the quality of life of its citizens.

Granted this explanation is a bit banal and hand wavey and leaves out a ton of stuff (consider impacts on jobs for instance); this is an internet post not a thesis on economics. :) Hayek, Mises, and Friedman are good sources if you care to explore more.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by chillwaves on Thursday November 05, 2020 @01:19AM (#24996063)
I just don't understand why rich people would need to share their resources with poor people at all if we live in a world that does not value labor.

Guy says "post-scarcity" but what does that really mean? Even if we have cheap energy and cheap raw goods, there will still be things that are limited, perhaps open space, nature preserves, beach property.

Or maybe even in a land of plenty, there will still be those who live in poverty (some would argue that poverty is a choice today).

I'm not sure what will be valuable in the future, but I am sure the rich will hoard it.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by tsimionescu on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @02:05AM (#24986948)
Capitalism is about profit. How could a post-scarcity society (assuming that were possible, which it isn't) further anyone's profits?

Further, under capitalism, you only get money from working. Minimum human work implies that most humans won't have any money of their own at all.

Re:Scientist David Sinclair on why we age and why he thinks ... by sdfin on Wednesday November 04, 2020 @07:15AM (#24988332)
Markets are about optimizing allocation of scarce resources. A post-scarcity society (if it were possible) would work differently.