News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by thrwyoilarticle on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:13PM (#24971132)
I have irrationally strong feelings about production car speed records.

Firstly,

>Bugatti's claimed 300-mph-breaking Chiron run was never going to count

As much as they would like to believe otherwise, Guiness World Records can not create truth. If the Chiron goes faster than the SSC, it's the fastest production car. That's it. Two way runs & proper filming are an important factor if you're trying to decide who gets the piece of paper but there's nothing 'official' about it. If someone goes faster but never tells anyone, they still went faster.

That is apart from one point: the Chiron isn't a production car. But neither is the SSC. Nor the Veyron nor the Agera RS. If you don't believe me, try to buy one. No matter how much money you have, or at what time you try to do it, you can't. All of these cars have extremely limited units sold only to people with an existing relationship with the company. All of them set records with special editions. That's just a modified car. If there are only 25 Agera RSes & every one is modified for the owner, how do you establish the one that did the record isn't just the equivalent of a binned, liquid oxygen-cooled CPU that dies after the record setting run? You can't even drive the Veyron away from a record setting attempt: you need to replace its $40000 tyres.

Bugatti's record was once in doubt because they deactivated the speed limiter for the run. This was later retracted because it's not actually about trying to set consistent rules, it's about creating marketing material for Volkswagen's halo car. Which is why they won't let anybody else run their faster cars on their track.

Other, assorted viewpoints:

- If your car is just a modified Lotus, it doesn't count.

- For bidirectional attempts, how can you say that a car has a top speed of C mph when C = A+B/2 mph and A>B? That's an invented figure.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by Traster on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:22PM (#24971253)
>- For bidirectional attempts, how can you say that a car has a top speed of C mph when C = A+B/2 mph and A>B? That's an invented figure.

I agree that (A+B)/2 is an invented figure, but I think the logic of "This is the maximum a car can do without external factors" is a reasonable thing to agree on as a top-speed, and wind is an external factor. Otherwise a lot of cars can set their top speed by being dropped from a sky scraper, and the testing would get unreasonably expensive. (A+B)/2 is probably a good first approximation to a wind-neutral value (and a gravity neutral value too).

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by wlesieutre on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:37PM (#24972157)
On that note, a Porsche 911 Turbo races 1 mile against a VW Beetle dropped from a helicopter. I won't spoil the ending.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SiAbcw5s9_8

But based on the Beetle's terminal velocity here, this strategy for setting a car's top speed will only work for cars that can't drive particularly fast.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by Sebb767 on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:32PM (#24973676)
Fun fact: That was probably still cheaper with the Beetle than a record run with the Veyron :)
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by LoSboccacc on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:12PM (#24974088)
especially considered the veyron dismantled and crashed in the test run https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_3LhIjV6aY&list=LLCR_Dw6p0b...
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by wlesieutre on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:07PM (#24974921)
The Beetle probably cost similar to one tire for the Veyron
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by lacker on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:44PM (#24972260)
Otherwise a lot of cars can set their top speed by being dropped from a sky scraper, and the testing would get unreasonably expensive.

Dropping a $25,000 Camry from an airplane might actually be cheaper than a single speed run of these hypercars, where they burn through a $40,000 set of tires....

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by 0xf8 on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:30PM (#24972853)
I highly doubt the terminal velocity of any production car is even close to the top speed records in discussion here.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by skykooler on Monday November 02, 2020 @04:17PM (#24973471)
I was curious, so I ran the numbers on a Toyota Camry. With a mass of 1447 kg, a cross-sectional area of 2.7 square meters, and a drag coefficient of 0.28, it would have a terminal velocity of 391 mph. Other cars which are both heavier and more aerodynamic (e.g. a Tesla Model S) could reach even higher top speeds.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by myself248 on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:02PM (#24973973)
You'd need some sort of drogue chute or fins to keep it pointed nose-down, otherwise it'd tumble like the Beetle in the Top Gear episode just posted.

Or maybe being a rear-engined car put the Beetle at a unique disadvantage, and the Camry would orient itself just fine.

Junkyards are easy, who's got a helicopter-pilot friend and some land?

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by snovv_crash on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:35PM (#24974287)
For it to be aerodynamically stable you need the center of mass to be less than ~25% from one end. I don't think a Camry or Model S will do that, it will need stabilization fins.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by NickNameNick on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:52PM (#24974860)
For the Tesla, it might help to fill the frunk with water containers. That should bring the center of mass forward and up a little.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by Taniwha on Monday November 02, 2020 @06:33PM (#24974727)
So drop an old 50's car with big fins and an empty tank ....
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by tobmlt on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:14PM (#24974115)
Ha! Sorry - I hadn’t seen your comment when I started mine. Yeah that engine up front will help I think!
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by tobmlt on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:12PM (#24974091)
Surely this appears quick, but does this Camry maintain ideal orientation all the way to terminal velocity?

Hmmm, one could imagine using the front wheel drive as a flywheel for some attitude control...

Me thinks a drop test is in order.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by marcinzm on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:45PM (#24975525)
Given that you can get away with a production run of 25 and still count just get the cheapest car on the market, stick some fins on it and sell 24 of them at slight discount from cost (include instructions for fin removal). Likely still cheaper than one run of a supercar.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by atdrummond on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:08PM (#24971812)
Koenigsegg’s production list is capped, yes, but it doesn’t require a pre-existing relationship.

I work with a group of people who have built a car sharing club. I procured a Jesko production slot for the club and I have no existing relationship with Koenigsegg, nor any similar relationships with any major super or hypercar manufacturers.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by justinclift on Monday November 02, 2020 @08:15PM (#24975352)
> I procured a Jesko production slot for the club ...

How does that work? :)

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by rosseloh on Monday November 02, 2020 @02:51PM (#24972369)
> If someone goes faster but never tells anyone, they still went faster.

That's true, and I certainly am not the authority here nor am I knowledgeable enough to pretend to be one....But this reminds me of an argument I had once with someone about Short Takeoff & Landing airplane competitions.

They were bringing up how a group in Alaska was totally incorrect in claiming the competitors at their event were setting world records because (paraphrased) "well I know a guy whose uncle in Idaho took off in a foot less than that on his mountain airstrip, so that video isn't of the world record.".

Did he? Maybe. I can't prove either way. But the difference is, these guys are the, or at least an, authority on STOL world records. If you are serious about setting a record like that, you're going to participate in one of these events. Uncle Jimmy might be a pretty dang good pilot but it really doesn't matter if nobody was there to see it. And the pilots in these all agree that this group is the authority, so why would they recognize a "record" from someone outside it?

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by TylerE on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:29PM (#24972841)
> Two way runs & proper filming are an important factor if you're trying to decide who gets the piece of paper but there's nothing 'official' about it.

The FIA, which sanctions all land speed record attempts, disagrees: Two runs, in opposite directions, with no more than 1 hour between the runs.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by bigiain on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:21PM (#24975009)
Same argument holds though.

If Elon decided to go run a special build Tesla with a new "Infinite Insanity" mode and did 350mph - without Guinness or FIA observers or sanctions, that'd be a thing, and sure it wouldn't qualify for any "official Guinness/FIA piece of paper", but I have no doubt Tesla Marketing would mount a magnificent press campaign with totally convincing proof of their claimed numbers.

(I totally agree that if you _want_ to make claims like that, you should abide by commonly held agreements and recognised authorities. But Elon does dumb shit all the time, and may well be the sort of guy who chooses _not_ to follow FIA rules to intentionally generate social media "engagement" and "vitality"...)

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by mhh__ on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:26PM (#24971306)
The Veyron definitely was a production car if you had the money at the time.

As a wider point, the original Veyron had all the bells and whistles you'd expect from a mercedes S-class (for example), as opposed to being a stripped down racer.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by thrwyoilarticle on Monday November 02, 2020 @01:46PM (#24971534)
The base Veyron didn't set the record. There were only 35 of the model that did.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by brlewis on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:45PM (#24973078)
> there's nothing 'official' about it. If someone goes faster but never tells anyone, they still went faster

The word "official" refers to authority, not to reality. I'm using the official definition.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by anuila on Monday November 02, 2020 @07:49PM (#24975186)
This is it. There’s no difference between someone who goes faster and someone who claims to go faster if there’s no one to validate the result.

Bugatti’s “oh yeah we went superfast but we won’t bother to validate the record” is not very different from “my dad did 100mph once.”

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by thrwyoilarticle on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:26AM (#24981061)
I hope someone can tell CERN they need their particle physics verified by GWR.
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by anuila on Monday November 09, 2020 @02:53PM (#25039099)
Weak argument.

1. CERN is made of scientists; Their job is to measure stuff. SSC relied on a third party.

2. Their published studies are indeed open to replication/verification. "Hey we just achieved speed faster than light, believe us" doesn't just happen.

Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by thrwyoilarticle on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:25AM (#24981057)
Why are the editors of a novelty book the authority and not, for instance, the FIA? GWR don't accept some kinds of records, does that mean they don't have one?
Re:Internet sleuths take down the SSC Tuatara's 316-MPH spee... by 0xf8 on Monday November 02, 2020 @03:51PM (#24973158)
epistemics vs metaphysics.