News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by swiley on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:09AM (#24950755)
Delete your twitter/facebook/reddit account.

Seriously! Go do it now! These sites are built with the goal of pushing people into groups that are always angry at each other. Angry polarized groups spend more time on the site and are easier to sell things to.

The only thing ignoring this trash will do is make you a happier, more functional person.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by nabla9 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:49AM (#24951008)
People in social media spend several hours per day following politics but almost nobody of them is engaged in any real political work. They are engaging with politics to satisfy our own emotional needs and intellectual curiosities. That’s political hobbyism/consumerism.

It's not different from being sports fan. Making noise from the couch but not having no effect in the game and annoying people who don't follow.

They have no serious purpose. They are just wasting energy.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ecocentrik on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:24AM (#24951267)
Keeping informed has been always been a prerequisite of American democracy.

"wherever the people are well informed they can be trusted with their own government" Thomas Jefferson (https://www.loc.gov/exhibits/jefferson/60.html)

Engaging in the political dialogue is not wasted energy. Low level engagement on social media might be about as impactful as filling a stadium to see a politician speak during a pandemic but high level engagement is really the only way to participate in American democracy right now. If it wasn't valuable, nobody would be training bots to disrupt the process by amplifying division and hate.

Sane politicians aren't going door to door these days or standing on crowded street corners. They're interacting on social media.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by read_if_gay_ on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:30AM (#24951312)
> If it wasn't valuable, nobody would be programming bots to disrupt the process and amplify division and hate.

The fact that social media sites are a valuable manipulation target to certain people doesn't make them valuable to you as a consumer. To the contrary.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by nabla9 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:48AM (#24951452)
> Engaging in the political dialogue is not wasted energy.

As it is practised in the internet it's horrible destructive energy in the internet.

Actual political work is much better.

>Sane politicians

Yes. Politicians. They also do actual political work. Public that spends hours in political internet and does not engage outside it goes insane.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ecocentrik on Sunday November 01, 2020 @11:03AM (#24960328)
It seems like your assumung that pundits and bots already dominate the dialogue to such an extent that normal people can't communicate and voice their political grivances. I don't belive that's the case.

We're learning to deal with new forms of propaganda the same way we dealt with the old ones. I remember when people were talking about the information overload of the early days of the internet as driving people insane. Or people who complained about TV advertising being a form of mind control.

People that can't cope will either succumb to the will of others or retreat but that doesn't mean the rest of us shouldn't keep using these tools to our advantage.

> Yes. Politicians. They also do actual political work.

Isn't it clear that renaming post-offices a few months before they're defunded qualifies as actual political work or filling stadiums of people to give them a rock concert version of the political experience or hosting twitch streams of a co-op video game to an audience of 500k people? You might consider grilling social media companies for not doing enough to promote for their party's interests "political work" but when it's done in a chamber dedicated to governing through legislation and comes of as whining or yet another attempt at pandering it misses any loftier goals you're implying might exist.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by salamimonger on Saturday October 31, 2020 @04:55PM (#24955124)
This got me thinking. Is it ultimately better for people to be battling it out online, on social media, rather than actually fighting in the streets? Everyone will get to have their fair share of outrage and stress release(after amassing it online in the first place), but no one get's hurt. On the other hand, like you suggest, none of their struggles will produce anything real. Which got me thinking, was it better back then, when people actually had to fight it out in real life? Then there would be some kind of result, and people would be able to make changes to the society that they see fit. It was often bloody though, and one side losing meant actual death(s). But from that, there was progress - good and bad. The way things are now, reminds me of all the bureaucracies in the world that prevent things from getting done - good and bad. Maybe people are drawn to fighting it out online, because they subconsciously know there's nothing they can do in real life anymore. They are well aware of how little influence they actually have on the real world and the only outlet for fighting for their ideals is online, which mostly result in nothing but mental stress and pain. Another thing, I have this idea that after two sides fight in real life, sometimes they can gain an understanding or appreciation of each other. They see each other face to face, as real people, and both understand that they are fighting for what they believe in. Whereas online, there's none of that. You could be fighting against a bot, or someone across the seas who was paid to just start shit. And online, if you lose, you just move on to a new thread or a different forum. You never have to live with the consequences of losing.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by navidfarhadi on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:44AM (#24950966)
It’s possible to (mostly) avoid political stuff on those websites if one wants to, instead of refusing to use the sites completely. Just as an example, I rarely visit r/all, but I do visit specific subreddits that I’m subscribed to like r/privacy, r/pihole, and r/thinkpad. On Facebook, I never browse my newsfeed, but I am a member of a group for my apartment complex in the Stockholm area which lists local events and people selling stuff or giving away stuff in the community.

My point is that is that it’s possible to filter out a lot of the political garbage on those sites if one wishes, but it does appear to be getting more difficult since political stuff is appearing more and more often in places that I personally wouldn’t expect.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by everdrive on Saturday October 31, 2020 @12:24PM (#24952718)
It’s easy to filter your reddit, and get quite boring results. (Who knows if that will change in the future, though? The old reddit interface could be taken away at any time.) But, Facebook and Twitter are a different beast. Facebook seems all the sadder since the groups can be quite good, and the prospect of staying connected with friends is obviously appealing.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by legulere on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:24AM (#24951266)
How is a subreddit about privacy not political? It might not align to the two political parties in the US, but for sure I expect there to be an echo-chamber of people that value privacy more over other rights than regular people.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by arkitaip on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:53AM (#24951035)
It is virtually impossible on Twitter, I know because I've used every tool possible (tweet deck, lists, occasionally muting people, changing the feed layout) and it just doesn't work because (a) Twitter is designed to bleed content from one tribe to another (b), because people have one feed where they combine work, private life and politics and (c) the metrics Twitter use are based on designs that agitate and divide.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by treeman79 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:57AM (#24951513)
Was keeping an eye on Twitter a Few months ago, while watching the downtown being burned.

Started seeing tons of tweets from people who decided my area was next. Tons of people going out about how they were going to burn us down. Then watching them as they all started heading our way.

Thankfully they found all the exits blocked by police.

I don’t own guns. But my area is big on gun rights. Looters vs gun nuts.

So yea, well. It’s a pretty screwed up situation. Like one step from civiL war screwed up.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by bogwog on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:26AM (#24950848)
Social media might need to be controlled in the same way cigarettes are. At the end of the day, both are drug dealers. One of them sells nicotine, the other sells dopamine.

Not sure what that would look like though. Cigarettes have scary labels and enforced age requirements. Maybe social media would have to change the way likes/upvotes/etc work to be less polarizing, in addition to an age limit enforcement?

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by op03 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:46AM (#24950982)
Its not complicated. There are dose response curves for everything once you start studying them -

https://www.epa.gov/environmental-topics/chemicals-and-toxic...

https://www.epa.gov/fera/dose-response-assessment-assessing-...

How did we build these tables?

Same process will apply to how much dopamine (and whatever else) you can keep giving a kid or a group of people over time without serious consequences

Whether that takes 2 years or 20 years more to tabulate, lots of people will take a hit thanks to their internal reward mechanisms being gamed.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by BurningFrog on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:48AM (#24950992)
The various Wars On Drugs do not inspire.

According to me, they have at best been ineffectual, and more commonly made a bad thing worse.

I think/hope we're in a transitional phase of our civilization where we haven't figured out how to handle these new things yet. Over time, institutions will emerge. They always do, right?

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ben_w on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:14AM (#24951177)
Yes, but the dynamics may be different. If social network software is banned, and replaced with a ten million small DIY networks that don’t interact with each other, will that be any different than local pubs and clubs?

If the networks join up, letting people interact, enabling or encouraging hate between each other, there is an incentive for members of each group to report the illegal networks to the authorities to harm “the other lot”.

(This is just an off-the-cuff thought, I’m a long way from understanding sociopolitical dynamics)

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by agumonkey on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:12AM (#24951161)
It's fun because, just like cigarettes, internet has been 'sold'. It was a new eldorado of information and choice ..

It started slightly innocently but at some point it became a product.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by treeman79 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @10:00AM (#24951541)
It’s weird seeing the down fall of cigarettes and the uptick of vaping by 20 year olds.

Yes water vapor is safe. But additives are poorly regulated/understood.

But people are destroying their lungs faster then cigarettes ever did.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Lendal on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:24AM (#24951273)
Maybe we should do the opposite. Maybe we should all create thousands of Facebook accounts, with randomized profiles that promote random articles and AI-generated comments. Then that program runs on your machine whenever you're not using it. It would be opt-in, like SETI@Home. It could bring the whole world together in a massive community effort, with the feel-good focus of destroying-Facebook togetherness. I would call it Baseball-and-Apple-Pie@Home. Then we all sit back and enjoy the ensuing utopia of a clean, Facebook-free planet.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ploika on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:47AM (#24950991)
"Rivals are alien, unlikable, contemptible" could be a description of feelings in Northern Ireland during its worst days, long before the advent of social media. Poisonous rhetoric definitely made things worse, but the real damage was done by things like gerrymandering, unequal access to jobs and housing, and repressive one-sided policing.

From a distance, it looks like some of those same problems are contributing to the USA's polarisation. Fixing them will be much more important, and much harder, than just tuning out obnoxious media.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by cblconfederate on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:36AM (#24950910)
I wish that were true. Social media cringe is just the symptom
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by codysan on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:50AM (#24951015)
I'm not so sure that it's the cringe that is the problem. I think it's the notion that these social media platforms are acting as a lens for how a lot of people see the world.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by laurent92 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:36AM (#24950909)
The double problem is, we are isolated, often after various moves due to our studies and first years of work, otherwise because we diverge politically from other ex- or people in our family who, themselves, got polarized the other way. So deleting social networks would be a good thing, but we depend on them for out last human interactions on weekends and evenings. Even worse during confinement.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by _iyig on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:40AM (#24950936)
Computer games with voice chat have helped me weather COVID cabin fever as an alternative to social media. Particularly in PvE MMOs, players are just there to collaborate and have fun, with no room for politics to intrude.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by BurningFrog on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:49AM (#24951003)
Can you recommend some PS4 titles?
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by _iyig on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:08AM (#24951132)
Don’t have a PS4, sorry. World of Warcraft Classic on PC has been fun for me, using Discord for voice chat.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by netcan on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:50AM (#24951017)
How do you see HN fitting into this?

I mean, HN is a "single feed" which avoids the belligerent group dynamics... but culture bleeds.

The narrative dichotomies and other elements of this belligerence dynamic (I think it's more belligerence than polarisation, btw) exist here and other social media that isn't explicitly structured for it like twitter, reddit or fb. Is massive, many-2-many communication a lost cause?

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by intended on Saturday October 31, 2020 @10:15AM (#24951646)
America had this issue before these sites came up.

Ignoring this will make a single individual better, but that will only leave you back at square one - which is being at the mercy of the America news media environment.

For an individual this may be the right call, for the scope and scale of the issue being discussed in this article, it doesn’t seem like it.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by agumonkey on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:11AM (#24951150)
Please, they're not all made for this. Curating subreddits you follow will make reddit pretty much ok and problem free.

Now I still suggest people to reduce online activities as much as possible. It's probably a long term neurological disease.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by tomohawk on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:04AM (#24951104)
Social media has served as an accelerant for identity politics. The two go hand in hand.

How does civil society survive if we're just a collection of tribal groups pursuing divided interests and throwing rocks at each other?

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by mc32 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:11AM (#24951153)
That helps, but it’s impossible to avoid —even if you avoid partisan sites.

Traditional Mainstream media take sides and present one side as orthodox and the other as heterodox.

Google is guilty of soft censorship (either deranks, or with autocomplete refuses to autocomplete search phrases that are contrarian to orthodoxy).

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by golergka on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:02AM (#24951086)
As if there isn't as much polarization happening right here.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ecocentrik on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:05AM (#24951106)
Just deleting social media is not a solution. Divisive otherisum is an attack on the social sensibilities of the the last few decades and a lot of it is being promoted by bots. A better solution is to find ways to disrupt the bots creating or amplifying the hate.

Why poison the well that opened up global communication and brought us closer together? Why promote anti-globalism and distrust in journalism while disrupting the lines of communication? Are we being primed for war? genocide? mass-depopulation? Whatever it is, the last thing people should do is comply.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:33AM (#24950889)
If it wasn’t for Twitter I would have literally no clue about the machinations of the intelligence agencies to undermine the president or the corrupt activities of the Biden family. Unfortunately the mainstream media outlets choose not to report or pursue a lot of stuff, and have an alarming habit of citing dubious statements from “the intelligence community” as legitimate evidence that resolves the matter.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by bsenftner on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:36AM (#24950907)
Wish this was a joke. Twitter is just an idiotic mess.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by swiley on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:36AM (#24950905)
twitter is a terrible tool for this. It's heavily censored and biased. You could have heard it here or from a decent journalist.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:53AM (#24951029)
Twitter can only make meagre attempts to censor. They can stop something from “trending” or whatever. But if you want to hear from independent journalists and researchers and analysts, Twitter lets you do that, and short of shutting down the entire service, it’s unstoppable.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by knaq on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:03AM (#24951095)
Twitter blocked the nation's oldest and 4th-largest newspaper, the New York Post, for 16 days. This was election interference. Twitter's CEO was called to testify about it in front of congress, where he falsely claimed that the New York Post wasn't blocked. Ted Cruz called him out on the matter, pointing out that lying in sworn testimony to congress is a felony, and the New York Post got unblocked an hour later.

The numerous little independent journalists rarely get that level of help from a senator. They have no chance against the censorship.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:23AM (#24951254)
It may have been a ridiculous decision, but as a means of stopping the information from propagating, it was wholly ineffectual. There’s always enough people that want to get to the truth of the matter, rather than the version of events that has been shaped for The Narrative. Twitter lets those people easily connect with each other, so it is by far the most powerful tool for “freedom of the press” that we have.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by treeman79 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @10:06AM (#24951586)
This time.

How about next time?

Fact checking became a thing less for facts and more as an attack tool.

I’ve been part of as agencies. They go out of their way to make sure their is only one viewpoint on anything that gets ad dollars.

Makes it difficult for other side to run a media company if they can’t get advertising dollars.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by vehemenz on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:24AM (#24951276)
If you're going to be upset about blocking a company blocking a low-quality, propaganda-laden newspaper, muster some outrage about the actual government suppressing the vote and gerrymandering.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by TheAdamAndChe on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:48AM (#24951001)
This site is censored too, and the news media is becoming increasingly partisan an consolidated as well.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ForHackernews on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:36AM (#24950906)
Uh... is this a clever meta-comment about the kind of nonsense on social media? Poe's law seems to apply extra hard these days.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:57AM (#24951061)
I’m not joking. Is it your opinion that there were no attempts, from within the agencies, to undermine the president (or his campaign) and that there is nothing corrupt about what the Biden family has been up to?
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ForHackernews on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:06AM (#24951112)
I'm not going to get sucked down this rabbit hole because there are a zillion other sites where you can have this specific argument, but I will say that if you're voting for Trump because you're anti-corruption then you and I have world views too far diverged for any meaningful communication to take place.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:25AM (#24951282)
I don’t want to get into an argument with you, I was just curious if that was your actual opinion. Similar to how you asked if I was joking and I answered you.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ForHackernews on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:40AM (#24951394)
Yes, my actual opinion is that Joe Biden is a vastly less corrupt candidate than Trump.

Presumably Hunter Biden traded on his famous name to get job opportunities (in a smaller way than the Trump kids), but I've seen no credible evidence (and please don't reply with a gish-gallop of shady twitter and youtube links) that Joe Biden compromised his office to assist his son.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by Tycho on Saturday October 31, 2020 @10:13AM (#24951627)
If it wasn’t for Twitter, I too might think that Hunter Biden was just getting a cushy job similar to, say, Bush’s daughter getting a job at the Smithsonian Design Museum. It might not occur to me that of all the jobs he could have landed, these just happened to be big money deals in China and Ukraine, where Joe Biden was active in foreign policy - negotiating trade deals and firing financial fraud prosecutors - that seemed to involve a lot of free money for the Biden family. It might not strike me as corrupt, and I might not notice that the press are clinically uninterested in finding out more, or even asking the Bidens to clear things up.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by read_if_gay_ on Saturday October 31, 2020 @09:35AM (#24951348)
> if you're voting for Trump because you're anti-corruption then you and I have world views too far diverged for any meaningful communication to take place.

How ironic. Have you read the linked article? Way to prove its point.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by iso947 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:39AM (#24950933)
I watched a documentary about how covid was caused by a khazakstani journalist finding out about the clintons eating bill gates’ child’s adrenal gland. that was more credible than whatever conspiracy you’re reading about.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by zo1 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:17AM (#24950793)
On some level yes. But the unfortunate side is that it's seeping into the overall culture and previously-benign and relatively apolitical institutions. That makes it dangerous to "ignore" and hope it goes away due to us all deciding to be reasonable and ignore the hateful and prominent voices that use social-media as a megaphone.

Some institutions being actively soaked in identity politics and other divisive elements:

Higher education

Lower Education

United Nations

Local government bodies

Charity Organizations

Sports

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by throwaway3699 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:20AM (#24950819)
I do agree with you and I want the constant crawl of IdPol stop, but I can't help but feel this is part of the polarization aspect.

The internet is causing the growth of IdPol as well as the growth of the movement against it.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by swiley on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:24AM (#24950837)
IMO: it's not "the internet." At least, not to the same degree. It's the huge platforms with their own ad networks that are driving it.
Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by ForHackernews on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:42AM (#24950951)
https://areomagazine.com/2020/10/27/why-fourteen-critics-of-...

IMHO, we need a return to "boring" centrist politics.

Re:New political polarization casts rivals as alien, unlikab... by auganov on Saturday October 31, 2020 @08:31AM (#24950876)
> But the unfortunate side is that it's seeping into the overall culture and previously-benign and relatively apolitical institutions

It's very hard to be apolitical. Almost all behavior can be interpreted politically.

What has really changed is it's much easier to obtain information about an organization and the individuals involved. In the past you might have simply not known enough to peg someone politically. Hence the impression of neutrality. Today it's just harder to create this illusion.