News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by philips on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:40PM (#24944037)
I recently learned that there is a group in Oregon advocating a slight twist on RCV called STAR[1]. There are efforts to get it used in Lane and Multnomah counties at the moment.

[1] https://www.starvoting.us/

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by vanattab on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:49PM (#24944148)
Why is star voting (where you award each candidate 0-5 stars) better then ranked choice voting?
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by philips on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:52PM (#24944205)
The FAQ[1] and comparison page[2] explain their position.

[1] https://www.starvoting.us/faq

[2] https://www.equal.vote/star-vs-rcv

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by ElijahLynn on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:20PM (#24944554)
Great links on STAR, especially the comparison!
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by godelski on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:46PM (#24946162)
Fun fact, STAR came out of Oregon too. Lane county (where the University of Oregon) has been trying to pass it for awhile (very close last time).
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:37PM (#24944792)
Simplifying greatly, tactical voting in RCV gets super complex, and STAR does a much better job at rewarding honest voting.

In STAR voting, the optimal strategy is almost always to vote how you actually feel. This isn't the case with pure RCV.

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by Zak on Friday October 30, 2020 @02:52PM (#24945590)
The Condorcet method also rewards honest voting, and can be used with ranked ballots.
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by godelski on Friday October 30, 2020 @03:53PM (#24946239)
I think this is a bad way to think about things. Rewarding honest voting means that people have perfect information and act rationally (meaning they understand how to maximize their voting power). The other way to frame things is how systems handle strategic voting. One of the reasons I'm a big fan of STAR is because it both prefers honest voting (you maximize your power her) AND it handles strategic voting well[0]. That is, the difference between VSE_best and VSE_worst is small. Where we see that the gap in Condorcet methods (like RP and Schulze) is quite large (>10%). I think people get caught up in Condorcet methods because they look at RP's VSE being the max. But STAR0-10 only has a 0.5% VSE difference on max but a 4% difference in worse case (not to mention that STAR is substantially simpler and scales better). You can't compare voting systems just by looking at VSE. It is an important factor, but there are many other factors that matter (e.g. handle of strategy, transparency, handling spoilers, scalability, and more mathematical factors).

[0] https://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/vse.html

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by Zak on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:48PM (#24946755)
> Rewarding honest voting means that people have perfect information and act rationally

Democracy itself implies that we expect voters to be informed and rational. Since we know that isn't the case, perhaps the important business of ruling countries should be left up to those who are very well educated and who possess a certain... nobility.

What I like about Condorcet methods is the Condorcet criterion itself. I have yet to find a better definition of a candidate being most preferred by the voters than that the candidate would beat every other candidate in a two-person race. The later-no-harm criterion (that giving a positive rating to a less favored candidate cannot hurt a more favored candidate) is also valuable and STAR doesn't satisfy it.

STAR does seem easy to count though, and without doing much research, likely to elect the Condorcet winner most of the time.

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by godelski on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:34PM (#24947101)
I'm not sure that's a necessary prior. This also isn't a binary condition (informed vs uninformed) but rather a spectrum. One can be reasonably informed (or worse! Misinformed!) and still not vote optimally, but would trend in the direction. Because of this spectrum it is reasonable to also want to handle strategic voting well. Especially because there's nothing better to discourage strategic voting than to make it not very useful (think why would you perform this adversarial attack if it isn't effective?).

While the Condorcet criterion itself is nice it is far from the most important (cardinal systems are going to do a good job here). VSE really is measuring the MSE distance between true voter preference and candidate policy. But there are other criteria that matters. Simplicity is one, as it allows for transparency and voters to understand the system. Ranked systems typically fail the favorite betrayer. This includes RP and Schulze (the most popular Condorcet methods, and what I assume you are specifically referring to). But also consider factors like: expressiveness, spoiling, monotonicity, scaling (do ballots look the same?), and momentum.

It is really easy to get caught up in a single metric, but the difficulty of voting is that there are a lot of metrics that matter and you really have to do a lot of tuning. But I'll tell you that the researchers themselves, including Arrow, typically prefer cardinal systems because of the combination of criteria.

https://electionscience.org/library/approval-voting/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4FXLQoLDBA

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by Zak on Saturday October 31, 2020 @01:25PM (#24953322)
After looking in to it some more, I think one of the strong arguments for STAR is that scoring captures more information about voter preferences than ranking does. The fact that some voters might have a very strong preference for a candidate who isn't quite the Condorcet winner is relevant.
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by godelski on Saturday October 31, 2020 @03:59PM (#24954688)
Yes, this is a big feature I like of cardinal systems, particularly STAR and range/score. Although I would take approval voting any day of the year since it captures most things while being simplistic. But I think in an more information based world and where we make policies based on information, a simple voting mechanism where we can capture fine voter preference should allow us to better govern the society (assuming good intentions).
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by heintje_ghulam on Friday October 30, 2020 @12:50PM (#24944182)
See my post in this thread for an example of why RCV is bad, and see the links I provided to learn more about STAR.
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by ElijahLynn on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:15PM (#24944493)
Can you clarify if by "Is bad" you mean not as good as STAR or worse than the First Past The Poll (current system)?

It does sound like STAR is better than RCV, especially after reading about it here https://www.wired.com/story/dana-debeauvoir-texas-county-cle... (A Texas County Clerk’s Bold Crusade to Transform How We Vote).

I do wonder if those adopting RCV are still in a better place, than FPTP, simply because it decreases voter apathy and gives voters a chance to be "heard", thus increasing participation. At least in the short run, I feel like RCV is still a win, even though it may not be as optimal as STAR.

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by ElijahLynn on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:24PM (#24944618)
Linking your post you mentioned: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24944151
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by heintje_ghulam on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:33PM (#24944740)
By the way, STAR is not really a twist on RCV, it's a twist on Score Voting.
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by ElijahLynn on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:14PM (#24944475)
Oh, I just read a big article about how Star voting came to be. https://www.wired.com/story/dana-debeauvoir-texas-county-cle... (A Texas County Clerk’s Bold Crusade to Transform How We Vote)

I thought I remembered it was mostly about how to verify your vote, I'll have to read more into it again. Thanks!

Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by patmorgan23 on Friday October 30, 2020 @01:24PM (#24944609)
That's a different STAR vote (i know its confusing). The one you posted is about design for a voting machine. The one the comment is referring to is a vote counting method (like first past the post or rcv)
Re:Maine Becomes First State to Use Ranked-Choice Voting in ... by godelski on Friday October 30, 2020 @04:03PM (#24946331)
STAR came out of Oregon actually. One of the co-inventors actually sometimes frequents HN.