News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by jrockway on Thursday April 28, 2011 @01:23PM (#2494165)
How does he know nobody will buy the Android app? I barely use any free apps other than the ones that come with Cyanogen Mod.

Titanium Backup? Paid. ROM Manager? Paid. Treking? Paid. Android IRC? Paid. X-Plane? Paid.

Android users have no problems paying for apps. Non-Android developers are afraid of the unknown.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by xinsight on Thursday April 28, 2011 @02:02PM (#2494319)
I ported an iOS app to Android. I've sold three (!!) copies while in that same period, the iOS version has sold about 300. I dropped the price from $5 down to $2 over easter and still didn't sell a single copy during the sale.

The two apps have the same content and the sales funnel is exactly the same. (The only difference is the iOS app has lots of 5-star reviews.) It seems clear to me that Android users can't or won't pay for certain kinds of apps.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by dkarl on Thursday April 28, 2011 @02:41PM (#2494527)
To all app developers, please don't give up on Android. If your market is educated middle class folks -- i.e., if you don't sell games and fart apps -- then give us a chance to start showing up in the Android market. Most of us bought iPhones back when they were clearly superior, and we are unwilling to throw away a couple-hundred-dollar piece of electronics that works perfectly fine. The new line of Android phones look great. I'll certainly be there in less than two years, maybe less than a year depending on how long my phone lasts. At that point all my spending will move to the Android market. I'm not a huge purchaser of apps -- I've probably spent somewhere between $50 and $100 on apps -- but I did buy Instapaper!
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by dkarl on Thursday April 28, 2011 @04:03PM (#2494881)
Okay, what bias did I run into here? Not everyone who is excited about Android is going to immediately shell out a few hundred bucks when they already have an iPhone. For me, that's enough money that I think about how to spend it, and new gadgets usually lose out to other priorities. Does that make me a bad nerd or something?
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by xinsight on Thursday April 28, 2011 @04:55PM (#2495052)
I'd also like to see Android thrive (mainly to keep Apple from behaving badly) and you make a good point that Android is steadily moving into the mainstream. But it will be a challenge for Google to shake the impression that Android users are reluctant to buy apps.

btw, another post from marco that shows his skepticism towards Android: http://www.marco.org/2011/04/02/time-bombs

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by Suan on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:15PM (#2494696)
Amen. My $0.99 app (http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2407744) for Android which has been out for more than a month and costs $0.99 has seen only 6 downloads (4 of which are my friends!) I'm really curious as to how it will "sell" if I change it to free, and if there was an iOS version.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by jokermatt999 on Thursday April 28, 2011 @02:36PM (#2494505)
What app? How well known is it? What is your competition on both platforms? Have you marketed the Android version as much as the iOS version?
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by xinsight on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:38PM (#2494789)
It's called GoSwedish - a friendly introduction to learning Swedish. http://xinsight.ca/goswedish/

Findability within the Market might also be a factor. A search for "swedish" in the App Store, and it's on the first screen. But it's quite a long scroll down on the Android Market.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by flyosity on Thursday April 28, 2011 @10:24PM (#2496100)
This is the testament to the reach of the App Store. Your app is targeting an incredibly small, niche market, and you're still selling hundreds of copies.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by stevestreza on Thursday April 28, 2011 @10:40PM (#2496134)
Sounds like it was the primary reason you had low sales. Without similar placement in the Android Market, you really can't claim that one market was more successful than the other purely on its own merits.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by xinsight on Friday April 29, 2011 @10:04AM (#2497358)
I wish I knew where customers came from, but the app Store and Android Market are both black boxes.

I'm sure some people find apps from within the store (e.g. searching for "swedish") - but I expect most to come from youtube (where there are lots of GoSwedish videos) and then search for the app by name.

Update: Or maybe I just need to do more to get the word out. I sold 10 Android copies yesterday! (Thanks HN!)

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by SMT on Monday May 02, 2011 @07:22AM (#2505886)
GoSwedish and BikeDoctor? Pretty fringe apps. I wonder if the real problem is the findability of fringe apps for Android.

Also perhaps Android users are not indoctrinated to the Apple "walled garden concept", and expect to find these on an Internet website rather than in an application. I certainly find the concept of a guide to bike repair or learning Swedish in the form of an application very odd. An application store isn't the first place I would consider looking for this type of thing.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by londoncyclist on Monday May 02, 2011 @02:29AM (#2505421)
Second Amen - my app http://bikedoctorapp.com launched on iPhone and Android using exact same tactics (5000 person email newsletter + dominating the relevant keyword on Google + contacting app blogs) download rate on Android has been maybe 1/30th of iPhone. Typical feedback: "This is the first app I've paid for on Android".
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by cygwin98 on Thursday April 28, 2011 @02:30PM (#2494467)
Wow, sounds like a good story that deserves its own blog post.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by xinsight on Thursday April 28, 2011 @03:51PM (#2494838)
Thanks for the encouragement.

I was going to release a free version on Android before writing up my experiences. I thought the liberal return policy on Android would eliminate the need for "lite" apps - but the return window is only 15 minutes which seems a bit tight. Better to have an app where you can fully evaluate it and then buy when you're ready.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by bstrand on Thursday April 28, 2011 @04:43PM (#2495003)
Marco has a well established anti-Android bias, both Android the platform and Android users. He's been dismissive of it since the beginning, so this post-facto justification that Android users won't pay for apps is a bit hollow.

ReadItLater Pro for Android is clearly analogous. It was released at a $1 launch sale price (80% off, they say) on March 9; 11 days later it crossed 10,000 downloads from the Market. That seems like a substantial demand and willingness to pay for it on behalf of Android users. http://www.appbrain.com/app/read-it-later-pro/com.ideashower...

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by jammur on Thursday April 28, 2011 @04:19PM (#2494928)
The market data suggest that you're mistaken. In 2010, the App Store took in almost 20 times the revenue that the Android Market took in. $1.7 billion for the App Store, compared to $102 million for Android Market. Considering where Android market share stands relative to iOS, this means that iOS users are absolutely more willing to spend money on apps. That's obviously not the case for every Android user, but the relative aggregate difference is what matters when deciding what platforms to develop for.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by flyosity on Thursday April 28, 2011 @10:16PM (#2496085)
As an iOS developer, I can't stress how important this metric is. I don't care if Android gets 70%, 80%, 95% marketshare if the App Store is generating way, WAY more money for developers.
Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by orangecat on Friday April 29, 2011 @01:48AM (#2496489)
In 2010, the App Store took in almost 20 times the revenue that the Android Market took in.

That's less extreme than it sounds for several reasons:

- Android's market share was tiny for the beginning of 2010. It didn't start taking off until mid-year with the EVO, Droid X, Galaxy, Desire, etc.

- There were way more paid apps for iOS than Android in 2010.

- Android apps more commonly use ads than iOS apps, which isn't captured in app store revenue.

I'd still expect that the median iOS app makes more than the median Android app today, but the difference should be much less than 20x.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by AllenKids on Thursday April 28, 2011 @02:41PM (#2494525)
There will be buyers, but he does not see enough buyers to worth his time.

He'd have to rewrite the whole thing in Java, modify UI to fit in Android environment, maintain two code bases and try to keep feature parity.

He's a one man shop, he decided against it, and I agree with his decision.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by chewbranca on Thursday April 28, 2011 @05:11PM (#2495105)
I'm sad to hear his attitude towards android, I've been anxiously waiting for an android version of the app, and have been holding off on becoming a subscriber until he moved in the android direction. Knowing this, I will sign up as a subscriber to show my appreciation for the ability to export to kindle format, which has been great for me, but unfortunately it means instapaper is no longer a candidate for a long term solution, but rather an intermediary tool I use for reading articles on the kindle until something else comes along.

Marco I really hope you change your attitude towards android, there are definitely people out there who would happily pay for an android instapaper app. That said, I understand if you don't and want to say thank you for everything you've done so far, even without android support it has been a very useful application for me.

Re:Why Instapaper Free is taking an extended vacation by haribilalic on Thursday April 28, 2011 @10:41PM (#2496137)
Instapaper has an API. There are at least five third-party Instapaper clients for Android available in the Marketplace. http://www.quora.com/Whats-the-best-client-for-Instapaper-on...