News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by martin-adams on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:59AM (#24929153)
This does concern me. For example, if I buy kindle books instead of physical books, my kids can't enjoy those books when I'm gone. I have a car that can now do software unlocking of physical features (e.g. rear heated seats). Am I adding value to the car which I can sell to the next person, or am I licensing the right to that feature for the duration for my own use.

We're moving to a model where we spend the same, but their value is zero when considering the value of our assets.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by dhab on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:22AM (#24929293)
thanks for pointing this out. For a while i had an uneasy feeling about this, and they way you have put it gives words to those: digital assets that we create and are licensed really can't be passed on generationally. Taking it to an extreme - imagine not having physical transcripts of historic documents - e.g. the constitution - and its effect on a country's trajectory (not that constitution would stay always relevant in it's original form - but still)
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by schwartzworld on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:03AM (#24929180)
the part about your kids really resonates with me. a lot of my taste was formed by going through my parents old books and records.
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by s17n on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:45AM (#24931005)
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by Qwertious on Thursday October 29, 2020 @12:09PM (#24932010)
To add to that, Kindle store is actually two things combined:

1. An eBook distributor 2. A "PayPal replacement" that let's you send $$$ to authors.

They theoretically have a monopoly on #1, but in practice piracy exists and potentially does it better.

They don't and can't stop people from setting up a platform for sending $$$ to authors - in fact, you could even have a database of authors, their books and the RRP of those books, and an embeddable button to pay the author an RRP's worth. That could then be embedded on arbitrary piracy sites.

The piracy sites could be shut down, but realistically the pirate sites are too portable to be shut down for long, and private trackers make some sites impractical to shut down at all.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by wycy on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:02AM (#24929170)
> I have a car that can now do software unlocking of physical features (e.g. rear heated seats)

Was this a permanent unlock, or do you need a subscription to unlock the rear heated seats?

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by bonkabonka on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:04AM (#24929184)
Well and is the permanent unlock transferable? There was that fellow who bought a Tesla from a used-car dealer and had a bunch of paperwork stating certain things were unlocked that when he bought them got disabled because he wasn't licensed for them.
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by martin-adams on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:11AM (#24929229)
Yeah, it's pretty much this. Apparently Tesla locks the features when the car is sold to them. The guy in question had a broken paper trail but apparently it was sorted.

What is worrying is that these aren't clearly explained when you make the purchase. And it's really down to the company's policy, which if all companies do the same, the consumer ends up having no choice.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by judge2020 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:33AM (#24930269)
Supposedly the story is: Tesla bought a car back then sold it to an auction house and enabled FSD as a "demo". The auction house mistakenly listed the features as being enabled, and when the car sold Tesla never disabled the FSD demo. When the user then privately sold the car to a new owner, the new owner performed an ownership transfer - when they did this, either a human or some automated system saw that the FSD demo was enabled and disabled it.

0: https://www.businessinsider.com/tesla-disables-autopilot-on-...

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by martin-adams on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:12AM (#24929233)
All I know is that it's a one time payment, but it's not obvious if that's transferable to the next owner.
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by Mediterraneo10 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:04AM (#24929586)
> if I buy kindle books instead of physical books, my kids can't enjoy those books when I'm gone.

Do you think your kids will want to read their ancestors’ books? I have watched even ardent bibliophiles among my friends gradually lose interest in books, because they grow accustomed to consuming snackable content on the internet, and I have little confidence that books will be a mainstream pastime for following generations.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by netsharc on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:22AM (#24930194)
Dude, is your question for real? Just because you hang out with those people, you think it's not necessary for books to be transferrable to kids? It's currently possible to pass on books, DVDs, MP3s to kids, and a corporate-controlled future where that's not possible without them getting a cut is a stupid future.
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by ls65536 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:01AM (#24930548)
I really don't think their point was that it's not necessary for books and other physical media to be transferable to kids. I saw it more as an anecdote that I think probably a lot of people would, unfortunately, nod in agreement with.

To your point, however, I do agree. I think one of the major benefits of physical media (or even digital media as long as it's entirely self-hosted) is that you can enjoy it entirely without surveillance, and that it's much more resistant to censorship. Being able to read about and understand how people lived, thought, and created in the past is incredibly important, and it's something we should preserve for the benefit of future generations, even if they might sometimes contain things that one might not necessarily agree with today.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by Mediterraneo10 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @02:20PM (#24933543)
> you think it's not necessary for books to be transferrable to kids?

Where did I say that? Obviously it is nice to be able to hand things down to one's children. But what I am questioning is whether the envisioned scenario (children of the future being enamored by dad or granddad's old books) is really likely to happen.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by netsharc on Friday October 30, 2020 @08:04AM (#24941328)
It's the inferred interpretation. Fine, your lawyer could go to court and successfully defend that you didn't utter that question, but in my mind you're arguing that would future generations even want to read books, so should we even care about e-products being transferable?
Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by ls65536 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:37AM (#24930307)
> Do you think your kids will want to read their ancestors’ books?

Maybe they will and maybe they won't, but how are we to know that with certainty today? The whole point is that if the opportunity is taken away now, then that guarantees that they won't be able to in the future. Beyond that, they would also lose the possibility of otherwise sharing them with someone else who might be interested in reading them, and I think that would be a loss as well.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by mattferderer on Thursday October 29, 2020 @09:54AM (#24930494)
The best books I own & re-read are over 30 years old.

At the same time, most every decent library should own a few copies of them. They're all well known, at least in their industries niche.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by ethagnawl on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:20AM (#24930690)
I think there's something to be said for having the physical object that belonged to someone you knew. For example, I was recently given my mother's collection of 7"s. Yes, they're completely impractical by today's standards and I can find almost all of those songs on Spotify, but the collection included her handwritten index and notes scribbled in the columns about memories connected to the various songs in it.

I don't have a specific example in mind, but I'm sure the same applies to books people have inherited from friends and family. People write all sorts of interesting notes in books, tuck photos in between the pages, etc. These items offer a connection that a library book or its digital equivalent (often) cannot.

Re:Amazon Argues Users Don't Own Purchased Prime Video Content by keiferski on Thursday October 29, 2020 @11:15AM (#24931395)
Yeah, I have a dictionary that belonged to my grandfather, which is in the language he spoke. It's just a generic, paperback book, but the physical item has meaning to me. I can't imagine a $Language Kindle dictionary would have remotely the same relevance.