"Even after two years, Cadillac’s Super Cruise remained our top-rated system because, when turned on, it uses direct driver monitoring to warn drivers that appear to have stopped paying attention to the road."
Autopilot doesn't "nanny" drivers, as you call it, and is therefore not a safe system so they ranked it lower. If you're fine with your ADAS system killing multiple people [1], this is not the ranking system for you.
[1] https://apnews.com/article/ca5e62255bb87bf1b151f9bf075aaadf
But Consumer Report's title isn't entirely clear either. They rank Cadillac ahead of Tesla because Super Cruise makes stronger attempts than Autopilot to make sure the driver is engaged. That isn't a bad thing, but it should be clear in the title that the "performance" they're measuring heavily weighs toward safety. It's like saying that a Volvo station wagon outperforms a Ferrari sports car because your family is safer in the Volvo. Sure, I'd rather my kids ride in a Volvo but that's not what I think of when I read the word "outperforms".
Not really surprising from CR. They've always emphasized safety--along with maintenance, cost, etc. The target audience for CR is mostly a conventional middle-class suburban family (understanding that Cadillac is still a relatively high-end car). They don't really care about car enthusiasts who are prioritizing other types of capabilities.
The numbers are pretty clear. If we want to save lives by making sure drivers are paying attention, it should be on the cars without Autopilot.
[1] https://electrek.co/2020/04/22/tesla-autopilot-data-3-billio...
Given that current traffic fatalities and injuries are rare events compared with vehicle miles traveled, we show that fully autonomous vehicles would have to be driven hundreds of millions of miles and sometimes hundreds of billions of miles to demonstrate their safety in terms of fatalities and injuries.
From "Driving to Safety - How Many Miles of Driving Would It Take to Demonstrate Autonomous Vehicle Reliability?"
On a pure deaths per mile basis Autopilot is already safer than the average car driven by the average driver. However, people downplay that by adjusting for various things making them relatively equivalent with not enough data to really say one way or another.
Basically, there is simply not enough data to be statistically significant improvement or detriment vs drivers, but there is enough data to say they are safe enough to be used.
In some ways having a human take over in difficult conditions is stacking the deck, but computers are also taking over in an crash to slow down before impact and people are adjusting how much autopilot speeds. So, it’s kind of a grey area, but at a minimum we know autopilot isn’t dramatically worse than humans.
Instead you need to count the number of times someone has actively taken control to avoid a collision, which is rare enough it’s hard to find examples.
Having an alert driver paying attention is a net benefit, but in practice people don’t continuously pay full attention for long stretches with autonomous driving. If you assume people are paying attention say 90% of the time in practice then their only catching less than 90% of the potential accidents they could avoid. Further, assuming identical rates of accidents to the average person the other car is at fault 1/2 the increase is further reduced.
As such, I think the regulation is a good idea for now as the net benefit to fully autonomous driving is to the individual while the risks include other drivers.
That said, unknown future forms of driver assistance might be relevant, but I would lump that in with better cars.
Each car in with the automated system will provide data to update all the other cars with automated systems.
I trust that process way more than individual unconnected human drivers. I don't trust Elon or Tesla corporation to care about human lives but I do trust that it will eventually get better and very quickly.
So, thank you for the altruism everyone, it will be fine.
Specifically, they insist that the system should only be usable on limited-access highways. CR docked all manufacturers (except GM) 4 points for that.
CR also docked 3 points from every company (except GM, again) for "unresponsive driver" without saying what, exactly, GM is doing differently from everyone else.
Finally, under "keeping the driver engaged", GM somehow got 3 more points than anyone else, despite being subject to the same complaints.
Sadly, CR is not the publication it used to be. While this isn't a "Tesla hit-piece", it is quite clearly a "GM submarine."
It's brilliant the Tesla has managed to convince people that things like mapping and geofencing and LIDAR are all crutches, despite the fact that they improve performance and safety.
Obviously the beta still is a long ways from true FSD, but it is clearly a massive amount more capable than it used to be, so I don't think there's any indication at all that Tesla is stuck.
1. What happens when there is unexpected construction or an accident? The geofence isn't going to be updated fast enough. Same-day updates are considered extremely fast in the mapping world.
2. What happens when there is rain or snow? LIDAR becomes useless, so the system can't be used in rain or snow. If you want an all-weather self driving car, you can't depend on LIDAR.
Edit: Humble request. Instead of just downvoting (I don't mind the downvotes), why don't you write a comment to tell me why this is wrong?
Geo-fence lets the car know that the road has been mapped so that it can correlate its sensory data against fixed data.
Rain reduces the operational distance of a LIDAR system but does not render the system useless. On the other hand, tests have shown that more than moderate amounts of rain (i.e,. more than a sprinkle) will render a camera-based system useless at both recognizing objects and at determining distances. https://ouster.com/blog/lidar-vs-camera-comparison-in-the-ra... (Most car manufacturers have already stated they will not let their advanced driving functions work in snow for safety reasons.)
Yes, I get that, and my point is that updating the geo-fence fast enough to account for changes in the ground truth which invalidate your map is an unsolved problem.
Geo-fence is the backstop safety mechanism for SuperCruise, not the primary mechanism.
They don't need to update geo-fence to account for changes to "ground truth." The whole point of the geo-fence is to confirm sensor data and assist in identifying anamolous situations like accidents and construction. If sensor data doesn't match "truth" then the self-driving system can engage safety mechanisms, engage additional processing, or disable self-driving as appropriate.
Similar to airbags- You can't only depend on them, but nobody does. That is why cars still have seatbelts
Sure, that's an fun slight-of-hand. But plenty of people are arguing that vision-only (or vision + RADAR) systems cannot possibly work, and that you must have LIDAR in addition to vision to do self-driving. If you must have LIDAR, then you can't make an all-weather system that has the same performance in good weather and bad.
It also seems odd that you would accept degraded performance during driving conditions which are especially challenging... It's like saying that you'd turn off your airbag in the rain because you still have seat belts. If anything, I would think most people would want better performance during bad driving conditions.
So, while very good autonomous driving on interstates is definitely a convenience win and doubtless could save lives, accidents on those roads are not the leading cause of auto fatalities. (Which sort of makes sense. You're often going almost as fast on those two lane roads and there are far more opportunities to have a head-on collision or to veer off the road and road maintenance/plowing/etc. is often quite a bit worse.)
[1] https://www.sutliffstout.com/faqs/where-car-accidents-happen...
If this kind of regulation were to be removed, self-driving cars like Tesla's or Cadillac's would be free to go everywhere and the technology would quickly reach massive adoption.
Of course, there is the little detail that regulation that requires cars to be safe and reliable is sane and logical and makes sense. But, if it were to be removed, there's nothing stopping self-driving cars from making a left turn into traffic at a busy intersection near you!
CR's idea of goodness is that autopiloting should only ever be allowed on pre-mapped divided highways with restricted access. Since Cadillac's only works on pre-mapped divided highways with restricted access, they get high marks. But that's not better performance. That's worse performance with a geofence to hide the details.
> “Active driving assistance systems should only be able to be activated in low-risk driving environments, void of pedestrians and tricky situations, such as intersections and complicated traffic patterns,” Funkhouser says.
But this ignores the fact that most traffic fatalities happen from human negligence in the places where Cadillac's Supercruise explicitly disables itself, rural roads + intersections. If Cadillac's system only ever activated while parked in your garage they could give it a 10/10 for safety, and it would not make the world safer.