Re:Type in the exact number of machines to proceed
by chrisseaton on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:53PM
(#24910572)
I think the whole point of the 'rule' is that they have to do it themselves.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Type in the exact number of machines to proceed
by the_af on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @05:13PM
(#24911980)
I think it would work equally well if the president had two aides and had to order one to butcher the other, in front of her eyes, in order to launch a nuclear strike.
Regardless of the exact details, I think the point of this thought experiment is that for a head of state, the decision to launch a massive attack that will cause hundreds of thousands of casualties can feel a little abstract. "Bombing a city" can seem abstract, even if the president understands this means killing children. Understanding is quite different from feeling. However, if the act of ordering a bombing raid on a city involved physically murdering a child, it would definitely feel more immediate and less abstract.
Your point stands, of course. But the part about removing the abstractness of the act seems relevant when ordering people killed.