News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:52PM (#24909966)
I see this repeated often, but it's totally incorrect, they do not resemble utilities at all, not even a little bit. I think everyone agrees these companies need more regulation, but the idea that they are in any way comparable to utilities is absurd.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @05:18PM (#24912045)
> they do not resemble utilities at all, not even a little bit.

I think that these large communication platforms absolutely resemble other large communication platforms that are currently covered by common carrier laws.

Specifically, a lot of the functionality that these platforms provides, fulfills a usecase that is similar to the phone network.

And the phone network is both a large communication platform, and is all covered by common carrier laws.

The laws need to be updated to recognize that many of the online communication platforms are now as important as the phone system, and therefore should be covered by our existing common carrier laws.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Natanael_L on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @04:21AM (#24916478)
All of this assumes an equivalence in function and access that just isn't there.

If my phone company decides who I can call, then I got issues. I can't trivially change carrier however I want.

If a website arbitrarily bans all kind of people it will soon be their own problem as people leave with a single click.

More specifically, I do not need linkedin, Facebook and co at all to communicate with people over the internet, stuff like P2P software never went away.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:25PM (#24926845)
> If my phone company decides who I can call, then I got issues.

> If a website arbitrarily bans all kind of people it will soon be their own problem as people leave with a single click.

False. I use facebook for communicating with people more often than I use the phone network.

Being banned from facebook would have a much larger effect on me, and many others, than being banned from ever making phone calls again, due to the fact that we use facebook for the vast majority of our online communication.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Natanael_L on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:10PM (#24935948)
Is that because you can not replace Facebook, or because it's merely inconvenient to do so?

Because the law doesn't protect convenience in these contexts.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:36PM (#24936255)
> Is that because you can not replace Facebook, or because it's merely inconvenient to do so

As in it would be much more difficult to replace Facebook as a communication platform for me than it would be for me to be banned from making phone calls ever again.

So facebook is more in the category of "can not replace" than being able to make phone calls.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Natanael_L on Friday October 30, 2020 @05:51AM (#24940664)
Again, is that because you literally don't have the physical option of communicating by other ways, or because the people you want to communicate with are too lazy to use another option?

If I ask you to meet me at the bar and you're banned from the bar I've selected, it's not the bar's problem.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Saturday October 31, 2020 @07:22PM (#24956061)
> literally don't have the physical option of communicating

I am saying that the problems of getting kicked off of a facebook are larger than that of getting kicked off of the communication utility that is phone calls.

And this is due to things like network effect.

And these issues and prevention that make it difficult for people to switch is larger on facebook than it is for phone calls.

So the "physical prevention" is larger for facebook than it is for phone calls.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Natanael_L on Monday November 02, 2020 @05:45PM (#24974361)
I seriously doubt that. Network effect "just" makes a particular means of communication more favorable - it doesn't prevent the use of any of the options.

Not being able to use the phone cuts you of from a lot of services where no option exists.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Tuesday November 03, 2020 @11:30PM (#24986456)
> Not being able to use the phone cuts you of from a lot of services where no option exists.

Nah, it really doesn't when compared to something like getting banned from facebook.

I make way more video calls with people than I make phone calls. And probably around 50% of my communication is done over FB message.

It would be way less of a problem to get banned from making phone calls for me and for many other people.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:25AM (#24919832)
> I think that these large communication platforms absolutely resemble other large communication platforms that are currently covered by common carrier laws

They have nothing in common except the "communication" label.

> Specifically, a lot of the functionality that these platforms provides, fulfills a usecase that is similar to the phone network

They don't. The "phone network" is what provides access to the internet, a website is not a phone company, it sits at a higher level of abstraction. That's like saying a popular TV show is a broadcast network because everyone watches that show.

> online communication platforms are now as important as the phone system

That's not true. If the top 10 most popular websites on the internet disappeared overnight there would still be many thousands of ways to communicate over the internet.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:22PM (#24926823)
> They have nothing in common except the "communication" label.

Sure they do. They have usecases in common.

There are many ways that I communicate with people, online, that has now entirely replaced me calling those people up on the phone.

That is how they are similar. They are similar in that online services are, in many cases, direct or indirect substitutes for the same exact usecase.

> They don't

They absolutely do. The shared functionality is that I no longer use phone companies anymore, and I instead use online services for that same exact content.

> That's not true.

It absolutely is true. To explain what I mean, I would say that I would truly rather be banned from the entire phone network than to be banned from something like facebook.

This is because I legitimately use facebook for communication more often than I use phones. Therefore, being banned from facebook would have a larger impact on my life than being banned from ever making a phone call again.

That is how facebook is more important than the phone network.

It is more important in that being banned from facebook would have a larger effect on my life than being banned from make phone calls ever again, due to the fact that I use facebook much much more for communication.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Thursday October 29, 2020 @01:37PM (#24932975)
> This is because I legitimately use facebook for communication more often than I use phones. Therefore, being banned from facebook would have a larger impact on my life than being banned from ever making a phone call again..

If you use Facebook as your primary communication platform I can see how getting banned from Facebook would be very inconvenient, unfortunately, the fact that you would rely on Facebook in such a manner doesn't change the reality that Facebook is just one website, while a phone network is fundamental infrastructure that underpins internet connectivity. For the vast majority of Facebook users losing access to the phone network would mean losing access to not just Facebook, but everything on the internet. You might have grown accustomed to thinking of Facebook as something more than just a website, but that conception is simply wrong, the idea that Facebook is comparable to the network that Facebook runs on is categorically incorrect.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:02PM (#24935849)
> e fact that you would rely on Facebook in such a manner

It is the reality of the situation that a whole lot of people rely on facebook in such a manner, and because of the network effect they would be unable to convince all of their friends and family to switch to other platforms.

One person cannot defeat platform locking and network effects.

> while a phone network is fundamental infrastructure

Not really. It would be easier for me to never call someone's phone number again, than to get rid of other communication platforms that I use.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:08PM (#24935923)
> It is the reality of the situation that a whole lot of people rely on facebook

You're just wrong. The overwhelming majority of people use a variety of communication services like e-mail, imessage/sms and many others, and this is common knowledge, people who only use Facebook for communication are frankly extremely rare.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @05:38PM (#24936296)
> people who only

I am saying that they rely on it more for communication than they do on phone calls.

I communicate with people much more over Facebook than I do through actual phone calls, and it would be less of a problem to be banned from ever making phone calls again than it would be to be banned from facebook.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:16PM (#24936761)
> I am saying that they rely on it more for communication than they do on phone calls.

Nobody is talking about phone calls and you know it. It doesn't matter that you use Facebook more than anything else, it doesn't change what Facebook actually is. If you use discord or slack to do most of your communicating that doesn't mean they become utilities, that's just your personal preference.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @06:39PM (#24936957)
> Nobody is talking about phone calls

Literally I was the one to bring up this example in the very beginning. It was my example, that I chose at the start. So yes, that is relevant.

The fact of the matter is, that me being banned from ever making phone calls again would absolutely be a larger problem for me, and many other people, than if we were banned from using facebook.

> It doesn't matter that you use Facebook more than anything else

Of course it does. It is a point of comparison, so as to show that it would be a bigger problem to be banned from facebook than it would be to be banned from making phone calls.

> that's just your personal preference.

I can assure you that there are many people for whom it would be a bigger problem to be banned from facebook than to be banned from making phone calls.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Thursday October 29, 2020 @07:55PM (#24937535)
> It was my example, that I chose at the start. So yes, that is relevant.

It's not relevant because you're ignoring the fact that "the phone network" doesn't primarily mean "phone calls" it primarily means "internet access".

> The fact of the matter is, that me being banned from ever making phone calls again would absolutely be a larger problem for me

Yes, you keep repeating that over and over again (3 times in this response) but what you don't seem to understand is that nobody is forcing you to rely exclusively on a single website for all your communications, that is a self-imposed restriction that isn't meaningful when trying to decide if a website meets the definition of a utility.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @08:40PM (#24937885)
> what you don't seem to understand is that nobody is forcing you to rely exclusively on a single website for all your communications

That does not change the fact that it would be a bigger problem for me to be banned from facebook than it would be for me to be banned from making phone calls, lol.

So when you say this "nobody is forcing you", you are ignoring the fact that they would be forcing a problem on me that would be larger than if I were banned from making phone calls.

So yes. They would be forcing an issue on me that would be larger than if they banned me from making phone calls.

> ignoring the fact that "the phone network"

Phone systems have fallen under utilities laws since before the internet existed. Therefore the analogy to phone calls is relevant.

You can look at home phone line systems. A home phone lines, that gives zero internet access, still falls under utilities laws.

Are you aware that a landline, that gives zero internet access, would still have to follow utilities laws? Just want to make sure you are aware of that.

> meets the definition of a utility

A perfectly reasonable thing to do is compare it to how much a problem it would be to switch from a different utility.

A landline, that has no internet access, is a utility. It falls under utilities laws, even if the singular only thing that it does, is make phone calls, without any internet access. Phone calls, without internet, is a utility.

And switching away from the system that only allows you to make phone calls, and has no internet, and is therefore a utility, would be easier than switching away from facebook.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:08PM (#24938391)
It doesn't matter what's easier, it matters that facebook is just a website, not something that at all resembles a utility.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Thursday October 29, 2020 @10:23PM (#24938479)
> It doesn't matter what's easier

Sure it does. It matters regarding the justification for the law.

Yes, I understand that common carrier laws do not currently apply to facebook. But, I am saying that the law should be changed so that that do apply to them.

And the justification for this, is because we have utility laws that currently apply to things like a phone system, (even if that phone system provides no internet), and yet it is easier for me to switch from that than it is to switch from facebook.

I understand that the laws don't currently apply to facebook. But it absolutely does resemble a utility in that the problems that it pushes on people are larger than that of other utilities.

That is how it resembles it. The problems are larger than that of another similar utility.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by goodluckchuck on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:59PM (#24910030)
How so?
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:00PM (#24910047)
It's absurd on its face and this topic has been beaten to death on this forum; the burden of demonstrating why social media websites are like utilities rests on the person making the claim.

However, for the sake of discussion, I'll start out with the fact that a privately owned website is not an example of shared public infrastructure. Think water, electricity and other basic staples of civilization... Facebook is not an example of that.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by scbrg on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:05PM (#24910095)
I admit I use some Google services. At the same time, I have no relationship with the non G:s of FAANG, which arguably is 80% of them (though perhaps not 80% of the influence). I'm not sure how they can really be considered public utilities at that point. None of the services they provide are essential.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by strawberrypuree on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:14PM (#24910167)
Much of the web is hosted on AWS. So, you have an invisible relationship with Amazon. Same with Facebook and their trackers, unless you block them.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by scbrg on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @04:23PM (#24911426)
> Much of the web is hosted on AWS.

Fair enough. I'm sure I use some web sites that are hosted on AWS, I did not consider that.

> Same with Facebook and their trackers, unless you block them.

That may be (though I block at least some of them), but that's hardly equivalent. I don't depend in any way on Facebook tracking me. If they stopped, I would certainly not suffer from it.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by stale2002 on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @05:20PM (#24912065)
> None of the services they provide are essential.

I use online messaging and online communication more than I use the telephone network.

To me, and many others, these online platforms are as or more essential than the phone system, which is already covered by common carrier laws.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Natanael_L on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @04:25AM (#24916498)
Utility regulation doesn't depend only on importance. It depends on importance plus access.

That's why your local grocery store can ban you even if food is necessary for your survival, because you didn't lose access to other sources (stores).

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by root_axis on Wednesday October 28, 2020 @11:29AM (#24919885)
> I use online messaging and online communication more than I use the telephone network.

That's your choice, you don't have to use any particular online messaging service. My cousins communicate over steam more than over SMS, that doesn't mean steam is a utility.

Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by Ensorceled on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:02PM (#24910067)
I can cook dinner, heat my house, call 911 and even check out government websites on the internet without google or facebook.
Re:Facebook has sent a cease-and-desist letter to researchers by ethanwillis on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @08:07PM (#24913507)
More government websites are relying on infrastructure from these companies. S3, cloudfront, etc.

And don't worry soon enough Amazon themselves will insert themselves between you and 911 https://aws.amazon.com/blogs/publicsector/modernizing-911-to...

Edit: I would like to point out my original parent comment that started all of this was in the context of FAANGs not just Google/Facebook