Part of obtaining a trademark is doing due diligence and finding out how the name is being used in public. That includes use that isn't trademarked, but is publicly visible.
This is a different matter, since it's about a username on a private service, but the principle still holds. Danah has no legal recourse in this instance, but it does show that Tumblr is acting hastily and, in my view, improperly, by just yanking her account away from her without notice, appeal, or recourse.
I'm surprised there aren't many famous 'double' trademarks. The only one that springs to mind is Jif, the lemon juice, and Jif, the kitchen cleaner which were both household names in the UK. The kitchen cleaner renamed to Cif as part of a global brand realignment, though.
Apple Records (Beatles) and Apple (Steve Jobs). They started with an agreement to stay clear of the others turf, but then Apple Computing got into music. I think they went to court before working something out.
WWF (World Wrestling Federation vs World Wildlife Fund). They went to court and the wrestling became WWE.
I agree. But she wasn't trying to pass herself off as anyone else, merely use the handle she's been using for over a decade.
> Yanking it out from under her and selling it to someone else is just rude at best, and criminal at worst.
I don't see how it's criminal, though I agree it's rude. I run the MeowCat messaging website (http://meowc.at/ -- it's a cross between Twitter and blogging) and I certainly wouldn't allow a company to take over a user's identity like Tumblr have done.
So if you're reading this Danah, if you want to create Zephoria on MeowCat, I promise I won't give your account to someone else.
Not even for $1000? $5,000? $10,000? We don't know if a favour was done or paid, if any.
And what value have YOU added to the conversation?
> THAT turns out to be empty words?
This will only be the case if at some time I renege on this promise, which I don't intend to do.
To do something that slimy and not get paid for it is stupid. (The fact that it was stupid in the first place does affect the fact that not getting paid for it is stupid in itself.)
If she really was using their name improperly, Tumblr would have been within their rights... But they STILL should have contacted her first and let her try to explain. Yanking it out from under her and selling it to someone else is just rude at best, and criminal at worst. (I'm assuming they sold it... If they didn't, they're dumber than I think. This kind of BS isn't worth it unless they get something from it.)