Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:28AM
(#24904694)
People who menstruate need menstrual products. Not all women menstruate, and transmen may menstruate and certainly, by definition, do not identify as women, and that's even before considering those of nonbinary gender identity.
“People who menstruate” (the term actually used) is different from “menstruators” (the latter is reductionist, the former identifies a trait of people without reducing them to that trait, merely identifying it as one of many traits they have that may or may not be central to their identity; the difference is approximately that between “breeders” and “people with children”.)
If you have to change the term used in order to get upset at it, maybe you are trying a little to hard to find an excuse to be upset.
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by dragonwriter on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:48AM
(#24904778)
> I don’t understand why it has to be bought up.
It was literally a campaign about menstrual hygiene and making menstrual products available to people who need them. Do you not understand:
(1) Why the campaign was needed, or
(2) Why in the course of conducting the campaign it was necessary to make some reference to the people whose needs the campaign sought to address, or
(3) Why the campaign chose to use a term that accurately identified the group it sought to serve without denying the gender identity of any of them?
If it is the last, you should understand that when one is having a campaign about awareness of and access to menstrual products, an important focus is likely to be transmen [0]. As such, identifying the target beneficiaries as “women” or “women and girls” is counterproductive.
> Post menopausal women do not menstruate. They are women. Not ex-menstruators.
Once again, no one (except the complainer) used the term “menstruator” anywhere in this scenario.
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @04:36AM
(#24905471)
Ok. Now I see what you meant. I am late to this as I am catching up at the end of the year. Apologies. I didn’t know the original article was about Covid and menstruation hygiene.
I hope you will accept my apologies for dismissing you. Altho’ I still do think you were a little condescending but that’s ok. You were trying to communicate something I missed.
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by pksebben on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:36AM
(#24904729)
Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist - It's a term for someone who is a feminist, but doesn't want Trans people benefiting from their activism, or identifying as anything other than what they were assigned at birth.
Depending on who you ask, it's either a ridiculous leftist flailing or a legitimate painting of a behavior as a kind of uncle-tom-ism. I tend towards the latter, myself.
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by pksebben on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @02:16AM
(#24904885)
replying to
> I don’t get it. Who is 1. The minority 2. Dominant group 3. Oppressor?
...because we have reached peak nesting.
2 + 3 are the same thing - in this context, as we are talking about feminism, cis white males. Why cis and white? Because that is the demographic that has held the strongest monopoly on cultural and political power - from priests to politicians.
1. The minority (defined, in this case, as the class(es) with inferior cultural and political power) - is sort of the sticking point between a TERF and not-a-TERF.
If you are a TERF, you define the boundaries of this class as "assigned at birth biological women" - these are your compatriots for whom you march to get rights for. In your opinion, there is no Uncle Tomming happening, because you are engaging in the fight with all good faith that the oppressed (women by your definition) are being represented against the entrenched desires of the opressors (men).
However, if you are of the opinion that the circle of individuals deserving of representation includes both assigned-at-birth and Trans women, then by your standard, any woman who engages in the same oppressive behavior that men do (in targeting or singling out Trans individuals for derision / marginalization) is an Uncle Tom. They are more closely identifying themselves with the oppressor than the oppressed.
Mind you, this is not to say that
a) all cis white males are actively engaged in being oppressive
or
b) women, whether they are labeled as a Terf or not, are part of the oppressing class
...it is merely a distinction useful to those who are of the belief that as go one, go all, and that Trans women have just as much a right to be recognized as such.
edit: apologies, I suppose I just missed the appropriate 'reply' button, but I swear it wasn't showing up before.
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by pksebben on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:50AM
(#24904781)
Precisely, yes. Specifically
> In a broader context, the term may refer to a minority's strategy of coping with oppression from socially, culturally, or economically dominant groups involving suppression of aggressive feelings and even identification with the oppressor, leading to forced assimilation/acculturation of the cultural minority.[3]
Re:We shouldn’t call women ‘menstruators’
by jelliclesfarm on Tuesday October 27, 2020 @01:57AM
(#24904814)
https://www.shethepeople.tv/lgbtqia/menstruators-a-gender-ne... [..] This history of the word Menstruator actually goes back to the third wave of feminism in the west- almost 30 years ago. Often TERFs – Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminists have spoken about the term ‘menstruators’ being erasure of femininity. But, femininity is not biological, so why should it be centred around this. Also, this does not in any way complicate ‘periods’ or ‘feminism’ but instead nuance it. This has been a common critique for the inclusion of any intersectionality in feminism, but intersectionality makes feminism more comprehensive. Another thing to notice is the constant discourse around the ‘body’. It says, transmasculine people still have ‘female bodies’, but using such terminology delegitimises trans people by reducing them to their anatomy. This implicit construction of gender through biological sex leads to violence against trans people, discrimination in availing health care and complete erasure of non-binary folks.[..]
Why can’t transgender people call themselves transgender? If anything we must work towards erasing the taboo around transgender.
“People who menstruate” (the term actually used) is different from “menstruators” (the latter is reductionist, the former identifies a trait of people without reducing them to that trait, merely identifying it as one of many traits they have that may or may not be central to their identity; the difference is approximately that between “breeders” and “people with children”.)
If you have to change the term used in order to get upset at it, maybe you are trying a little to hard to find an excuse to be upset.
Post menopausal women do not menstruate. They are women. Not ex-menstruators.
It was literally a campaign about menstrual hygiene and making menstrual products available to people who need them. Do you not understand:
(1) Why the campaign was needed, or
(2) Why in the course of conducting the campaign it was necessary to make some reference to the people whose needs the campaign sought to address, or
(3) Why the campaign chose to use a term that accurately identified the group it sought to serve without denying the gender identity of any of them?
If it is the last, you should understand that when one is having a campaign about awareness of and access to menstrual products, an important focus is likely to be transmen [0]. As such, identifying the target beneficiaries as “women” or “women and girls” is counterproductive.
> Post menopausal women do not menstruate. They are women. Not ex-menstruators.
Once again, no one (except the complainer) used the term “menstruator” anywhere in this scenario.
[0] as an illustration of why, https://www.nbcnews.com/feature/nbc-out/transgender-men-pain...
I hope you will accept my apologies for dismissing you. Altho’ I still do think you were a little condescending but that’s ok. You were trying to communicate something I missed.
Thanks. I will check out the links.
Depending on who you ask, it's either a ridiculous leftist flailing or a legitimate painting of a behavior as a kind of uncle-tom-ism. I tend towards the latter, myself.
ETA: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncle_Tom_syndrome
Is this what you meant?
> I don’t get it. Who is 1. The minority 2. Dominant group 3. Oppressor?
...because we have reached peak nesting.
2 + 3 are the same thing - in this context, as we are talking about feminism, cis white males. Why cis and white? Because that is the demographic that has held the strongest monopoly on cultural and political power - from priests to politicians.
1. The minority (defined, in this case, as the class(es) with inferior cultural and political power) - is sort of the sticking point between a TERF and not-a-TERF.
If you are a TERF, you define the boundaries of this class as "assigned at birth biological women" - these are your compatriots for whom you march to get rights for. In your opinion, there is no Uncle Tomming happening, because you are engaging in the fight with all good faith that the oppressed (women by your definition) are being represented against the entrenched desires of the opressors (men).
However, if you are of the opinion that the circle of individuals deserving of representation includes both assigned-at-birth and Trans women, then by your standard, any woman who engages in the same oppressive behavior that men do (in targeting or singling out Trans individuals for derision / marginalization) is an Uncle Tom. They are more closely identifying themselves with the oppressor than the oppressed.
Mind you, this is not to say that a) all cis white males are actively engaged in being oppressive or b) women, whether they are labeled as a Terf or not, are part of the oppressing class
...it is merely a distinction useful to those who are of the belief that as go one, go all, and that Trans women have just as much a right to be recognized as such.
edit: apologies, I suppose I just missed the appropriate 'reply' button, but I swear it wasn't showing up before.
> In a broader context, the term may refer to a minority's strategy of coping with oppression from socially, culturally, or economically dominant groups involving suppression of aggressive feelings and even identification with the oppressor, leading to forced assimilation/acculturation of the cultural minority.[3]
Strictly speaking, this isn't correct since their advocacy includes trans men, since they view them as female.
Why can’t transgender people call themselves transgender? If anything we must work towards erasing the taboo around transgender.