News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by throwaway0a5e on Monday October 26, 2020 @08:19AM (#24895307)
So we should tax the crap out of everyone's estates on the premise that they probably wronged society and that society will need to pay to un-screw up whatever they did?!? Whatever happened to giving people the benefit of the doubt? Whatever happens to presumption of innocence?

Firstly anyone with a brain is gonna conveniently go broke before they die if you try and pull something like that.

Second I'm struggling to find words for just how fundamentally wrong, unethical and dystopian the assumptions that underlie your comment are. I and a hell of a lot of people don't want to live in a society where assuming malice is the default like that.

Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by nix0n on Monday October 26, 2020 @08:47AM (#24895551)
> So we should tax the crap out of everyone's estates

Just the wealthy. Estate taxes have (in the USA) applied only to large estates.

> on the premise that they probably wronged society

Some wealth is inherited now, but large gains (extracted from the market) are generally the result of exploitation.

> anyone with a brain is gonna conveniently go broke before they die

That's already happening, they call it The Giving Project.

Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by burrows on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:37PM (#24898769)
Is there a precise definition for ‘exploitation’? Is it a function of feelings?
Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by ses1984 on Monday October 26, 2020 @08:22AM (#24895338)
How about we just tax the crap out of everyone's estates so that our democracy doesn't devolve into a feudal oligarchy.

Oops, too late.

Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by charlesu on Monday October 26, 2020 @09:15AM (#24895799)
We should tax the crap out of everyone’s estates because it’s aligned with the American value of equal opportunity. Do you want to live in a society where everyone has a fair shot? Then you need the estate tax. It’s the great equalizer. We can the funds to improve our schools, roads, and social services so that everyone is a bit better off.
Re:L.A.'s coast was once a DDT dumping ground, but no one co... by dahfizz on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:05PM (#24901380)
> We should tax the crap out of everyone’s estates because it’s aligned with the American value of equal opportunity. Do you want to live in a society where everyone has a fair shot?

I do not understand this sentiment one bit. To think that we should implement equality by pulling people down to the mean is, frankly, insane. That does nothing to help anyone - its a stance based solely on anger and jealousy. Your policy would literally decrease the average quality of life.

Would you be happy if everyone was destitute? At what point do you realize that actual quality of life matters more than perfect equality?

We achieve equality by bringing people up, not tearing them down. If you think we need more tax money to accomplish that goal, I would argue that we have much more of a budgeting problem than a tax income problem, but I understand the sentiment. But to think that the appropriate tax vehicle is to explicitly destroy lives is not an American ideal.