Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by sandworm101 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @06:05PM
(#24890374)
It is a cute policy, a historical anachronism. In these days of internet databases and facial recognition the actual security advantage of not knowing someone's last name is minimal. Anyone who really wants to can find it.
As a basic first-order op, start with a the graduation photos of the elite British schools, which wouldn't be hard to get from their libraries. Pass that to some basic facial recognition software and within minute you will have all those secret last names.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by rmrfstar on Sunday October 25, 2020 @06:29PM
(#24890618)
You're definitely correct, but its more like "scrape Facebook and Linkedin in real time".
This measure is probably more about generating mystique that is useful for recruiting than it is about maintaining security.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by pjc50 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @06:16PM
(#24890480)
.. and a visit from GCHQ informing you that you've breached the official secrets act.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by sandworm101 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @06:30PM
(#24890630)
Anyone who matters, anyone properly dangerous from whom GCHQ wants to hide, doesn't care much about official secrets acts. Any KGB (ie russia's FSB) wouldn't hesitate. But it would be an interesting exercise. A visit to the oxbridge libraries, then compare those faces to everyone walking the streets around MI5/6. Seems rather tame compared to all the other things we know have been done.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by pjc50 on Monday October 26, 2020 @05:38AM
(#24894326)
Entertainingly Bellingcat is doing the same thing to the GRU: https://www.bellingcat.com/news/2020/02/25/an-officer-and-a-...
(people should stop using "KGB" to refer to any Russian intelligence service, it's just fighting a war that ended 30 years ago)
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by sandworm101 on Monday October 26, 2020 @06:20AM
(#24894532)
KGB means state security service. There are plenty of KGBs around the world in places like Belarus. Only russia has renamed its KGB to FSB.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by qz2 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @04:12PM
(#24889497)
I think I'd probably spend most of the meeting trying to find out their real names.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by noir_lord on Sunday October 25, 2020 @04:52PM
(#24889785)
I'd like to ask them how they square the circle morally by supporting an agency that under the most optimistic interpretation breaks the law constantly.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by cmdshiftf4 on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:51PM
(#24892063)
At this point in time I’d almost go as far as saying those working in something as ethically disagreeable as cigarette production would be justified in guffawing at the hypocrisy should some tech worker bring up the morality of their work with them.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by DanBC on Sunday October 25, 2020 @06:45PM
(#24890743)
They claim that they don't break the law.
Most of the UK laws do specifically have sections allowing the security services to operate.
Re:Secrets and spies: Behind the doors of the GCHQ
by hevelvarik on Monday October 26, 2020 @01:44AM
(#24893142)
Yeah the UK would be much better off without an intelligence agency and if only the West would lay down its arms. Imagine!
It was amusing going to tech meetings in London, when GCHQ/NCSC staff sometimes attend. The spooks are blatantly obvious with their first-name-only badges :-)