News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Admitting That Functional Programming Can Be Awkward (2007) by fiddlerwoaroof on Saturday October 24, 2020 @12:40PM (#24880264)
This is sometimes true, the `=` equivalent in Clojure is an expression, though:

   user=> (def a (def b 2))
   user=> a
   #'b
Lisps generally only have expressions (every form returns a value.
Re:Admitting That Functional Programming Can Be Awkward (2007) by gnulinux on Saturday October 24, 2020 @12:45PM (#24880300)
Lisp runtime implicitly runs each top-level expression as statement. When you run (def x y) it's not only true that this expression returns 'x, it's also true that it alters the static state of the program by adding 'x to the scope.

To make a purely statementless language, I think you need to make everything happen in a single monadic computation. E.g. in pseudo-Haskell-ish:

    main : Scope -> StaticIO Scope
    main scope0 = do
      scope1, x' <- def scope0 "x" Int
      scope2, xv <- dec scope1 "x" 3
But the main part is still statement.
Re:Admitting That Functional Programming Can Be Awkward (2007) by tsimionescu on Saturday October 24, 2020 @01:39PM (#24880707)
At least in all of the discussions I have seen, the difference between statements and expressions is whether they return a value, not whether they have side-effects. So (def x b) is an expression, because it returns a value. {} in C is a statement, even though it has no side effects.

Now, there are some statements in CL as far as I remember - I believe (declaim x integer) is a kind of statement, at least in the sense above.

But you can write a CL program that doesn't use a single statement.

Re:Admitting That Functional Programming Can Be Awkward (2007) by fiddlerwoaroof on Saturday October 24, 2020 @05:36PM (#24882132)
The return value of some forms is implementation dependent, but all forms return a value in CL:

    CL-USER(1): (defparameter *foo* (declaim (special x)))    
    *FOO*
    CL-USER(2): *foo*
    (X)
    CL-USER(3): (defparameter *bar* (declaim (type integer x)))
    *BAR*
    CL-USER(4): *bar*    
    (X)

In other cases, e.g. `(values)` which is an expression that returns no values, the value is nil