News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by resfirestar on Friday October 23, 2020 @05:32PM (#24874446)
Worth noting the MPA already tried doing this to Popcorn Time, a BitTorrent client designed to provide a Netflix-like UX.[1] The Popcorn Time devs put in a counter-notice and the repository was back up a few weeks later when the period for the MPA to respond expired.

The same thing will probably happen here because this is not one of the purposes of DMCA takedown letters, period. Even if there are inappropriate test cases or something in the repo, or if they’re correct that youtube-dl bypasses DRM in violation of a different part of the DMCA, it’s still not a valid takedown because GitHub isn’t hosting anything the RIAA/those it represents own the copyright to. The correct way to do this is to go after the lead youtube-dl developer(s) and/or GitHub for facilitating infringement or whatever, but I don’t think RIAA wants to do that because they probably don’t have much/any legitimate grounds for legal claims against them, so they abuse the DMCA to look like they’re doing something.

Edit: for a more concrete picture of what happens next, read GitHub’s DMCA policy.[2] Basically youtube-dl can file a counter notice assuming they disagree with the claims, after that the RIAA has 10-14 days to get a court order or the repo goes back up.

[1] https://torrentfreak.com/github-reinstates-popcorn-time-code...

[2] https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-...

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by quotemstr on Friday October 23, 2020 @05:40PM (#24874531)
It's interesting how many Github counternotices (e.g., [1] [2]) seem completely justified yet link to repositories that are no longer on GitHub. I wonder what happened.

[1] in https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2020/05/2020-05-0... someone forked a permissively-licensed project; the original author made the project-closed source, then issued a DMCA takedown against the fork. That's clearly bogus: you can't revoke an open source license.

[2] in https://github.com/github/dmca/blob/master/2019/11/2019-11-2... Microsoft DMCAd a project that did something with Windows local licensing keys. I can see how Microsoft would prefer that this project not exist, but I see no infringement. Not everything that a big company dislikes is an infringement of copyright.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by judge2020 on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:20PM (#24874912)
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by junon on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:48PM (#24875164)
WTF this isn't copyright infringement. This is breach of TOS, technically. They have no grounds to use DMCA takedowns for this.

How in the world is Github allowing this?

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by resfirestar on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:01PM (#24875280)
DMCA doesn’t give the service provider much room to adjudicate these claims. The intended way to correct bogus DMCA notices is a counter notice. GitHub’s particular policy says they reinstate content 10-14 days after getting a counter notice, unless the claimant gets a restraining order: https://docs.github.com/en/free-pro-team@latest/github/site-...
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by Griffinsauce on Saturday October 24, 2020 @04:30AM (#24877778)
DMCA! jazz hands

Github basically has no choice here, they must take it down immediately and then they or the creator has to fight to get it back up.

The law is set up for DOS attacks.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by nitrogen on Saturday October 24, 2020 @01:28PM (#24880618)
One of the earlier worries about the DMCA takedown process was that it would be used fraudulently to take down important things right before an election, or during a breaking news window to bury a story. I wonder if anyone has tried that yet.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by sildur on Saturday October 24, 2020 @09:57AM (#24879253)
Pity. I really liked rubymine, and while I used it legally, I really dislike abusing the DMCA like that. Time to search for an alternative.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by odensc on Saturday October 24, 2020 @03:14AM (#24877531)
Those repos have a 404 response, which means the user decided to delete it themselves for whatever reason. Repos taken down from DMCA return 451 (unavailable for legal reasons).
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by blazespin on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:34PM (#24875040)
I just used windows-g to record upside down music video. Seems to work fine. mp4 file is in my captures video. Sound is great. How is that acceptable and this isn't?

btw, Popcorn time is a bit different situation. I would say bit torrent is more the problem, or at least the people who upload pirated content.

What is odd though is that it's the RIAA filing suit here and not google. Google has a real complaint, RIAA certainly does not.

It would be like if NYT went after a web client for saving news articles for offline reading.

Bizarre.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by lgregg on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:53PM (#24875656)
> What is odd though is that it's the RIAA filing suit here and not google. Google has a real complaint, RIAA certainly does not.

Probably not wanting to poke a hornets nest of the open source community.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by nexuist on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:59PM (#24875260)
> How is that acceptable and this isn't?

Because Microsoft can afford lawyers to fight this, and random GitHub projects can't. It's an intimidation tactic.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by Griffinsauce on Saturday October 24, 2020 @04:27AM (#24877765)
It's copyright terrorism.

The aim is fear.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by resfirestar on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:54PM (#24875212)
What’s the difference? The main one I can see is that the RIAA is accusing ytdl of being a DRM circumvention tool while Popcorn Time is just a straightforward P2P infringement tool. That doesn’t make the DMCA notice any more valid.

I guess I’m nitpicking but it’s important that they’re not “filing suit”, possibly because they don’t care enough or don’t think they have a case. DMCA takedown is a sort of dispute resolution process mandated by law, it’s not a substitute for an actual lawsuit.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by Wowfunhappy on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:36PM (#24875052)
Can you use the DMCA for a TOS breech? It's not obvious to me that Google would have a claim.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by sudosysgen on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:42PM (#24875600)
TOS don't really have any legal power, and you don't even have to accept TOS to use youtube-dl, so I guess the worst they could do would be to deny you service.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by swiley on Saturday October 24, 2020 @11:02AM (#24879612)
All this misuse of technology is going to bring back the kinescope.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by ls612 on Friday October 23, 2020 @06:39PM (#24875076)
Well I for one hope you are correct. The fact that popcorn time is still up gives me hope that ytdl will also return soon.
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by ebg13 on Friday October 23, 2020 @07:48PM (#24875628)
Is there any chance that someone could sue them for filing illegitimate claims?
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by aww_dang on Friday October 23, 2020 @10:15PM (#24876376)
Yes, but it is more difficult than just spamming DMCA takedown requests. I was told I need to prove "tortuous business interference".
Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by kordlessagain on Friday October 23, 2020 @11:46PM (#24876781)
Tortious Interference with Contract

To prove tortious interference with a contract, a plaintiff must establish several elements, including that The defendant’s conduct led to a breach of the contract; and The plaintiff suffered damage as a result.

The question would be whether Github users suffered a breach of contract for having any of our repos potentially shut down for a reason that involves a third party's claims of violation of DMCA.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by aww_dang on Saturday October 24, 2020 @12:47AM (#24877024)
As I recall, there was also an element where the DMCA claimant was protected if they could reasonably believe within good faith that their takedown was valid.

There's also unseen elements at play. If you're publishing semi-anonymously, the counter-claim process can deanonymize you.

Republishing the same content at a slightly different URL is the obvious, cheapest solution.

Very few people have been able to claim damages from false DMCA takedowns, although the DMCA specifically allows for it.

Re:YouTube-dl has received a DMCA takedown from RIAA by zucker42 on Saturday October 24, 2020 @01:13AM (#24877119)
They probably can't go after Github because part of the purpose of DMCA takedowns is that companies which honor takedowns avoid liability for copyright infringement.