News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Halide Mark II by AnonHP on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:06PM (#24861140)
That was confusing. When I saw the app and that it offers in-app purchases, I thought something minimal would be possible without a purchase. But after downloading and launching it, I see the prompt to buy the subscription or the one time purchase, and nothing more. The app description on the store doesn’t make this — that a purchase must be made to use it — clear either.

Edit: An observation I’ve had is that third party camera apps on iOS have a niche audience because they cannot be the default app. If you swipe left on the Lock Screen or tap on the camera icon on the Lock Screen, only Apple’s stock camera will open. I hope Apple adds more app types to have defaults set to third party apps. I know Apple cares about camera launch time and how quickly photos can be taken. There could be a minimum performance threshold set for that. It’s high time!

Re:Halide Mark II by sandofsky on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:43PM (#24861719)
Halide author here. Previously, you would pay-once at the time of download, so this isn't much different than what we had before.

That said, we wish the App Store offered a better solution than what we had to settle with; we'd much rather people know up-front the business model than download the app, be surprised, and possibly leave a negative review.

As far as replacing the first party camera, it's by far our top user request. Some users have come up with interesting hacks via shortcuts or the back-tap gesture, but we'd much rather the user be able to customize it similar to how iOS now lets you set a different default browser. Hopefully someday!

Re:Halide Mark II by ValentineC on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:46PM (#24863114)
Random Halide user here. (I haven't upgraded the app because I'd rather any bugs be ironed out first.)

I think there should be more details on what customers get with either Pay-Once (which all existing purchasers get), and/or the Membership.

If I were a new user, I would think that Pay-Once means that I'm set for life(time of the product) (seeing as how it's equivalent to slightly under 3 years of membership payments), but the comments here sound like there's a basic feature set that new users would have to pay ~$30 for at first, and newer features would be restricted to people who commit additional regular annual payments.

It's very confusing.

Re:Halide Mark II by ThinkBeat on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:05PM (#24863288)
I hate apps that you download and the first thing you have to do is to pay.

It is a dark pattern as far as I am concerned. Peple have invest a little more In an when they dowloaded it to their phones so it might possibly get a better conversion rate.

What is even more annoying in this pattern is that you have to fill out all sorts of data and configuration and once yo are done with all that and the app owner has collected all that nice data, you are prompted to pay and no other action is possible.

Further it hides the true cost of the app, unless you go to the app page on the app store scroll al the way down the page and click on the little arrow to see what the in app prices are.

I strongly prefer pricing up front. It is easy to understand, honest, and clear.

Re:Halide Mark II by andrewmunsell on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:45PM (#24861759)
So, genuine question-- why did Apple allow Mk II into the App Store if the first screen is a "you must make a purchase", which is exactly what they rejected Hey for? Is there a trial of some sort to satisfy the requirement that your app has to "work" on download (edit: or are Apple IAP paywalls ok and I am just misunderstanding the App Store rules, which is very easy to do...)?
Re:Halide Mark II by frakkingcylons on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:08PM (#24862061)
Apple’s issue with Hey was that you couldn’t pay for it via IAP.
Re:Halide Mark II by xcrjm on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:12PM (#24862122)
The problem with Hey is that they were directing you to their website, circumventing apple's payment mechanisms. If you're using their stuff and giving them their cut you're gucci.
Re:Halide Mark II by red_trumpet on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:11PM (#24862106)
This article (https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/16/21293419/hey-apple-reject...) suggests that Hey was rejected because it didn't use Apple's in-app purchases?
Re:Halide Mark II by andrewmunsell on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:19PM (#24862225)
Which could make sense, but Phil Schiller actually directly said

> “You download the app and it doesn’t work, that’s not what we want on the store,”

https://techcrunch.com/2020/06/18/interview-apples-schiller-...

Now, he does follow with (quoting the TechCrunch article):

> This, he says, is why Apple requires in-app purchases to offer the same purchasing functionality as they would have elsewhere.

So, even though I, as a user, may consider the app to "not work" if it just asks me for a purchase immediately, Apple appears to consider an IAP prompt to be ok.

Anyways, I am an Halide v1 user so I have access to Mk II and love the app, but I'm just curious about how Apple makes these decisions.

Re:Halide Mark II by cpmsmith on Thursday October 22, 2020 @03:54PM (#24862622)
He was certainly being disingenuous about that. Whether or not an app requires a payment to do anything is entirely orthogonal to its method of accepting the payment. Hey was rejected because they didn't use in-app purchases, no question about it.
Re:Halide Mark II by K0balt on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:42PM (#24863089)
IAP increases their valuation because it is categorized as recurrent revenue? Is this some kind of accounting hack? Or is it just that they get a bigger percentage of IAP?

Scummy at any rate, Apple.

Re:Halide Mark II by unicornporn on Friday October 23, 2020 @08:30AM (#24868742)
Great to see you're here.

Just so you know, I tried to open the app for 3 minutes or so before realizing I'm getting nowhere without paying. At that point I was so pissed off I uninstalled the app thinking to myself: scam attempt.

Make it clear you have to pay to even launch your app. I don't believe this dark pattern is the way forward. It's just dirty.

Re:Halide Mark II by AnonHP on Friday October 23, 2020 @04:37AM (#24867222)
> That said, we wish the App Store offered a better solution than what we had to settle with; we'd much rather people know up-front the business model than download the app, be surprised, and possibly leave a negative review.

GP here. I was indeed surprised after downloading the app because the business model was not known (I didn't leave any reviews though). I haven't purchased the previous version and have no experience with the app.

My issue is not about your business model in that comment, but with the App Store description not saying that the application is usable only by an in-app purchase. I wouldn't even have downloaded it if that were clear. You should update the description to make it clear that the app is completely useless without buying an in-app purchase.

Re:Halide Mark II by jrrrr on Thursday October 22, 2020 @04:22PM (#24862881)
What's the backstory here? (why did you have to settle on free-with-immediate-IAP?)
Re:Halide Mark II by deergomoo on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:34PM (#24863545)
I’m guessing because they want to offer both a pay upfront option _and_ a subscription option. There’s no way to do this on iOS.
Re:Halide Mark II by emdowling on Friday October 23, 2020 @05:04AM (#24867367)
I agree with other posters - the issue isn't that Apple doesn't better support your business model, it's that you aren't honest about it in the app description.

Also, even in the app you don't have a clear statement saying that you must purchase a subscription to use it. I spent 5 minutes thinking I was missing an "X" in the top corner or some kind of "dismiss" action that would let me use basic functionality before buying.

Re:Halide Mark II by iamunr on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:30PM (#24861503)
Such a sad part of iOS.

I have several high quality photo apps I prefer, and almost always end up using the default one because its easier to access.

Re:Halide Mark II by skavi on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:37PM (#24861627)
To be fair, Android also doesn’t make third party camera apps accessible while locked.
Re:Halide Mark II by jotux on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:48PM (#24861802)
Just installed a 3rd party app on my pixel 3, made it the default and tried this. Worked just fine and popped up the 3rd party app.
Re:Halide Mark II by comeonseriously on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:48PM (#24863661)
But why bring up Android at all? Halide doesn't work on Android and this entire discussion is about iOS.
Re:Halide Mark II by freeone3000 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @02:42PM (#24861713)
I can bind double-tap on the side key to any app, and my lock screen launcher can have any complication it likes. So, yes?
Re:Halide Mark II by ayoisaiah on Thursday October 22, 2020 @06:54PM (#24864164)
That's not true. You can change the lockscreen shortcuts on Samsung phones for example
Re:Halide Mark II by LeoPanthera on Thursday October 22, 2020 @07:47PM (#24864597)
I'm so tired of everything becoming a subscription. The worst part is, in-app purchases don't translate to family accounts, so we're back to the Bad Old Days of buying apps multiple times for multiple devices. And that's even worse when it's a subscription.
Re:Halide Mark II by the_lucifer on Sunday October 25, 2020 @09:47AM (#24886218)
It’s weird because apple recently added IAP family sharing but I’ve yet to see an app add support for it (I can see why though, it’s easy to get people to double dip when they’re in a family and can’t share it)
Re:Halide Mark II by cageface on Friday October 23, 2020 @02:45AM (#24866642)
I had the same problem. An automatic upgrade rendered my previously functional app unusable. After tapping around for a minute in frustration to try to find some way to dismiss the new subscription screen I deleted the app.

I really do sympathize with the plight of indie developers on the app store but this is too much.

Re:Halide Mark II by inickt on Friday October 23, 2020 @09:23AM (#24869189)
This was fixed in the 2.0.1 update. It came out pretty quick after the initial release, but looks like you hit the unlucky window of having 2.0? If you had Halide previously and download it again it will upgrade you for free.