Then once that's over, you explain to the students this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7OEzyEfzgg it's a duality of interpretation, not reality, we use wave mathematics for simplified calculations. Plus if you interpret it as a wave (as Feynman shows) you run into problems with experimental results not coming out as expected that a particle interpretation doesn't have problems with. (And for some reason I can't think of color in terms of waves, it makes much more sense if I think of it in terms of the energy of a photon with the brightness as a function of how many photons there are, which then ties back to a probability point of view where it's obvious that it's brighter where there's probabilistically more photons.)
http://lesswrong.com/lw/r5/the_quantum_physics_sequence/ remains for me the best introduction to thinking sanely about the subject without becoming confused from the get-go as you start talking about waves vs. particles.
Something I've been mulling over for awhile now is... what does it mean to represent a color with numbers?
That is, every pixel on our monitor is RGB 0 through 255. But what about in physics? Well, "color" is a photon whose wavelength falls between 400nm (short wavelength; intense energy; "ultra"-violet; and violet = blueish; therefore 400nm = "the blue side" of the EM spectrum; this is how I remember that) and 700nm (red).
So on one hand, we have three numbers, R, G, and B; on the other hand, we have a single number, wavelength.
Obviously, the answer is that R, G, and B have some significance to the human eye. But wait a minute; every human eye is different. Some people are color blind, for example. So these RGB values can't really claim to have a physical basis.
Now, what is the meaning of a combination of colors? Let's say, RGB(50,50,0) + RGB(0,50,50). Is the result RGB(50,100,50), like you'd expect?
I think not.
RGB is not a linear space. In the same way you can't add two points on the Richter scale, you can't add two RGB values and get a meaningful result, I think.
So then we have something called "sRGB", which claims to be a linear space. But really, sRGB is merely RGB space "warped" to conform to the gamma curves of standard monitors. It still has no physical meaning, as far as I can see.
I believe perhaps the correct answer is...
When a light source emits light (for example an incandescent light bulb), it's really emitting many different wavelengths along the EM spectrum. The final color is the result of our eyes combining those wavelengths.
So, to add two colors A and B, we must first convert them both from RGB back into the EM spectrum (think of it like a histogram, where the X axis is wavelength from 400nm to 700nm, and the Y axis is the intensity of each wavelength); then add the two spectrums; then finally convert the resulting spectrum back to RGB.
Will this produce the same results as (A + B)? I don't think so, but I haven't tried it.
Food for thought...
This has vast implications for computer graphics. Video games, for example.
"Light wave frequencies do not add up, i.e. you can't add 2 green beams to create an ultraviolet."
The light wave frequencies do add up --- if you add 2 "green" beams, then you get a more intensely bright green beam. The hue changes only slightly.
In the case of combining beams, what changes is the intensity of the beam, the frequency spectrum does not change at all (there is two photon excitation, but that's a completely different phenomenon).
From a physical standpoint, it makes no sense to add two RGB colors.
It makes sense to add two lengths. (1 inch) + (1 inch) = (2 inches).
It does not make sense to add two RGB colors. The result is not a meaningful physical quantity. In the same spirit, (7.8 earthquake) + (8.3 earthquake) != (16.1 earthequake).
This is a big problem for those of us who are trying to reproduce how nature looks on the screen of a computer. (In my case, realtime graphics.)
For the case of the combining beams of light, the only time that the hue wouldn't change is if you have two lightbulbs that emit precisely the same EM waves --- the same frequencies and the same intensities for all emitted waves. This is practically impossible. Therefore, the hue of the combination is never exactly the same. Just because you can't perceive the difference, doesn't mean there isn't a difference.
Sure it does. If you work in linear space, the RGB values corresponds to the number of photons.
> It does not make sense to add two RGB colors. The result is not a meaningful physical quantity.
5 photons + 3 photons = 8 photons
> (7.8 earthquake) + (8.3 earthquake) != (16.1 earthequake)
The Richter scale is not linear, so of course it won't work.
More importantly, several earthquakes won't combine onto one. That is not a problem when combining beams of light, since they are already composed of a number of photons each.
Even multiplying RGB values have a physical basis. If one RGB value is the number of photons in a beam of light, the other RGB value represents the probability that the photons will pass through a filter, such as colored glass.
So, to fool a machine you might need to exactly match all the individual wavelengths relative intensity but with a human you get to ignore most of that and just look at 3 numbers per pixel.
PS: A small number of people can detect 4 colors but the net effect of this is almost meaningless for various reasons.
It seems to me in computer graphics you also have to deal with other color problems such as light dispersion, the blue shift due to light scattering in the atmosphere, maybe even doppler effects :), but it's still valid to combine colors linearly for short distances, for example a green and yellow lightbulb would look yellow from a reasonably far distance.
In the example you give below, RGB 128 can be considered halfway between black and white, just not in terms of frequency, but in terms of freq. distribution (also, RGB is a 3dimensional space). As for the earthquakes, you 're right, the amplitude of the resulting wave would be the product of the original waves. Sorry for the rambling, i think it's a fun subject.
The scale is non-linear.
As far as I can see, the only true linear space is frequency space --- aka "EM spectrum" space.
Your alternate graph, however, shows another common misconception that is matched in your text. Specifically, the amplitude of the wave varies, but the intensity does NOT. The amplitude being graphed can be though of as the strength of the electric field pointing.... how about to the north? Then, when the amplitude is negative, all that's happening is that the field is point to the south, instead of the north. The intensity of the light is the energy contained within the electromagnetic field, which is independent of which direction the field is point. Thus, where you have dark spots in the graph where the amplitude goes negative, the intensity of the light is just as strong as it was at the peaks.
The obvious next question is what happens when the amplitude is zero? Well, the changing electric field produces a magnetic field. This magnetic field reaches its maximum value where the electric field goes to zero and goes to zero itself at the minima and maxima of the electric field's amplitude. Thus, the total energy electromagnetic energy, and, therefore, the intensity of the light, is constant across the whole graph.
That's why I'm cautious about using your proposed diagram. I've known many students with the misconception that light alternates between bright and dark as it travels and that lines up exactly with what you've drawn.
Yes, exactly as you say, the total energy is the same but the orientation and amplitude of the field differs. I think the trouble is showing another dimension without resorting to the y-axis which is too easily confused with a path to travel (especially a sine wave, which is usually shown in the context of "height on a circle" or somesuch).
Red and blue colors may be better -- bright red to bright blue, showing which way the field is pointing at that time. Black and white are too easily confused with dim and bright (and a light wave never goes "off").
The original diagrams were made years ago and I should update the colors. Definitely appreciate the feedback!
Since we're on the topic of light -- despite going to a great school and taking several physics courses, I suffered from a severe misconception until about a month ago. Maybe you have it too.
Think about a light wave. You might imagine a diagram like this:
http://betterexplained.com/wp-content/uploads/graphs/Wave.pn...
Yep, you've seen it a million times. Light is a wave and wiggles up and down... right?
Oh really? Do you think the fastest thing the universe travels in a zigzag pattern? Hey, why don't we beat the speed of light by moving on a straight line! Nobel prize time!
No, the y-axis is amplitude of the field. The graph is not a Family-circus dotted line following the particle's motion! A better diagram may be this:
http://betterexplained.com/wp-content/uploads/graphs/wave_am...
It's the intensity of the wave which is varying. But we memorize the "light is a wiggling wave" diagram and wind up with a severe misconception.
(Shameless plug: I blog at http://betterexplained.com and try to hammer away at the insights that have befuddled me.)