News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by brundolf on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @04:51PM (#24842250)
Setting aside the primary subject, this is an excellent observation:

> What I find however is that there are a base of unspoken intuitions that underlie expert understanding of a field, that are never directly stated in the literature, because they can’t be easily proved with the rigor that the literature demands. And as a result, the insights exist only in conversation and subtext, which make them inaccessible to the casual reader.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by wenc on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:14PM (#24842875)
This is very true.

This is why conferences are important. A lot of knowledge is sociological in nature. Failures and tricks of the trade are discussed at the bar after 5. I've experienced this first hand.

Academic publications and lectures, in their (rightful) pursuit of rigor, aren't usually the right space for conversations around hunches and experiences. Reputations are at stake, and most people are doing impression management. When experienced readers read a journal publication, they read it with the implicit understanding that it is a highly curated view of the messiness behind the scenes.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by brundolf on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:32PM (#24842991)
It seems toxic to me that there's no accepted public venue for that stuff, though. The fact that people are too afraid to relay certain useful information until they're tipsy; the emphasis on "doing impression management".

Maybe it should remain separate from the rigorous stuff, but where's the "Op-Ed section" of academic publishing?

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by wenc on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:52PM (#24843113)
I feel the word "toxic" is maybe a bit too pejorative for what it is? Another framing is that it is "guild knowledge". The incentives in academia are complex and it affects how open some folks are or can afford to be with such knowledge.

That said, there are certain open avenues for making such knowledge public. MathOverflow is one. Some academics document their guild knowledge in "technical papers" which they put up on their website. The ML community (which I'm not part of, but that I'm able to observe as an outsider) seems to be particularly open when it comes to publishing blog posts -- sometimes to gain reputational points?

In some journals, arguments over publications are carried out in the Letters to the Editor section. Sometimes this leads to public feuds however, and some academic communities are small enough that if you make too many enemies your publications may be visited upon with disfavor when it comes time for peer review. It's not worth getting into public tiffs unless there's a principle at stake.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by brundolf on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:12PM (#24843251)
> The incentives in academia are complex and it affects how open some folks are or can afford to be with such knowledge.

> Sometimes this leads to public feuds however, and some academic communities are small enough that if you make too many enemies your publications may be visited upon with disfavor when it comes time for peer review. It's not worth getting into public tiffs unless there's a principle at stake.

This is more the kind of thing I was using the word "toxic" to describe. Of course I know this is a widespread and deep-seeded problem and not one that could be fixed overnight, I was just commenting on it

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by kerng on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @09:20PM (#24843991)
That's why publishing and presenting outside the formal academic realm is important. Especially presentations that have one level of indirection from original creators often provide much better intuition and also the presenter isn't afraid sharing that he/she doesn't know certain things or they present content in a more creative funny way.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by bArray on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:58PM (#24843152)
Personally I've wanted a 1-page IEEE publication for a while that accepts smaller contributions, where people can share these kinds of insights. Just a "we tried this, this is what happened" or "we were not able to repeat this" or "we found this interesting, but we need more data".

You could argue it's kind of like a long abstract, but a long abstract really indicates you intend to probe it further, but in actual fact you might just want to indicate that there might be something there for somebody else.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by Fishysoup on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:25PM (#24843723)
People have been floating the idea of doing this for the life sciences too, where the cost of performing an experiment can be very high (animals, enzymes, local permitting and legal considerations etc. on top of the man hours). It would be very useful to see the results of an experiment you want to do(or something resembling it) but didn't follow up on it for whatever reason and would definitely accelerate research. And would probably help with the weird incentive structure and secrecy issues academia is pointlessly built around.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by jvvw on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:43AM (#24846190)
When I worked in crypto 20 years ago there was a journal like this which took papers that were only a few paragraphs long for quick results. I think it was called Electronics Letters.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by tastroder on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @03:44AM (#24845631)
I'm not sure that would be a net benefit over research blogs or something like a technical report directly published by a lab/working group to be quite honest. In a few domains I've recently looked at these notes to the editor / commentary sections seem to only be pseudo-reviewed and I'd say the likelihood of an IEEE rubberstamped one pager on perpetual motion would be non-zero.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by bArray on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @04:57AM (#24845997)
> I'm not sure that would be a net benefit over research

> blogs or something like a technical report directly

> published by a lab/working group to be quite honest.

I think this is kind of the problem, half of this stuff sits on a webpage somewhere completely unread and not really reference-able.

> I'd say the likelihood of an IEEE rubberstamped one pager

> on perpetual motion would be non-zero.

I would hope that each single page would be reviewed with the same integrity as a six pager. Of course, it's not impossible crap leaks through to any conference/journal.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by munchbunny on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:07PM (#24844397)
It’s the stuff you 60-80% believe but you don’t want to put your name on it because once you do people assume you believe it 99% or more. That’s unfortunately how publishing it works.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by hobofan on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:24PM (#24843326)
There is a venue for that stuff and it's in blog posts. The main problem however is that for a hype topic like this there are so many blog posts that it's hard to find the gems with valueable insights between all of the badly regurgitated common knowledge.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by moultano on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:49PM (#24843485)
I'm curious which category you put this one in. :D
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by hobofan on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @03:34AM (#24845578)
Definitely not the latter ;) I think it's too new of an article to already qualify as a gem, but it's certainly made me think about a few things with a new perspective, so there is that :)
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by renewiltord on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:10AM (#24844665)
All of this stuff already exists. By design it excludes people who would likely disparage the lack of rigor. And sometimes other people get caught in that net.

That's a good way. It's called knowing your audience. No one wants to be savaged on HN or Reddit by a bunch of people.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by sjg007 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:37PM (#24843399)
Require people to publish their code.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by p1esk on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:55PM (#24843128)
Good tricks or intuitions don't stay hidden for long. Everything good is quickly published, can easily be found in high quality implementations, and is discussed on GH issues, Pytorch forums, r/MachineLearning, or Twitter.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by cwyers on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:06PM (#24843212)
That just kicks the can down the road a step, though: that just makes the folklore knowing where to find the good GitHub issues.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by p1esk on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:27PM (#24843341)
The point is, the experts do freely share this knowledge. Making it accessible to "casual reader" would be low on my priority list.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by moron4hire on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:07PM (#24843215)
Other fields have their popular message boards. It's not just programmers.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by philipov on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @01:01AM (#24844880)
What are the popular message boards for practicing physicists and mathematicians?
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by Zee2 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @04:54PM (#24852068)
The Mathematics Stack Exchange has consistently surprised me (in a good way) in their helpfulness and rigor.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by TrackerFF on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @02:49AM (#24845351)
There are blogs

But, then again, lots of academics will outright ignore blogs - if they're ever brought up in "serious" discussion.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by dehrmann on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @01:28AM (#24844999)
> Reputations are at stake, and most people are doing impression management

What's the saying about academia? The politics are so vicious because stakes are so small? It's pretty ironic because the stakes are larger for a lot of decisions made by engineers in industry, but we seem content with swapping best practices.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by machinelearning on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:59PM (#24843909)
While most people think this "knowledge" should be organized and even shared, I strongly disagree. For context, I have worked in large research labs, ML engineering organizations and startups and have encountered many people across the engineer and research spectrum.

These intuitions are often wrong and arise due to the lack of vocabulary in correctly describing the mechanisms that occur.

From a researcher's standpoint, learning these is counterproductive if the goal is to study and understand the underlying mechanisms from first principles.

From a beginner engineer perspective, these intuitions may be effective "functional truths" but there's the danger of perceiving these handwavy intuitions as truths. This leads to inflexibility in light of empirical evidence that contradicts these intuitions and even worse - not debugging enough since the pattern seems to match roughly the intuition. The latter results in flawed institutional knowledge being accrued over time. An engineer might say: "Engineer X tried Y and it didn't work because of ML intuition Z, since this is a related problem, we should not prioritize Y due to the precedent."

I think its much better for a beginner engineer to learn the methods from first principles and develop an appreciation for them. They can then learn the distinction between what's true and the intuitive language people use to describe a phenomenon they don't completely understand but can pattern match to. This will help them avoid making the mistakes that people who rely on this intuitive language too much, mistaking it for ML theory.

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by p1esk on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:16PM (#24852282)
This is a very good point. Especially in ML, there have been many cases where very smart people were wrong with their intuitions (the original explanation of batchnorm comes to mind), or maybe their intuitions were correct, but attempts to explain the intuition (especially when there's a race to publish) led to wrong conclusions. I still think intuitions should be discussed and shared, but with a clearly stated caveat like: "that's just my guess, we don't know what's really happening there". This is how I usually explain to others (and to myself) my experimental results.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by bigyikes on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @10:48PM (#24844325)
> I think its much better for a beginner engineer to learn the methods from first principles and develop an appreciation for them. They can then learn the distinction between what's true and the intuitive language people use to describe a phenomenon they don't completely understand but can pattern match to.

This seems super meta, because I am a beginner engineer and your comment is totally pattern matching to distillation, but for humans instead of models. Maybe beginners should start with those “functional“ (read: distilled) truths and train from there :)

Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by machinelearning on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:20AM (#24844707)
If you want to go more meta, I can point out that your comment is pattern matching to training models and applying them to humans vs. thinking from first principles and realizing that humans and models learn differently. That's exactly the issue with applying functional truths as truths.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by m0zg on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:11PM (#24843238)
This is true in a lot of other fields. This is also the reason why experienced people make a lot more money than inexperienced ones. They know where the rakes are buried under the leaves.
Re:Why deep learning works even though it shouldn’t by mam2 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:51AM (#24846221)
This is NOT TRUE that it's NOT SHARED, especially in learning. Just browse quora on any deep learning realted fields, it's a bunch of guys shareing their (more or less relevant and exact) hunch. Also most ML vulgarisation articles focus on that too.

Not sure it's true for the other fields tho.