News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:16PM (#24831642)
> I like the idea but it does seem like you're setting up a poll tax to participate fully in the internet, simultaneously having it high enough to deter or at least raise the bar on scams and low enough to be affordable to the whole world is a hard ask.

It's not actually that hard, because ordinary users can generate one ID and use it for many years, but spammers have to generate a new ID every five minutes because they immediately get blocked and have all content associated with the blocked IDs get retroactively dumped in the spam folder. So the cost to spammers is literally a million times higher than it is for ordinary users, which is exactly the sort of thing that actually works.

Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by rtkwe on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:47PM (#24831876)
It's still important to think about how much $10, the current Urbit ID price, represents in some parts of the world. The World Bank has a poverty line of ~$3-4 per day and over half of India lives (or did in 2017) on less than that and the official rural poverty line is around $6-7 a month. If we're setting up the next internet we really shouldn't be locking out anyone due to price.
Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by AnthonyMouse on Monday October 19, 2020 @09:30PM (#24833149)
Even for someone living on $3/day, paying $10 once every ten years represents 0.09% of their income. You could also plausibly impose alternative costs, like making someone solve captchas for an hour. Then people in rich countries pay $10, people in poor countries spend an hour (which to them is significantly less than $10 of their time).
Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by ddalex on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @04:37AM (#24835105)
that's like 500-1000 USD for the average middle class american - a steep price to pay for a membership with no obvious benefits

I wonder why can't score IDs by page-rank them - one's identity gets credibility based on the social score - hacker news manages to be quite effective at preventing spam using this technique

Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by AnthonyMouse on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @10:17AM (#24837542)
> that's like 500-1000 USD for the average middle class american

Which would be $50-$100/year, i.e. still not very much.

Recall that it costs significantly more than that to have internet access.

> a steep price to pay for a membership with no obvious benefits

The obvious benefit being that you get to be in the same network as the people in rich countries, and that network is not overrun by spam or controlled by a multinational conglomerate that uses its ownership of the means of communication to cost you significantly more than $10.

> I wonder why can't score IDs by page-rank them - one's identity gets credibility based on the social score - hacker news manages to be quite effective at preventing spam using this technique

What do you do with new IDs that have no reputation? If they can't post they can't earn a reputation, if they can post they can spam.

Re:The Centralized Internet Is Inevitable by olah_1 on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:44PM (#24831858)
> So the cost to spammers is literally a million times higher than it is for ordinary users, which is exactly the sort of thing that actually works.

The law-abiding user is the one that incurs the real cost. Spammers pump and dump millions of IDs. This drives up the cost of getting an ID. The normal user that just needs a new ID for some reason is the one that suffers the most here.

I don't care if it's expensive for a scammer. If it's cost-prohibitive for grandma to get a new ID, then it defeats the purpose.