News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by dwaite on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:02PM (#24830324)
Apple did not terminate Epic's SiwA account, and several journalists have sources within Apple that say that Apple never sent the message Epic claimed to receive that said access was going away.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by virtue3 on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:06PM (#24830366)
https://developer.apple.com/forums/thread/123774

Not the only ones that randomly gets their accounts terminated.

Based on how apple has -insane- fragmentation and security for different aspects of the company, I would doubt any employee that isn't directly tied into the store accounts would know the whole details. (Source: GF worked for the department that did art/design for the apple stores, no one had access to their room, and they had more secure rooms that only a few employees had access to).

FWIW google has the same issues.

Don't trust a company with an account that you can't get a human on the phone for to review shit.

Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by toomuchtodo on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:23PM (#24830554)
I use Sign In with Apple everywhere I can (so many of my passwords are in haveibeenpwned datasets), and if Apple blacklisted a provider I use, I’d expect the service to email me to migrate to their own email/password identity provider (if I didn’t hide my email from them with SIWA), with a link to the migration process in the email.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by dkonofalski on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:15PM (#24831625)
Same except that, if Apple blacklisted a provider, I'd want to know why they got blacklisted. At this point, I trust Apple as a neutral third party more than I trust most other companies since Apple isn't incentivized to sell my info.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by toomuchtodo on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:24PM (#24831693)
Agreed, with the caveat that we need some regulation through legislation to codify safeguards around identity providers, their responsibilities, etc.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by mvanbaak on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:23PM (#24830556)
> Not the only ones that randomly

Not really random now right...

Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by dwaite on Monday October 19, 2020 @06:23PM (#24831684)
That does not necessarily have anything to do with SiwA, however.
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by saagarjha on Monday October 19, 2020 @04:12PM (#24830439)
Tim Sweeney produced a letter saying that Apple would terminate their access: https://twitter.com/TimSweeneyEpic/status/131134525357683097...
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by jsjohnst on Monday October 19, 2020 @08:19PM (#24832589)
That’s a pretty misleading interpretation of what Apple said or even what Tim Sweeney said in the tweet...
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by saagarjha on Monday October 19, 2020 @08:32PM (#24832702)
How so?
Re:Face ID and Touch ID for the Web by jsjohnst on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:48PM (#24833764)
> Apple is entirely in its rights to terminate Epic Games’ developer account and all related functionality, but SIWA will continue to function for two weeks.

Ok, let’s translate it:

1) Apple believes it’s entirely in its rights to terminate Epic’s dev account and is doing so

2) Apple also believes it’s in their right to kill all related account functionally, but they aren’t, specifically with SIWA, for at least two weeks.

3) they don’t specify what will happen after two weeks, as that likely depends on several factors. We later learn that they extended it indefinitely.

So there’s multiple possible scenarios:

A) Apple really is just threatening as you indicated, but not being blatantly direct about it. Possible, but not the only possibility, and not usually their style from what I’ve seen for something like this, but who knows. I feel if Apple really wanted to threaten, they’d make the threat explicit and say “after two weeks of non-compliance, we will terminate everything”.

B) Apple is stalling making a decision over if SIWA will continue to be available to Epic’s users to ensure the SIWA team can support it when the dev account is deactivated. From other rumors where we hear folks saying SIWA team did have to make changes, I’m thinking this was the likely scenario. Don’t make a commitment to keep something going if you can’t deliver on it for sure yet, so “give them a two week extension” so you learn if you can actually keep SIWA up. If they can’t and Epic is still fighting with Fire, maybe you do terminate SIWA, but maybe not. Either way, Apple wins.

C) Apple is stalling a decision to scare Epic into compliance after Epic’s users backlash over word it might end. Possible, but I think Epic had well shown they were ready to play the Russian roulette game with Apple down to the last chamber, so I’m thinking less likely than A/B.

So if I was a betting man, I’d say it’s a mixed bag at best, but would likely go:

B > A > C

Apple doesn’t play checkers, they play chess. When they send a letter like that, they ensure there’s multiple positive outcomes for them for any potential scenario, from technical complications, to user perception, to legal proceedings, etc.