Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by albroland on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:43AM
(#24827369)
I think your observation applies to most online communities. IME the quality of a forum/community seems to be directly tied to the population size following a somewhat skewed normal distribution. A monday morning theory based on my observations:
Once you reach a critical mass of users that will sustain discussion, you will see a gradual rise in quality as a small board of passionate users will organically attract likeminded individuals, who typically contribute and elevate the discussion. Everyone is highly motivated to explore, discuss, and challenge ideas with each other and decorum is usually quite polite, as to them there was no other place you could engage so freely with these ideas with likeminded individuals.
At a certain point though, you seem to cross a rubicon where the new users are less informed, less motivated/passionate, and don't contribute anything new or novel to the discussion. This is quickly followed by an exodus of the most informed/important voices who aren't interested in dealing with uninformed conjecture, or novice matters that aren't particularly interesting to someone who has more subject matter expertise.
This progresses to the end state of the board, where there are very few if any true believers to whatever the original intent of the board was, and the posting reflects that as it moves further and further from the intended subject and more into meta and social. I'd describe this state as similar to the discourse you'd see on twitter today: rude, tribal, uninformed, speculative, etc.
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by zwieback on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:47AM
(#24827429)
I don't think that's generally true. I was using Usenet during that time, mostly CS groups for C++ and Lisp, and there were many established users that were toxic jerks. They were constantly being called out and nothing changed.
I do agree that the general quality of Usenet nosedived around then but it had more to do with the transition to other forums than with the influx of AOL users.
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by Lutzb on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:12PM
(#24829778)
There is a pattern here, I've seen this over and over for the last 25 years. Every community has something like a resident troll. This person opposes the social concerns us and mostly never contributes positively. His arguments have been debunked analysed over and over but he keeps on posting.
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by 8fGTBjZxBcHq on Monday October 19, 2020 @12:28PM
(#24827912)
> The politeness of early USENET was a mark of privilege -- perhaps even white supremacy. Now that the world's ghettos have onramps to the information superhighway, online discourse has been increasingly truly democratized.
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by tech_elitist on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:41AM
(#24827349)
Why exactly should it end? They already have social network reservations where they're always welcome to spend time in. What's up with this cancerous desire to fill every niche and perverse every subculture? Stay in your lane, normies.
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by upofadown on Monday October 19, 2020 @01:27PM
(#24828623)
It wasn't some sort of culture clash. The new people simply did not understand the implications of the medium. As a result they would ask the same questions over and over again without looking at the FAQs. They were suckers for trolls and would waste everyone's time by engaging in manufactured arguments. In time they would learn how things worked but there was a constant stream of new people.
We seem to be in such a period globally right now...
Re:It’s Time for the Eternal September to End
by bitwize on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:39AM
(#24827342)
"Asshole" is Hackernews code for "person discredited for nonalignment with political orthodoxy". There are a lot of assholes in the casual sense in SV, but a statement of the form "X is an asshole" on HN means something like "you are morally obligated to disregard or denounce anything X says, does, or establishes, because X holds political opinions I and other fellow decent people find distasteful".
The implications about the use of JavaScript, created by known asshole Brendan Eich, are left as an exercise.
Thankfully nobody remembers that, so vice can use the term to darken our world a little more.
Once you reach a critical mass of users that will sustain discussion, you will see a gradual rise in quality as a small board of passionate users will organically attract likeminded individuals, who typically contribute and elevate the discussion. Everyone is highly motivated to explore, discuss, and challenge ideas with each other and decorum is usually quite polite, as to them there was no other place you could engage so freely with these ideas with likeminded individuals.
At a certain point though, you seem to cross a rubicon where the new users are less informed, less motivated/passionate, and don't contribute anything new or novel to the discussion. This is quickly followed by an exodus of the most informed/important voices who aren't interested in dealing with uninformed conjecture, or novice matters that aren't particularly interesting to someone who has more subject matter expertise.
This progresses to the end state of the board, where there are very few if any true believers to whatever the original intent of the board was, and the posting reflects that as it moves further and further from the intended subject and more into meta and social. I'd describe this state as similar to the discourse you'd see on twitter today: rude, tribal, uninformed, speculative, etc.
I do agree that the general quality of Usenet nosedived around then but it had more to do with the transition to other forums than with the influx of AOL users.
Has this ever been researched? Named?
this but unironically
We seem to be in such a period globally right now...
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gavin_McInnes
Seems to me that after 12 years, Vice maybe shouldn't be judged for it's founders vices [pun intended].
The implications about the use of JavaScript, created by known asshole Brendan Eich, are left as an exercise.