News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PlentyFS: PoC read-only filesystem with random contents g... by rwmj on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:27AM (#24824023)
Some comments: The seed should be an optional parameter (I see there's a comment in the code mentioning this). This is very important for CI testing where a bug only happens for specific file content and you need to reproduce the bug locally.

Why use a cryptographic hash? For nbdkit-random-plugin we use a fast PRNG (xoshiro256-starstar 1.0 as it happens, but the specific one is not important). I doubt a cryptographically secure hash is worth the extra computational cost to users.

Re:PlentyFS: PoC read-only filesystem with random contents g... by minoru on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:46PM (#24830145)
Hi, the author here. Thanks for taking a look at the code!

I picked SHA-1 because it was the simplest way to generate pseudorandom data: I knew there's a Rust crate for it which I used before. Works fine for a proof-of-concept :) I'm now reading up on other hashes and ciphers. My tentative plan was to replace SHA-1 with AES-NI in counter mode, but if I can find something that works on all CPUs while giving me a comparable performance, I'll go for that. (Should probably look at PRNGs as well; if I concatenate the file seed with the counter and use that as a seed for a PRNG, then ask it for a value -- it should be good enough too.)

I doubt Lars has requirements for the quality of randomness, but we'll see.

Re:PlentyFS: PoC read-only filesystem with random contents g... by dredmorbius on Monday October 19, 2020 @02:13PM (#24829119)
I'm really just a bystanderhere. File an issue w/ the project.