News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by projektfu on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:07PM (#24821856)
What happens to project planning when tasks and dependents form cycles? Doesn't that happen pretty often?
Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by Jtsummers on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:26PM (#24821965)
If you have a cyclic dependency in your project then you more likely have a DAG that’s not sufficiently broken down. That is if A and B seem to depend on each other you have some sub tasks in each that need to be pulled out. If this still fails to break the apparent cycle, you’ve got a problem.

Another thing to keep in mind is that there's a distinction between a system having cyclic dependencies (I need A & B working because they communicate with each other), and the task ordering. During development you can end up with a partially correct system. If A sends to B, and B sends to A but I only have one person working on both parts, then it's possible I'll end up in a state where A sends to B but not the reverse. That's fine during development. Yes, the system is "wrong" per the design or spec. But it's a partial system (like a half-built bridge). Your tasks will appear to have a cycle, but in reality you will break it by selecting one portion to complete first so in the end it remains (based on the chosen path) a DAG.

Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by jlokier on Monday October 19, 2020 @07:12AM (#24825216)
> That is if A and B seem to depend on each other you have some sub tasks in each that need to be pulled out.

That produces subtasks without cycles, giving you a way forward.

Assuming you still want to maintain shared information about the tasks which contain subtasks, those tasks still have a dependency cycle between them though, which is correct because tasks are often like that - they need to move forward together.

Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by projektfu on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:20PM (#24833647)
I assume a decent plan willbe hard to make without understanding that a sizeable portion will have to be reworked. (In software at least). For example, the Boehm model. How do you make a Gantt chart without abstracting away the whole project?
Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by TeMPOraL on Sunday October 18, 2020 @07:36PM (#24822023)
There shouldn't be any cycles in properly broken out plan, because the flow of time creates a causal directness; a true cycle would prevent any of the tasks involved from starting, which obviously doesn't happen in real life. Sometimes you may need to break things down a bit more.

And that's why I'm asking for a tool that lets me model projects as Directed Acyclic Graphs of tasks. Because all I seem to be getting in popular tools is a flat list with some categorizing, or a single level of subtasks at best. I want to be able to express directly that this subtask has sub-subtasks, and that this sub-subtask depends on completion of a subtask from some other task (without making it a dependency between root tasks).

Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by dragonwriter on Sunday October 18, 2020 @11:56PM (#24823205)
> There shouldn't be any cycles in properly broken out plan, because the flow of time creates a causal directness

Real dependencies can be not-before rather than strictly-after, which admits cycles without any problems with the flow of time.

Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by TeMPOraL on Monday October 19, 2020 @07:27AM (#24825313)
Then I'm fine with a cyclic graph.
Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by projektfu on Monday October 19, 2020 @11:17PM (#24833632)
Cool discussion. Thanks all.
Re:Openproject: Open-source project management software by spirobel on Sunday October 18, 2020 @11:38PM (#24823129)
maybe you can split the task into its subtasks and forget about the task itself. Then you forget about the concept of subtasks and you are left with a bunch of tasks. now you can define dependencies between these tasks like you would normaly do.