News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 25, 2011 @08:12AM (#2481037)
>"So, on the one hand we have my daughter’s irreverence to a great institution (“bad girl!”)."

I don't understand how it's irreverent to make up your own game inspired by another?

Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by jodrellblank on Monday April 25, 2011 @08:38AM (#2481073)
"Irreverent: showing lack of due respect or veneration" - she played it once and then invented a different game she'd rather play.

Since he holds Chess in high regard, she "should have" fawned over chess, wanting to play it again and learn more about it. To not do so is to not show enough respect to his ideal of Chess.

If instead, she had played chess a lot with him, talked about how much she liked it, and then presented him with a game she made while downplaying it as a trifling diversion from Real Chess which she really likes, then he would have felt suitable respect was being paid.

aka politics, see also: we humans delight in finding or inventing things to be offended at.

See also: how would you automatically react if someone posted "my forum is much better than YCombinator" and had an account registered a day ago, versus if patio11 posted "I'm trying out a few different ideas for auto-moderating comments on my forum, would any of you come over and give it a try please?". Same basic point, very different presentations.

Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by Contractor69 on Monday April 25, 2011 @08:37AM (#2481072)
I think the point he's trying to make is that we're all so conditioned to accept institutions without question ("we do it that way because we've ALWAYS done it that way"). This is beaten into us (and creativity beaten OUT OF us) as children, especially through the public schools. Clearly it's not irreverent to innovate, but I can imagine the shock/horror of the mainstream at the "reinvention" of chess.
Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by balakk on Monday April 25, 2011 @08:56AM (#2481112)
While the point is valid, certain institutions do require some reverence and respect. Chess is certainly such a game. I'm not saying one has to be a Fischer to invent a new chess format; but unless the person has seriously understood/appreciated the complexities of chess, I'll have trouble taking them seriously.

Irreverence is good if it comes from deep understanding and knowledge or genius - otherwise it just comes off as arrogance.

Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by TillE on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:02AM (#2481131)
That's only true if you're trying to invent something better, Chess 2.0. If you're just trying to create something different and fun with similar rules, it's not really necessary to deeply understand the strategic balance of chess.
Re:A GeekDad’s 8-Year Old Daughter Reinvents Chess by pbhjpbhj on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:55AM (#2481225)
Exactly. She appeared to make something more complex (though I didn't look at the rules). But perhaps it's something that allows here to make stories about it better, or something that uses her favourite toys, or something that is more fun for some other reason.

Now, if she'd said - that game is no good, it's not complex enough, it's not challenging enough or somesuch (and wasn't a grandmaster) then I think she would perhaps have been irreverent, though more likely ignorant.