News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The PhD problem by melling on Sunday April 24, 2011 @10:41PM (#2480227)
I think for the hard sciences and engineering we should be creating more research jobs in the private industry for PhD's. We have no shortage of problems that need to be solved and discoveries to be made.

Private industry needs to be incentivised to do more long-term R&D.

Re:The PhD problem by URSpider94 on Monday April 25, 2011 @01:58AM (#2480576)
What you are suggesting was the norm 20-30 years ago. Major corporate research centers like Bell Labs and IBM Watson were the crown jewels of their respective corporate owners. Today, these programs are mere shells of their former selves.

Corporate America just doesn't have the stomach to fund fundamental research with a payback varying from years in the future (optimistically) to never (pessimistically). In fact, we have exactly the opposite trend -- university researchers have taken on all kinds of applied research projects that would have been considered far too commercial in the past. In turn, the universities are looking to license out their IP portfolios and take stakes in companies founded by their students and faculty to raise more cash.

Re:The PhD problem by pbsurf on Monday April 25, 2011 @04:10AM (#2480772)
The list of inventions that came out of Bell Labs is breathtaking: solar cells, information theory, the first transistor, the first MOSFET, the laser, CCDs, UNIX, and many more. Silicon Valley was essentially founded by William Shockley, one of the inventors of the transistor at Bell Labs.

At Bell Labs the absolute best scientists could come together and just work, without having to deal with writing grant applications, teaching courses, or mentoring grad students (the three activities which now consume the vast majority of an academic researcher's time).

I am convinced that if Bell Labs was as strong today as it was 50 years ago, we'd have kilo-core microprocessors (and know how to program them), all our genomes would be sequenced already, and we'd all be driving electric cars recharged by ultra-efficient solar power stations. Or rather they'd be driving themselves. Maybe Google can help get us back on track.

Re:The PhD problem by farout on Monday April 25, 2011 @10:38AM (#2481357)
I used to worship institutions such as Bell Labs. But I guess when you learn how the sausage is made, it takes the luster off of things.

The book, My Life as a Quant: Reflections on Physics and Finance, talks about why he left Bell Labs to be a quant on wall street.

I remember after graduating college. I was unsure what to do next. My profs wanted me to do PhD. My fiancee, a PhD candidate, was against it. The company I worked at was willing to pay for my masters in electrical engineering but again my fiancee made the argument since I was repulsed by large organizations that I would resent it. I would most likely end up working for those companies. He was right. This is what happened to my friends.

5 years ago, I was reconsidering a PhD, I thought comp sci or stats. So I dipped my toe and got a masters in stats - it was fun. Do a PhD? No. What for. Economically it would not make sense for me.

I would only do it if I found a fun topic such as modeling detection of prostate cancer (my masters project) but so far the idea of working for the immoral pharma industry including the unis and rest of them makes me ill.

I wish I learnt Marie Curie's secret on how to focus on the work and forget the rest. But I haven't.

My husband works as a computer science researcher (AI) - I KNOW I never want to do this. Pittance for ground breaking work done at excruciating slow pace with so many failures. The shit he puts up so he can work on the stuff that interests him - boggles the mind. I almost want to scream - get a bloody commercial job (effectively 2x salary) and use your own money to run your own tests. But he has seen what the prospects and the environment through the eyes of friends smarter than him and knows the true cost of politics. Smart man.

I would never advise anyone to do a PhD unless you are in love with the topic.

Re:The PhD problem by pbsurf on Monday April 25, 2011 @12:35PM (#2481852)
I absolutely agree - any one of the Bell Labs scientists could easily have become a multi-millionaire by choosing a different path. Financially, they saw only an infinitesimal fraction of the value they created.

In one corner, we have engineers and scientists whose full time job is to solve problems and create new ideas; in the other corner, we have those whose full time job is to acquire money in any way possible - executives, Wall Street types, etc. It is easy to guess who will emerge financially victorious. Sadly, I don't think it can be any other way.

Re:The PhD problem by michaelochurch on Monday April 25, 2011 @08:56AM (#2481115)
Corporate America just doesn't have the stomach to fund fundamental research with a payback varying from years in the future (optimistically) to never (pessimistically).

Most corporations are completely beholden to Wall Street these days, and stock traders can't evaluate long-term research initiatives.

Re:The PhD problem by jcampbell1 on Monday April 25, 2011 @09:37AM (#2481189)
The universities also have a major cost advantage. They dangle the possibility of a tenured job in exchange for getting PhDs to work for $45k as post doc researchers. Even if primary research does have a payoff in the future, it makes more sense for universities to do it at 1/3 the cost and guaranteed government backing.

Maybe the government and universities have squeezed the corporate sector out of research?

Re:The PhD problem by brianobush on Sunday April 24, 2011 @11:27PM (#2480335)
Agreed. In my company, a fortune 500 company, we are concerned more with revenue than building technology to solve big problems. This leads to quick hacks that solve short term issues only to leave technical debt and little invested in truly solving a problem.
Re:The PhD problem by zheng on Sunday April 24, 2011 @11:56PM (#2480379)
I'd be willing to guess that you are more concerned with revenue because you have shareholders to answer to. R&D is something that doesn't show up on the bottom line with regularity. Sure, you might develop something huge and make tons, but probably not.

What would be interesting is to see some heavy quantitative studies done on the ROI of research in a corporate setting. If we could prove that R&D provides a decent ROI, I'd be willing to bet that the business types would be more willing to fund it.

Re:The PhD problem by achompas on Monday April 25, 2011 @12:33AM (#2480431)
Teasing out returns on R&D would be difficult. Companies that maintain R&D teams (Microsoft, Yahoo, AT&T, Google, Intel, etc.) tend to be industry leaders, which complicates the relationship between research and income. Further, research projects have varying timelines and levels of dedication -- you can work on a project full-time for weeks, only to table it for immediate needs -- so the NPV calculation would be difficult.

I bet R&D departments benefit from economies of scale -- 5 PhDs can likely produce much more than one PhD at 5 companies, and a solid team attracts top talent -- which means the aforementioned big shots are the likeliest to produce meaningful research. Still, I would give a lot to work at a something like a "research startup."

Re:The PhD problem by alextp on Monday April 25, 2011 @06:16AM (#2480899)
Microsoft Research seem very evaluatable (they routinely sell their work to product tems, and things like the algorithms driving the ad network from bing came out of MSR) in terms of the bottom line, and Google's research is so integrated with the usual engineering it's hard to know which is which (and hence I doubt it fares any worse than the rest of google in terms of contributing directly to the bottom line).
Re:The PhD problem by zheng on Monday April 25, 2011 @12:51AM (#2480460)
Oh I agree, I don't know how you would go about it, and I'm sure it's not easy or it would have been done. Talking with someone who has actual experience in both research and ROI studies leads me to believe however that these companies have a pretty good idea of their research ROI, but that it is merely a hard sell to shareholders due to the time delay.