News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Netflix is creating a problem by cancelling TV shows too ... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:44AM (#24776426)
> If you have a new series, all potential viewers are potential viewers. If you have a season 3, the only potential viewers are season 2 watchers.

This is only true for modern TV formats that favor season+ long story arcs so much that any individual episode often contains neither the start nor end of any particular plot and is entirely meaningless outside of its larger contextual role in the series.

In old-fashioned TV, each episode pretty much had to stand on its own as a story and stood a much better chance of hooking new viewers. The downside of that approach of course is that status-quo is God and almost nothing truly interesting ever happens because of it.

The best shows, in my opinion, manage to mix these in a way such that any individual episode can be interesting even to someone who has never seen the show before, while still creating a larger more interesting narrative over time. My personal gold standard for this is Stargate SG-1, which lasted 10 seasons and started with human beings walking through a wormhole to encounter the monster-of-the-week and ended with them zooming across the galaxy in starships and fighting ascended would-be-deities.

Re:Netflix is creating a problem by cancelling TV shows too ... by lgunsch on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:27PM (#24779882)
I find I can't watch shows with season+ long arcs at all. It always ends up one way: rage-quiting at 3am on a work night never to watch another episode. All due to the fact that usually the episode boundaries are placed in the most suspenseful places.

However, shows like ST:NG or Stargate SG-1 I enjoyed completely. I'd watch one or two episodes at a time and leave feeling good.

Re:Netflix is creating a problem by cancelling TV shows too ... by lliamander on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @05:11PM (#24781659)
I generally prefer long, integrated stories (I have reasonably good discipline about only watching one episode a night). Next Gen and SG-1 both occupy a nice middle ground, because even if the episodes are self-contained, they still engage in character development and reference previous events. Those shows are also nice in that manage to tell compelling stories without being overly melodramatic - so many shows now (especially sci-fi) are just re-skinned soap operas.

Watching shows like ST:TOS are painful for me now. That there is absolutely no connection from one episode to the next means that I have pretty much no investment in what happens. I only watched TOS just to complete the Star Trek lore, but in general I avoid such stories.