Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb...
by jpadvo on Saturday April 23, 2011 @04:08PM
(#2477480)
That is exactly what he claimed -- that the situation with high heels is in a stable equilibrium. Barring some kind of outside influence, stable equilibria remain in their state indefinitely.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb...
by Gianteye on Saturday April 23, 2011 @05:44PM
(#2477651)
But the author doesn't state why that equilibrium cannot change. He states that is hasn't, which is different.
It's the difference between a double blind experiment and an epidemiological survey. One attempts to isolate a mechanism that is predictive, another attempts to explain historical trends.
Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb...
by yummyfajitas on Saturday April 23, 2011 @06:26PM
(#2477750)
I don't claim that equilibrium can't change.
A speculative bubble is not an equilibrium. It will inflate and pop all on it's own accord. The housing bubble inflated and popped without any underlying changes in fundamental factors (e.g. population).
In contrast, a Nash Equilibrium based on signalling will inflate and remain until some fundamental factors change. Women will continue to wear high heels and people will continue getting unnecessary education until these activities stop being a means of obtaining status.