News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by pavel_lishin on Saturday April 23, 2011 @02:46PM (#2477295)
An individual has all the reasons to defect if they believe that their time and money would be better spent, e.g., starting a company and profiting off of it rather than sinking their time and money into a degree.
Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by incomethax on Saturday April 23, 2011 @04:56PM (#2477581)
Not only that, but an individual company (as a single rational actor) has every incentive to hire workers with less "perceived" credentials and more actual work credentials.

Part of the reason I believe the education bubble is a bubble and will pop, is that the entire point of an accredited degree is to have a recognizable proxy for someone's intellectual capability. The ease at checking a person's ability prior to the internet and social media was in checking with their alma mater if they had the degree that they had and therefore if they were as capable as they claimed. Now it's even easier to check if someone has the intellectual capability by looking at their blog/github repo/facebook/twitter.

With that in mind, I think its only a matter of time before that starts to translate into educational institutions competing with industry for students.

Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by hga on Saturday April 23, 2011 @05:13PM (#2477604)
"[...] the entire point of an accredited degree is to have a recognizable proxy for someone's intellectual capability."

Indeed, but the college degree is used for this because most of the former methods have been outlawed (or in the case of the high school diploma watered down to uselessness).

I don't find it impossible to imagine the government outlawing the new sort of Internet based investigations or enough people getting wise to the game to, well, game it.

Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by drcode on Saturday April 23, 2011 @03:03PM (#2477317)
It's risky though: If your startup goes belly up, many people will think of you as just a loser who dropped out of school because he/she couldn't handle it, even if that's unfair. Let's hope this dynamic changes in the future.
Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by sliverstorm on Saturday April 23, 2011 @03:31PM (#2477363)
What you are asking for is failures to no longer be regarded as failures. Maybe it's unfair, maybe it was just bad luck that conspired against you, but I can't really see a world in which failure is just as acceptable as success.

If the label of failure rubs you the wrong way, take it as an incentive- buck up, get back in the fray, and try again until you're a success.

Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by joe_the_user on Saturday April 23, 2011 @03:48PM (#2477397)
Among other serious flaws in the article, the author fails to make the distinction between simple irrational urges and the subtle and seductive irrationality specific to a bubble.

A number of people made more money by being in the housing market than was made by those who sat the whole thing out. The bubble was a loss in total but applying an overall process to an individual decision is not the easy-call that the author glibly claims it to be. A person can easily determine that wearing high-heals will be harder on their body than wearing flats. The calculations concerning a house in 2004 were much more complex and the calculations concerning whether to get a college education in 2011 are also more complex.

Re:The High-Heel Bubble never popped, and the Education Bubb... by yummyfajitas on Saturday April 23, 2011 @04:04PM (#2477460)
A person can easily determine that wearing high-heals will be harder on their body than wearing flats.

Of course you can - but how do you ensure that the other women in your office don't look down on you because you wear flats?

I'm not arguing that high heels are irrational at all. Far from it - I'm claiming the loss in status is worse than foot pain and thus it is rational for any individual to wear heels.