News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:42PM (#24771147)
This is the most dangerously stupid thing I've ever heard. Tetlock is a known academic charlatan pushing his absolutely useless "superforecasting" nonsense which @nntaleb keeps debunking on Twitter. If Tetlock and friends are so good about forecasting the future, why didn't they predict and warn us about COVID-19 BEFORE @nntaleb and friends (including myself) did?

P.S. I have been downvoted for saying this.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by civilized on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:56PM (#24772395)
You could be right, but I've people-watched on Twitter long enough to know that "person who insults those he disagrees with while name-dropping @nntaleb" is an entire PERSONALITY, one that I take approximately 0% seriously.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:09AM (#24773013)
Not a criticism if the worst you can say about someone is that he is "mean," not that he is wrong.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by civilized on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:29PM (#24779896)
Taleb has deep insights about some things, is laughably ignorant on other things, and doesn't seem to know which is which. His followers definitely don't.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by aaron695 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:04AM (#24788757)
> Taleb has deep insights about some things

I'll bite, what?

I know he's rich and successful, so he has deeper insights than most.

But it doesn't mean he teaches them, as far I can see he just uses them. For instance he's very good at doublespeak.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by tim333 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:17AM (#24774365)
Thanks for the context. I was trying to figure what was noteworthy about an article saying we should think ahead which I kind of assumed we did anyway. Though I think "most dangerously stupid thing I've ever heard" is maybe an exaggeration. The US govt effectively banning coronavirus testing back in Feb kind of sticks out in my mind as outstanding on that front (https://www.nytimes.com/2020/03/10/us/coronavirus-testing-de...)
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:32AM (#24775401)
Thanks, yes, I try to write in a way where even I don't fall asleep, unlike our "nirvana fallacy" friend below...
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by cl42 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:45PM (#24771173)
I think you’re partially right. However, it also depends on what you’re comparing to and what the baseline is. There are lots of projects that try to predict the future and using a framework to do so in a systematic way that can improve over time with feedback is really valuable. That part resonates with me.

I do agree that keeping this high level and abstract (scenario planning + probabilistic estimates) isn’t necessarily doing them any favours. Their book on the topic is better, and I do appreciate their argument that it’s not about being a perfect predictor of the future, but simply better than what we have today.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:48PM (#24771191)
You cannot fundamentally predict the future, fuhgedaboutit, partly for the same reasons we cannot use Turing machines to solve the halting problem for Turing machines.

What you can do, however, is control your exposure to outcomes of unpredictable events. You don't know when a pandemic will hit, but you know it is is matter of time, just like getting hacked. So prepare and design accordingly. Simple. No need for this superforecasting nonsense which doesn't even work.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by cl42 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:51PM (#24771225)
They would actually argue the same thing. Certain events are impossible to predict.

Other events are not.

That’s part of the beauty of the problem. You need to be able to pick the right events to predict and ensure the event is well-defined enough to actually test. Your own examples of why this wouldn’t work are exactly what they discuss as the problem... Eventually a lot of forecasts are correct; what governments, companies, and leaders need are forecasts that are time bound, as that’s how they plan.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @06:57PM (#24771267)
Show me the money: did they warn about COVID-19 way BEFORE it be came a problem, or did they not? If not, why should we take them seriously? It is easy to prognosticate AFTER the fact.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by jacques_chester on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:21PM (#24772225)
This argument relies on the nirvana fallacy. "You are not perfectly clairvoyant, therefore prediction is worthless".

I recall, but cannot locate, that questions related to the outbreak of trans-species respiratory illnesses from China have been canvassed in the past. It does appear that the US intelligence community expected a pandemic to emerge: https://www.mercurynews.com/2020/03/16/analysis-yes-people-d...

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by _jahh on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @07:52PM (#24771700)
not seeing one crisis doesn't mean they aren't better than chance. Also do you know that they didn't make some accurate prediction of XX% of a pandemic that was born out in this situation? No one is claiming to have a literal crystal ball.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by jacques_chester on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:49PM (#24772044)
Taleb has anecdotes and insults.

Tetlock has data piled on data.

[dead]
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by jacques_chester on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:41PM (#24778631)
"There will be a pandemic" is a prediction with 100% accuracy. Any rare event, as Taleb likes to hang his entire career on, will eventually happen.

But such a prediction is basically worthless without a horizon. Information about when a pandemic happens affects what actions have to be made to deal with it. Pandemics that definitely happen tomorrow require far more expensive and disruptive actions than ones happening sometime in the next decade with gradually increasing probability.

Tetlock's work is about people who actually have to define a date and for whom the deciding measurements are objective. You can't just say "a pandemic!", you have to say "a pandemic is declared by WHO on or before January 1st, 2019".

In fact, Tetlock's data undermines Taleb's entire thesis that dramatic events are systematically under-predicted. He showed that dramatic scenarios are over-predicted by experts. They have higher emotional salience, and history that is taught focuses on dramatic, outlier events because of their disproportionate impact. Due to availability bias and hindsight bias, experts typically predict that dramatic events will happen more frequently than they actually do. Such predictions are regularly roflstomped by hilariously simple forecasting methods like "yesterday's weather" or fitting a line on a handful of data points.

As I said earlier: Taleb has anecdotes and insults. Tetlock has data.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by enkid on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:14PM (#24772189)
When did anyone predict COVID? You can just throw around assertions that someone predicted something like COVID without providing evidence and expect people to make judgements on it.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by mensetmanusman on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @10:01PM (#24772418)
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by dang on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:57PM (#24780219)
If you're being downvoted it's probably for fulminating, which the site guidelines ask you not to do: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

You may not owe authors whom you feel are charlatans better, but you owe this community better if you're posting to it.

[dead]
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by dang on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @05:46PM (#24782014)
You do if you want to keep posting here.

Edit: you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines a lot lately. Comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24772993 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24772982 are not ok. Would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules? I don't want to ban you, but we can't have people throwing their weight around and attacking others like this.

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by trishankkarthik on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:18PM (#24782881)
How was I "attacking" others, when they were allowed to put words in my mouth? Go ahead and ban me: @paulgraham and @sama were right about the intolerance of free speech in Silicon Valley.
Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by tomhoward on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:18PM (#24783714)
Hey there, I’m a longtime Taleb follower (Antifragile was life-changing for me), and I watched him and you and others in your crew commentate on the pandemic and found it highly beneficial for understanding the scenario. I’d consider it a great shame if there were no place for you here.

But this attack on dang misses the mark badly.

pg and sama have always been fully supportive of the way he runs HN (pg hand-picked him to take it over, sama was YC CEO for most of the time since, and they've both repeatedly endorsed him and his HN work publicly [1], including recently in pg's case [2]).

dang’s approach to moderation makes it more conducive to free speech, as, unlike on Twitter, it allows difficult/complex topics to be discussed without being derailed by personal insults.

We don’t need to attack people here; we have the downvote arrow and flag link for when people are being assholes, otherwise we can just focus on presenting persuasive arguments.

[1] https://blog.ycombinator.com/two-hn-announcements/

[2] https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1282055086433284103

Re:A Better Crystal Ball? by dang on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:06PM (#24795899)
I don't want to ban you! I'd rather try to persuade you to make your points without sharp elbows. Others also do bad things (for example, I can see how https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24772044 was a provocation) - but that it doesn't make it ok to escalate; we just get a downward spiral that way. Rather, we each need to spend the energy and time needed not to escalate. That creates capacity to then respond neutrally with good points. This strengthens the commons rather than damaging it—and as a bonus, your comments become more persuasive.

"Free speech" means different things to different people and depending on what one wants, there are different tradeoffs. On HN, we're trying to optimize for interesting speech, i.e. curious conversation: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... That means we have to moderate people away from being nasty to each other. I don't think that's "intolerance of free speech", because HN's guidelines leave lots of room for arguing most views.

pg had a much lower threshold for banning people than we do, FWIW.

If you're not persuaded, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24620683 is an explanation I wrote recently which makes the same points I'm trying to make here and gives more examples. It also links to other comments on the same. The point is that smart people often come here with a combative model of how to do intellectual discussion that actually works well in smaller, more cohesive communities. The reason we don't allow it here is not because we think it's bad in itself, but because it doesn't translate well into HN's context—here it's just a recipe for tedious flamewar.