News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by davorak on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:51PM (#24757211)
> Sure enough, plenty of well-reasoned critiques exist from Jewish groups, Noam Chomsky (hardly an anti-Semite), Christopher Hitchens, and others.

Are these armchair critiques? Or are these people/groups putting in serious effort to change things? That indirectly indicates their priority for the issue for them.

Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by saas_sam on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:11PM (#24757491)
Your comment is strange...

1. ephimetheus: The only people who have a problem with these laws are bad people with evil intent

2. me: I just looked and there are a lot of people voicing problems with these laws who are good and have noble intent

3. you: But are they prioritizing the issue enough or are they just saying stuff?

...Uh, what is the argument you're trying to make here? That if people aren't making enough of an "effort" in some way, that their critiques should not be taken seriously? Maybe you're serious, but it sure sounds like an extreme moving of goal posts to me. Presumably I would then link to you some activist group or other pushing to change these laws -- I expect you'd then come back with some variation of "oh well, that's not really trying /hard enough/, look at all the /other things/ they care about more." Just... very strange.

If you don't think sticking your neck out as a prominent intellectual like Chomsky or Hitchens to defend neo-nazi's right to lie in the public square.. if you don't think that constitutes a "serious effort" in and of itself, then YES I guess you can go further and look at Human Rights Watch's statements or whatever else.

I doubt you will. But maybe other readers of this exchange will leave better for reading my comment here.

Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by davorak on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @11:00PM (#24772702)
> ...Uh, what is the argument you're trying to make here?

That if they are not putting in some serious effort then "That indirectly indicates their priority for the issue for them."

Seeing how I am uninformed on what they have said as of yet I was interested in getting insight into their position and priorities.

> That if people aren't making enough of an "effort" in some way, that their critiques should not be taken seriously?

They have to prioritize, there is nothing wrong with that. I have to prioritize too. Knowing their priorities is useful information while evaluating their critiques.

> If you don't think sticking your neck out as a prominent intellectual like Chomsky or Hitchens to defend neo-nazi's right to lie in the public square.

There is definitely a difference between writing a critique and working consistently towards changing a law. It has no bearing on the seriousness of their crtique, but it does on the seriousness of their commitment and priorities.

Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by ephimetheus on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:50PM (#24758692)
Not sure what you dug up, but I’m not aware of anyone with an interest other than proving “see, we weren’t the bad guys”. Since the Holocaust is a historical fact, historians without revisionist goals have no reason to debate its existence. Research into the extent and details of the Holocaust are perfectly acceptable. Side not, the absolute vast majority of German society is on board with this limit of freedom of speech. It’s part of the constitution even.
Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by raxxorrax on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @05:18AM (#24763727)
You fail to make the distinction in holding the opinion and allowing people to have the opinion. I would a tiny minority of people complaining about speech restrictions hold the opinion or even want to make it socially acceptable.

Most just argue that people themselves should be the ones to cast the judgement, not Facebook. These are very basic comprehension issues and your insinuation on those that disagree are fairly similar to reasoning you see in plain fascism.

Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by ephimetheus on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:09AM (#24765208)
I’m very much able to make the distinction, but there are opinions so vile they can’t be tolerated. That’s just a fact.

The line is also pretty clear, at least as far as the German law is concerned, so the danger (see slippery slope argument) is well worth the risk. The slippery slope argument is more applicable the other way round: if you tolerate this, it normalizes or rationalizes the Holocaust, and that’s the first step towards another genocide.

Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by saas_sam on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:01PM (#24758810)
There are several examples under "Commentary" section on the Wikipedia article. This isn't hard, I don't see how you can dig your heels in on this. You really CANNOT fathom how someone would be against strict speech laws for good reasons? Outside your imagination entirely? Come on. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legality_of_Holocaust_denial
Re:Removing Holocaust Denial Content by ephimetheus on Monday October 12, 2020 @04:22PM (#24759039)
I should have added “in Germany”. Of course it’s not outside my imagination, but I think the idea that freedoms without limits should exist is super misguided and one of the central flaws of American democracy.

It’s like allowing someone to claim something that is an absolute fact like the existence of the sun was a lie. But that’s ok because it doesn’t invalidate the unspeakable suffering of millions at the hands of industrialized slaughterers.

That’s also why the slippery slope doesn’t apply. The line is clear as can be.