News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:36PM (#24756239)
We are building this: https://www.exodusorbitals.com

Feel free to ask questions

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by shanxS on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:40PM (#24756307)
Apart from science experiments and taking pictures, how can this platform be used to deliver business value?
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:01PM (#24756570)
There is a number of applications in development that will rely on in-space processing. Such as forest fire prediction, business intelligence from space (estimate the crop yields, oil reservoir levels, city planning and so on). Most of them use ML algorithms to extract valuable insights.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by Sanzig on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:40PM (#24757057)
I remain skeptical as to the broad applicability of this approach. Some amount of preprocessing on on the space segment is valuable for certain mission types, but I don't know how generalizable it is.

By doing all your processing on the space segment you have eliminated the possibility for analysts to take the level zero / level one products and reprocess them manually, either for quality assurance purposes or to develop enhanced or entirely new capabilities with the data.

The other main problem I have with satellite-as-a-service type approaches is that it requires building generic spacecraft hardware by necessity, which means that you'll never be optimized for a particular mission type. When you build a mission from scratch, you get to carefully specify sensor parameters to achieve your remote sensing objective. Not so much when you're trying to build a generic bird that does everything. For most applications that benefit from generic data, what's the advantage over, say, downloading data from Copernicus (which already has pole to pole coverage at moderate resolution and revisit) or tasking a DigitalGlobe satellite to do the work?

I can think of some edge cases where realtime calls might be valuable (eg: dynamic re-tasking based on realtime image analysis, especially if you have a wide-view forward squinted sensor and a higher resolution nadir sensor), but I really don't see the broad applicability.

It's true that communications is definitely a bottleneck in high resolution wide-coverage missions, but there are other intermediate approaches that work before going all the way to doing the entirety of the processing including decisionmaking on the space segment. We have a lot of room to grow in the comms space, such as moving EO missions to Ka-band (and above) and free-space laser for missions without stringent data latency requirements. Sure, it's a crowded world if you're doing X-band from an isoflux antenna, but there's other architectural options to improve throughout. We can also look at doing selective preprocessing on the space segment (ie: up to Level 1 products) which may allow for better data compression.

I'm not saying there isn't room for space segment processing and dynamic tasking - I saw a really interesting mission proposal a while back that used it extensively. But I don't see the business case for it on generic satellites in all but particularly niche cases.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:55PM (#24757274)
Well, that deserves a reply beyond the HN comment format. ESA hosted an event, called Phi Week, presenting many possible application cases in Earth Observation domain: https://livestream.com/esa/phiweek2020

If you don’t want to filter through 20 hours of videos, drop me an email to [email protected], I can send you a written summary. And some documents on our platform capabilities.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by lozaning on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:24PM (#24756843)
Is bandwidth from outer space so expensive that you save money by moving compute to the edge and only pushing down results to earth instead of the entire data set?
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:33PM (#24756955)
The bandwidth is not expensive. There is simply a lack of it.

Most LEO satellites have 10-20 minutes a day communications window assuming single ground station. Amount of data you can download from a single pass is a tens or hundreds megabytes per day. One high-resolution camera image can be easily over 10MB.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by portyllo on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:23PM (#24759596)
There is plenty of bandwidth to achieve more than 1 Gbps of throughput from a 3-U cubesat (see Planet with their latest X-band comms-system [1], which results in more than 50 GB per pass). If you really need more than that, new free space optical communications systems under-development will bring multi-Gbps to small-sats [2]. For me, the real problem with nanosats is that they generate barely no power and they are really volume-constrained compared to the bigger birds (so you cannot have high-resolution sensors, and cannot fit in there a good optical-comms system, you need to be mindful of your power consumption all time during the mission...).

Finally, note that nowadays Planet downloads 10 TB/day, and they could go up to 40 TB/day once they upgrade their fleet with the latest X-band antenna, which is comparable to the 80 TB/day that DigitalGlobe generates.

[1] https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=4... [2] https://www.tesat.de/images/tesat/products/TOSIRIS_Data-Shee...

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by lozaning on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:40PM (#24757054)
Very interesting, thanks for the follow up.

Would this issue be any way relieved with things like AWS ground station?

If you can only see a ground station from a satellite for 20 minutes, could you just add more ground stations?

Or is that 20 minutes window constrained by something other than having a ground station within receiving range?

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:57PM (#24757296)
More ground stations will definitely make things better, but 24/7 connectivity to assets in LEO will take monumental, Starlink-scale level of effort.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by portillo on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:35AM (#24762876)
You can get 24/7 connectivity to LEO right now (and 25 years ago too) using TDRSS.

The system costs a fraction of what Starlink will cost, as you only need 3 GEO satellites.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by chinathrow on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:07PM (#24758188)
Would it be possible to use Starlink for comms if a sat is flying in a lower position?
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @03:22PM (#24758365)
In theory, yes.

In practice, this will depend more on my negotiation skills when talking to Elon Musk and less on any technical challenge :)

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by portyllo on Monday October 12, 2020 @05:30PM (#24759651)
No, it will not be possible, no matter what Elon says.

Starlink operates in portions of the Ku and Ka bands that are reserved for Earth-to-space comms, not for space-to-space comms.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @06:09PM (#24760016)
My impression was that Starlink relies on inter-satellite links to route traffic. We can use the same links for our own extended network.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by portillo on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @02:32AM (#24762863)
The current satellites do not have crosslinks, and in any case, in their FCC filings SpaceX talks about optical crosslinks, not RF.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by iamgopal on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:40PM (#24756300)
Possible Application of this ? Can't satellite just be dummy sensor and all computing works happen on the ground ?
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:04PM (#24756600)
Downlink is the biggest bottleneck at the moment. Your satellite camera or SDR can produce thousand times more data than the amount you can download. You'd definitely benefit from in-space processing.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by jvanderbot on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:36PM (#24757004)
Downlink will pretty much always be the biggest constraint. You'll always want more data down than you can affordably downlink. And sensors will always produce more data.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by leptoniscool on Monday October 12, 2020 @12:53PM (#24756474)
What's the pricing structure look like?
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @01:01PM (#24756578)
"Pay per orbit model", with price range from $200 to $10K per orbit, depending on customer needs.
Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by jrumbut on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:19PM (#24757592)
How much competition is there at that price point?

To me being able to outlay such a small amount to get some space stuff done creates a situation like early PCs. They look like weak computers but you when you get some capability into so many more hands people start figuring out unexpected uses for it.

Re:Orbital edge computing: nano satellite constellations as ... by d_silin on Monday October 12, 2020 @02:24PM (#24757648)
There is no competition at this price point.

Our vision is exactly like you described, giving millions of people first-class level of access to software development platform in space.