And hazing.
Some form of the hazing seems very common for dotcom hiring right now, whether or not (as the article alludes at the start) the people who are mimicking it from elsewhere known the reasons or effects.
Eh, some would argue the opposite... (Probably hundreds or even thousands of psychologists & academic professors of psychology)
"In psychological trait theory, the Big Five personality traits, also known as the five-factor model (FFM) and the OCEAN model, is a suggested taxonomy, or grouping, for personality traits,[1] developed from the 1980s onwards."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Five_personality_traits
"Abstract We demonstrate that Big-Five personality traits are stable for working-age adults over a four-year period."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01651...
"The five-dimensional structure was robust across major regions of the world. Trait levels were related in predictable ways to self-esteem, sociosexuality, and national personality profiles."
https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/002202210629729...
"Personality was related to career success controlling for general mental ability and, though adulthood measures of the Big Five traits were more strongly related to career success than were childhood measures, both contributed unique variance in explaining career success."
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/j.1744-6570....
However I do it only so that I can potentially give a hire recommendation for a higher level with tens+ thousands/yr more compensation.
Also because I'm always just one of 6+ interviewers, and a committee of 6+ completely separate people makes the actual decision, I can't even know if the person is being hired anyways.
The article is written with this in mind, that's why there's multiple tests (coding and written!) for both "talent" and "judgement."
Intelligence isn't really very diverse, when you need people who are s-m-a-r-t smart. That means you need smart people, not half-smart differently-abled people.
Large tech companies will measure for this. From personal experience I know that Google, Facebook and Netflix all test for cross functional leadership at the senior+ level. By the time you're interviewing for senior or higher roles, only two of the six interviews are actually about coding at these companies. The rest are behavioral and system design, with specific questions used to calibrate how hands on you are and how much you're used to working with many teams effectively in a large org.
Oh, you have a better way to measure g?
Just a few things I disagree with:
- 'Talent', as it is defined in the article, is not the most important factor in most jobs (though granted he writes that this article doesn't apply to most jobs)
- IQ is not a good measure for intelligence. Intelligence is way too diverse to be broken down into a linear scale, even when it comes to just engineering or 'talent', as he calls it here.
- Personality is way more important than he makes it out to be. It can't just be broken down into 3-5 factors. This isn't a scientific process. In my experience, this is where most of the value of personal interviews is.
- I found the last section disgusting to read. He's advocating for manipulating the candidate into accepting the job by asking successively harder questions, even though you've already made up your mind. What a great start to your business relationship. And then justifies this by saying that 'people want to suffer'. This is almost like negging in romantic relationships. Just awful.
Slava, if you're reading this, I'm disappointed. I respected you for your experience and your writing but this is making me quite sad.
EDIT: As lots of people have written here in the comments: On a second read, I agree this could indeed be satire. If so, well played Slava, well played!
I don't think so though, unfortunately. This is what the 'everything is measurable and science has all the answers' mentality brings, if taken to an extreme. These days, science, data-driven approaches and 'measure everything' are more religion than anything else. Even if this article is satire, I think there's enough people out there that think this way.